Skip to main content

Facebook manipulated more than 600,000 users’ News Feeds to study people’s emotions

It’s possible that you were just involved in a massive psychological experiment — but don’t worry, nobody else knew about it either.

According to a study recently published in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences (PNAS), data scientists for Facebook tweaked the News Feed algorithms for 689,003 users, manipulating the types of posts they saw on a daily basis.  For one week in 2012, the algorithm filtered a disproportionately low number of either positive or negative posts on the users’ feeds.

The point was to see if emotions could be transferred virtually, just as they are transferred in face-to-face interactions. And sure enough, the scientists found that people who saw fewer positive posts on their News Feeds created fewer positive posts themselves.  Conversely, the fewer negative posts people saw, the more positive they became online.

“Emotional states can be transferred to others via emotional contagion, leading people to experience the same emotions without their awareness,” wrote study authors Adam Kramer, Jamie Guillory, and Jeffrey Hancock. “We provide experimental evidence that emotional contagion occurs without direct interaction between people (exposure to a friend expressing an emotion is sufficient), and in the complete absence of nonverbal cues.”

But the creepy part of the whole thing? None of these Facebook users were aware their News Feeds were being manipulated.  It also means that an algorithm was perfectly capable of messing with people’s emotions for a whole week.

However, the study is covered under the Facebook Data Use Policy, which users must agree to before signing up for the site’s service.  The policy gives the company the right to access and use information people post to the social media site, and according to A.V. Club, the policy also lists a number of potential uses for this data, “including troubleshooting, data analysis, testing, research and service improvement.”

So if you felt depressed for one week back in 2012 without knowing why, that mystery may have just been solved.

[Image courtesy of Gil C/Shutterstock]

Editors' Recommendations

Loren Grush
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Loren Grush is a science and health writer living in New York City, having written for Fox News Health, Fox News SciTech and…
Split Facebook News Feed doesn’t decrease fake news, report says
facebook, facebook local news

As Facebook gears up for another News Feed algorithm change, a new report suggests tests of the platforms earlier algorithm tests aren’t going as planned. In the fall, Facebook began testing a split News Feed, with posts from friends in one location and posts from news publications in another. Now, months into the test, a New York Times report suggests the split design not only brought less views for news, but inadvertently promoted fake news. The report offers some insight into potential pitfalls for the algorithm changes Facebook is planning to roll out in the next few months.

The split feed is only a test and at the time Facebook first shared the test, the company didn’t yet have plans to bring the setup worldwide. The tests, running in Sri Lanka, Bolivia, Slovakia, Serbia, Guatemala, and Cambodia, place all the posts from publishers such as news companies inside a new Explore section, requiring users to navigate outside the News Feed to see the posts unless they are shared by a friend.

Read more
Facebook plans major news feed changes ‘to improve your well-being’
Crisis Response Hub

Facebook is gearing up to make some major changes to your news feed.

The planned changes, which focus on reducing the number of public posts from businesses, brands, and media, were outlined on Thursday in a personal message from Facebook boss Mark Zuckerberg.

Read more
Your Facebook News Feed will soon rank faster loading websites higher
Facebook News Feed

In order to make the browsing experience more enjoyable on your News Feed, Facebook announced it is rolling out an update within the upcoming months. The mobile app will show users more stories that load quickly, pushing ones that may take longer further down in your feed -- giving you relevant content that you will spend time reading.

This update will help Facebook zone in on a variety of different factors when someone clicks on any link in the News Feed through a mobile device. This includes the estimated load time of and general speed of the website, along with your current network connection. If signals show the website will load quickly, that link will appear higher in your feed and bury those that are slower.

Read more