Photo essay ‘States of Decay’ about urban blight fails to prove political point

photo essay states of decay about urban blight fails to prove political point daniel marbaix barter 4

“If America is the Roman Empire of our time, then New York City is Rome. The pulsating heart of the West pumps greenbacks through the veins of Manhattan, the richest place in the world. Power emanates from its corporate brains and financial muscle across the whole surface of the globe. So how is it that even in the body of America, land of eternal youth, there is failure, death and decay hidden just beneath its glossy surfaces?”

So reads the description for States of Decay, a recently released and hardcover-bound 160-page extended photo essay featuring the photography of urban adventurers who captured the imagery throughout the Northeastern United States, offering a look inside generally off-limits but long-since-abandoned locales like hospitals, asylums, schools, and cathedrals.

And if that description should clue the reader into anything, it is that editors/photographers Daniel Barter and Daniel Marbaix intend the book’s title – States of Decay – to carry two meanings, serving as both a reflection of the pictured facilities’ general state of disrepair and the connection the book attempts to draw to what those abandoned structures say about the state of the country.

But to say the book is reaching for its message is an understatement. And its failures start with the imagery itself.

While the photographs are appropriately bleak and beautifully shot, the lack of variation in the style of the photographs already starts to feel mundane by the end of the first quarter of the book – States of Decay is divided into four sections, with text attempting to add context to urban exploration and the book’s forced message. And the photos lack a certain depth, so viewers won’t feel the desire to sit and look for every small detail in a photo, though most of the detail is usually the same peeling paint and rust.

But the bigger problem lies in the book’s political message, which – despite its description as a “visual poem” that allows readers to draw their own conclusions from the images – pushes readers toward a particular way of thinking when drawing parallels to the fall of Rome and generally taking a harsh stance against wealth, in and of itself, almost drawing a sick pleasure from the demise of the structures its images capture.

The odd thing is that while the photographs spanning from New York City to the country’s Rust Belt include industrial sites like power plants, steel mills, factories, hotels, and blast furnaces, the primary focus of this release from publisher Carpet Bombing Culture is – and the bulk of its imagery comes from – hospitals, asylums, schools and cathedrals. All of which – maybe save for the last, depending on where the skeptical reader’s religious beliefs lie – are institutions that were designed to help people. 

These facilities aren’t simply monuments to man, symbols of excessive American opulence and frivolous displays of wealth, but rather institutions – as large, abandoned and degraded as they may be – that were designed with others in mind. So the book’s message seems misguided, or at the very least is using the wrong arguments to make its point. More inexcusable, though, is that States of Decay is a book about photography, the images of which are simply boring.

(Copyright images via Daniel Marbaix and Daniel Barter)

The views expressed here are solely those of the author and do not reflect the beliefs of Digital Trends.

Home Theater

Budget TVs are finally worth buying, and you can thank Roku

Not all that long ago, budget TVs were only worth looking at if, well, you were on a budget. Thanks to Roku, not only are budget TVs now a viable option for anyone, but they might even be a better buy than more expensive TVs.
Computing

Looking for an Apple MacBook below $900? Woot has you covered

If you're looking for a great deal on an Apple MacBook, then Amazon's Woot may just have what you have been seeking. It has Macbooks available for only $810 with Intel M3 CPUs, 8GB of RAM, and 256GB SSDs.
Computing

Is your PC slow? Here's how to restore Windows 10 to factory settings

Computers rarely work as well after they accumulate files and misconfigure settings. Thankfully, with this guide, you'll be able to restore your PC to its original state by learning how to factory reset Windows.
Movies & TV

'Prime'-time TV: Here are the best shows on Amazon Prime right now

There's more to Amazon Prime than free two-day shipping, including access to a number of phenomenal shows at no extra cost. To make the sifting easier, here are our favorite shows currently streaming on Amazon Prime.
Movies & TV

The best shows on Netflix, from 'Haunting of Hill House’ to ‘Twilight Zone’

Looking for a new show to binge? Lucky for you, we've curated a list of the best shows on Netflix, whether you're a fan of outlandish anime, dramatic period pieces, or shows that leave you questioning what lies beyond.
Mobile

Smartphone makers are vomiting a torrent of new phones, and we’re sick of it

Smartphone manufacturers like Huawei, LG, Sony, and Motorola are releasing far too many similar phones. The update cycle has accelerated, but more choice is not always a good thing.
Home Theater

The Apple AirPods 2 needed to come out today. Here are four reasons why

Apple announced numerous new products at its October 30 event, a lineup that included a new iPad Pro, a MacBook Air, as well as a new Mac Mini. Here are four reasons we wish a new set of AirPods were on that list.
Opinion

Do we even need 5G at all?

Faster phones, easier access to on-demand video, simpler networking -- on the surface, 5G sounds like a dream. So why is it more of a nightmare?
Computing

Razer’s most basic Blade 15 is the one most gamers should buy

Razer's Blade 15 is an awesome laptop for both gamers, streamers, professionals, and anyone else needing serious go in a slim profile, but its price is out of reach for many games. The new Blade 15 Base solves that problem with few…
Gaming

Going to hell, again. The Switch makes 'Diablo 3' feel brand-new

I've played every version of Diablo 3 released since 2012, racking up hundreds of hours in the process. Six years later, I'm playing it yet again on Nintendo Switch. Somehow, it still feels fresh.
Gaming

‘Fallout 76’ may have online multiplayer but it’s still a desolate wasteland

"Is Fallout 76 an MMO?" That depends on who you ask. Critics and players often cite its online multiplayer capabilities as a reason it qualifies. Yet calling the game an MMO only confuses matters, and takes away from what could make…
Digital Trends Live

Microsoft has #*!@ed up to-do lists on an epic scale

Microsoft has mucked up to-do lists on a scale you simply can’t imagine, a failure that spans multiple products and teams, like a lil’ bit of salmonella that contaminates the entire output from a factory.
Opinion

As Amazon turns up the volume on streaming, Spotify should shudder

Multiple players are all looking to capitalize on the popularity of streaming, but it has thus far proved nearly impossible to make a profit. Could major tech companies like Amazon be primed for a streaming take-over?
Gaming

Throw out the sandbox. ‘Red Dead Redemption 2’ is a fully realized western world

Despite featuring around 100 story missions, the real destination in Red Dead Redemption 2 is the journey you make for yourself in the Rockstar's open world, and the game is better for it.