The truth about fitness trackers is that the buck stops with you

fitbit-aria-black
As fitness trackers and wearables become ubiquitous, it seems we have to lay down some ground rules to manage expectations once and for all. Fitbit is not a nutritionist, neither is Withings, Misfit, or Jawbone. Every so often, a story pops up accusing Fitbit and its ilk for its users’ weight gain. This is akin to blaming turn-by-turn directions for making you drive off of a cliff.

Occasionally, a fitness tracker is wrong. Either it may miscount steps, miscalculate heart rate, or may recommend a calorie count that users claimed as too high, since they gained weight adhering to it. With the exception of the heart rate cases, the assertion is that a slight inaccuracy of a given device can end up screwing users over in the long run. Fitbit, with its customizable calorie goals, is taking a good deal of the heat for this simply because it holds a lion share of the fitness tracker band market.

Of course every company strives to be as accurate as possible, but no tracker is 100% accurate. That said, while gross inaccuracies make a tracker unusable, a report that’s off a few steps or calories isn’t going to make or break a successful workout plan. It’s how people choose to act on the information that’s at issue here.

“There are huge differences in individual circumstances,” certified nutritionist and founder of Food Coach NYC Dana James told Today. “If your gut bacteria is full of bad bacteria, you can eat 30 percent fewer calories, exercise 30 percent harder, and gain 30 percent more than someone with the right microbial makeup.”

Hence, these devices are called “fitness” trackers instead of “weight loss” trackers. Apps like My Fitness Pal as well as gear with its own infrastructure, such as Fitbit’s wearables, are great at some things, like tracking your workouts and recording what you eat. Unfortunately, at the opening of 2016 they’re still not going to give you the same kind of insight and accuracy you’re likely to get from a visit to a personal trainer or doctor.

One of the most highly publicized posts that kick-started this misdirection “The Case of the Fitbit Defying Metabolism” was originally written three years ago. Since then, the writer has not only continued to use Fitbit, but has refuted any assertions that trackers should be vilified. The author Jessica Reed said, “I don’t feel lied to by the band around my wrist, only by the notion that weight control is simple.”

The fitness tracker and wearable markets are only projected to grow in the coming years, and it’s up to us as a society to use this technology responsibly and logically. Even after we have an app that can test your gut biome at home, the best advice experts have is to make smart choices about your diet in conjunction with info from a tracker. Calorie counting can help, but monitoring calorie content helps more.

Margaret Wertheim, nutritionist and registered dietician said, “If a person is drinking sweetened beverages or some of the coffee drinks like chai tea lattes, those calories aren’t going to allow them to lose the weight they want.”

Now for some enterprising designer to make an accurate kit with an app to test your gut biome at home.

Emerging Tech

Awesome Tech You Can’t Buy Yet: Pocket-sized drones and anti-road-rage displays

Check out our roundup of the best new crowdfunding projects and product announcements that hit the web this week. You may not be able to buy this stuff yet, but it's fun to gawk!
Deals

Fitbit Versa and Samsung Gear fitness smartwatches get big Amazon price cuts

Some of the best options can get pretty pricey, but with smartwatch discounts on the Fitbit Versa and Samsung Gear Sport, they are really quite affordable right now. You can save up to $125 on a new fitness watch.
Product Review

Samsung's $99 fitness tracker takes on Fitbit. Can it keep pace?

Samsung’s going toe-to-toe against Fitbit’s Inspire HR with its own $99 fitness tracker -- the Galaxy Fit. It also has a heart rate monitor, can automatically detect six workouts, and has a battery that can last for days.
Deals

Make some time for the best smartwatch deals for June 2019

Smartwatches make life easier by sending alerts right on your wrist. Many also provide fitness-tracking features. If you're ready to take the plunge into wearables and want to save money, here are the best smartwatch deals for June 2019.
Deals

It’s time to check out the best Apple Watch deals for June 2019

The Apple Watch has surged to prominence in recent years. If you're in the market for an iOS wearable, we've sniffed out the best Apple Watch deals available right now for all three models of this great smartwatch.
Smart Home

Turn to tech to get a good night's sleep with one of the best sleep trackers

There are a handful of different ways you can leverage today's tech to get a good night's sleep. Here, we've rounded up six of the best sleep trackers, whether you prefer a bedside solution or one tailor-made for your mattress.
Deals

The GoPro Hero7 action camera gets price cut on Amazon ahead of Father’s Day

Got an adventurous Dad? If so, a GoPro action camera will make a great Father’s Day gifts. Ahead of Father’s Day, capture the GoPro Hero7 Black on Amazon for just $329, down from its normal $400. Don't just settle for socks again this…
Deals

Before buying an Apple Watch, check out this cheap smartwatch under $100

Not looking to spend hundreds of dollars on a smartwatch? You might want to consider this little-known but well-reviewed cheap smartwatch from Amazfit called the Bip. It's on sale on Amazon, and you can have it in one day if you're a Prime…
Home Theater

The best Apple AirPod accessories can extend your high-end earbuds' life span

It might seem a bit strange to buy an accessory for an accessory, but sometimes you need a little something extra, like a case, cover, or transmitter, to get the most out of your Apple AirPods.
Deals

The Apple Watch Series 4 is still at its lowest price for Father’s Day

Sales are continuing on select Apple Watch at both Amazon and Walmart through Father's Day, including a deal on the 38mm Series 3 GPS that is one of the lowest prices we've seen yet, and the new and slightly larger 40mm Series 4.
Wearables

Exclusive: This is Mobvoi’s next Wear OS smartwatch, and it likely adds 4G LTE

Mobvoi may not be a household name in the U.S., but it sells affordable smartwatches running Google's Wear OS platform. The company's next watch has leaked -- by Mobvoi itself -- and Digital Trends managed to snap a screenshot.
Emerging Tech

This lifesaving wearable could diagnose strokes more accurately

A new breakthrough wearable device uses two light measurement techniques to track the body's blood circulation — and accurately predict deadly strokes in the process. Here's how it works.
Wearables

Samsung's $99 Galaxy Fit fitness tracker is now available in the U.S.

Looking for a new fitness buddy? Samsung just launched the Galaxy Watch Active and the Galaxy Fit, two new wearables with a raft of fitness-focused features that'll keep you moving and get you down to the gym.
Home Theater

Diagnose and fix some common Apple AirPods problems with our handy guide

Apple’s AirPods are among the best fully wireless earbuds we’ve seen, but they’re not perfect. If you’re having trouble, take a look at our guide to the most common problems and what you can do to fix them.