Skip to main content

Google secures appeal victories in Japanese ‘right to be forgotten’ cases

Ken Wolter/123RF
Google has scored a significant legal victory in Japan that mirrored the right to be forgotten rules in Europe.

At the center of the dispute in Japan were several cases taken against Google over search results and Google Maps where allegedly defamatory comments made about businesses.

In one of the cases a medical clinic had received negative comments on the mapping service. The clinic believed the comments to be defamatory and in April 2015 the Chiba District Court ruled that the remarks must be removed.

Google appealed the ruling and this week had its way with the court finding that the various comments made on Maps were legitimate customer gripes and did not defame anyone and any business.

In another case, the Supreme Court of Japan ruled against a man that was arrested on child prostitution charges who had demanded that Google remove search results that led to stories about his charges.

The court ruled that the man had no right to removal under these circumstances as the public had a right to know. “The deletion [of the results] can be allowed only when the value of privacy protection significantly outweighs that of information disclosure,” said the judge presiding over the case.

“We are pleased that the Supreme Court has unanimously recognized, based on existing privacy and defamation laws, that any decision to delete information from search results should prioritize the public’s right to information,” said Taj Meadows, Google Asia-Pacific’s head of policy communications.

The cases in Japan had drawn comparisons to the EU’s right to be forgotten, a regulation that allows individuals to request search results pertaining to themselves be removed from Google. The request only removes the link to the story but would make the information harder to find. The rules have become rather contentious, with Google and lawmakers jostling over the right to privacy and what’s in the public interest.

In Japan, things were a little different as while some of the cases were about individuals, businesses had attempted to use these legal mechanisms to scrub negative customer reviews from the web.

Editors' Recommendations

Jonathan Keane
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Jonathan is a freelance technology journalist living in Dublin, Ireland. He's previously written for publications and sites…
Former Google exec says the tech giant doesn’t prioritize human rights
Google's Logo

A former Google executive is speaking out against the tech giant, saying that he was ultimately let go for trying to create an internal human rights program. 

Ross LaJeunesse told The Washington Post that he was let go from the company in April 2019. His former title was Google’s global head of international relations in Washington, D.C. LaJeunesse was in charge of creating a plan to protect human rights in China, mainly free expression and privacy. He told the Post he wanted a similar human rights program for the company’s internal processes but had his idea repeatedly shut down.

Read more
Why wait? You can download the Google Stadia Android app right now
google stadia vs nvidia geforce now controller  1

Google Stadia doesn't officially launch until November 19, and when the streaming service does launch, its mobile compatibility will be limited to a selection of Google Pixel devices. If you happen to own one of those devices, however, you can install the official Android app right now and prepare to play your favorite games on the go.

There isn't much you can actually do with the official Stadia app yet, but you can download it for free to Google Pixel 2 devices and up, provided they are running Android 6.0 or later. The app will also work on the Chrome OS tablets like the Pixel Slate, HP Chromebook X2, and Acer Chromebook Tab 10, if you want to play on a bigger screen while you're traveling.

Read more
How to turn on the futuristic RCS messaging in Google Messages right now
Google promo image for RCS.

SMS messages are old and boring -- RCS messaging is the future. For the uninitiated, RCS messaging -- short for "rich communication services" -- turns your phone's standard text messaging app into a chat service like WhatsApp or Facebook Messenger. That means real-time typing indications, group chats, audio and video messages, and even interactive content.

Sounds pretty great, doesn't it? Well, it is. Unfortunately, it's not here yet. While RCS messaging is rolling out, it's not arriving quickly -- and that's because it's reliant on each carrier turning the service on. While those on Google Fi can already enjoy RCS messaging, if you're on another major U.S. carrier, you'll have to wait until the switch is flipped by each company in turn.

Read more