Nokia Sues LG, Samsung, Others over LCD Pricing

By Geoff Duncan December 1, 2009

Finland’s Nokia, still the world’s largest maker of mobile handsets, has filed suit against South Korean electronics giants Samsung and LG claiming the companies conspired to keep prices for LCD displays artificially high and reap profits. According to Bloomberg, the suit was filed on November 25th in a San Francisco federal court and is based on both U.S. federal law and California state law; the suit claims LCD display makers unlawfully colluded to inflate the prices of LCD displays above the level they would have sold for in a competitive market. Nokia wants the court to order to stop to the price fixing, as well as unspecified damages.

Nokia N900 — Image used with permission by copyright holder

Other companies named in Nokia’s suit include Hitachi, Sharp and Chunghwa Picture Tubes. Nokia’s lawsuit follows on the heels of a similar lawsuit brought against many of the same companies by AT&&T, also in regard to LCD price fixing. Both suits rely on a U.S. Justice Department investigation of price fixing in the LCD market that saw Hitachi, LG, Chunghwa, and Sharp plead guilty to pricing fixing and agreeing to pay almost $600 million in criminal fines. Executives from some of the companies even landed jail time.

Nokia has apparently also filed a similar suit in the United Kingdom.

The U.S. Justice Department investigation primarily centered in LCD displays used in notebook computers, with companies harmed by the collusion including computer makers like Dell and Apple. The new allegations seem to focus on smaller displayed used in mobile phones and portable media players.

Editors' Recommendations

Topics

LG
Samsung

Former Digital Trends Contributor

Geoff Duncan writes, programs, edits, plays music, and delights in making software misbehave. He's probably the only member…

Mobile

Samsung may have a price shocker for the Galaxy S24 series

An alleged photo of the Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra.

The much-anticipated reveal of the Samsung Galaxy S24 series is just a few weeks away, and excitement is building as rumors swirl around the Galaxy S24, Galaxy S24 Plus, and Galaxy S24 Ultra. Many interesting details about the new models' appearance and potential features have emerged. However, a critical piece of information has been missing until recently: the price of these handsets.

GalaxyClub says the Galaxy S24 and Galaxy S24 Plus could arrive at cheaper prices than their S23 counterparts in the EU. However, the Galaxy S24 Ultra could see a price hike compared to the Galaxy S23 Ultra.
The Galaxy S24 is getting ... cheaper?

Mobile

Apple AirTag, Samsung Galaxy SmartTag2, Tile Mate prices slashed

Person holding an Apple AirTag.

If you're always losing and misplacing stuff, you may want to invest in Bluetooth trackers. These handy devices can be placed or attached to any object -- and even held by people or pets! If you think they'll be very useful for you, there are three options with discounts right now from Amazon -- the Tile Mate for $18, down $7 from $25; the Samsung Galaxy SmartTag2 for $20, down $10 from $30; and the Apple AirTag for $27, down $2 from $29. You're going to have to hurry if you want to take advantage of any of these offers though, especially if you're planning to buy multiples, because they may expire at any moment.
Tile Mate --
Samsung Galaxy SmartTag2 --
Apple AirTag --

Tile Mate -- $18, was $25

Mobile

Samsung Galaxy Z Flip 5 price: here’s exactly how much it costs

Calender widget on the cover screen on the Samsung Galaxy Z Flip 5.

Samsung just held its latest Galaxy Unpacked event in Seoul, South Korea, and it had a whole slew of new products to unveil to the masses. We have three new Galaxy Tab S9 tablets, the Galaxy Watch 6 series, the Galaxy Z Fold 5, and the Galaxy Z Flip 5.

The Galaxy Z Flip 5 is sure to impress with an all-new 3.4-inch cover display that Samsung has called the "Flex Window." You can access some new widgets from the Flex Window, including a multi-widget view for more at once, and even run apps on the cover display (with some caveats). The Z Flip 5 also has a new Flex Hinge that looks aesthetically pleasing and provides a solid foldable experience. The cameras are also slightly better, with a new lens coating that should cut down on unwanted lens flares.