Skip to main content

Suit: Windows Phones tracking users without consent

Image used with permission by copyright holder

In an echo of recent gaffes involving Android and iOS devices keeping tracking users’ locations, a Michigan woman has filed a potential class action lawsuit in U.S. District Court in Seattle alleging that Microsoft’s Windows Phone 7 operating system gathers data from mobile phone users even after they’ve opted out of location-reporting. Moreover, the suit claims that Microsoft lied to Congress about the extent of location information it collects.

The plaintiff, Rebecca Cousineau, alleges that the Windows Phone 7 camera application continues to record and share GPS location information with Microsoft even after a user opts out of granting Microsoft access to their location data. The suit is seeking class action status, although doesn’t make a specific claim for damages.

Microsoft has not responded to the suit, but is expected to fight the charges.

The complaint alleges that, like the out-of-control location logging feature revealed (and fixed) earlier this year in Apple’s iOS mobile operating system, Microsoft is collecting location and network information from Windows Phone devices to create a “digital map” of cell towers, Wi-Fi hotspots, and other information that can be used with assisted GPS technology. The suit maintains Microsoft’s goal with this map is not so much to provide location-based services to consumers, but to create a targeted marketing system that can tailor ads to a user’s specific location.

“Faced with the expensive and laborious task of collecting this information, Microsoft has elected to gather instead the necessary geolocation information through its customers’ mobile devices,” wrote Kim Stephens of the Seattle law firm Tousley Brain Stephens, which is handling the case. “In this way, Microsoft uses its customers as a virtual army of surveyors who constantly gather and transmit the geolocation information.”

Microsoft has asserted both to customers and the U.S. Congress that the company polls for nearby Wi-Fi access points only when a user has specifically permitted an application to access location services, and that application in turn specifically requests location information. In the case of the camera app, the suit alleges Microsoft continues to poll and collect that information even after a user has opted out.

The suit follows on revelations last month that Microsoft was publicly publishing location information on WiFi-connected devices via its live.com location database, potentially enabling any Internet user to determine the location of specific devices.

[Image: David Parry/PA Wire]

Editors' Recommendations

Geoff Duncan
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Geoff Duncan writes, programs, edits, plays music, and delights in making software misbehave. He's probably the only member…
I review phones for a living — here are the 10 apps I can’t live without
iPhone 14 Pro with custom home screen on Mickey Mouse phone holder next to flowers

For most of my life, I think I’ve had a pretty unique career path among my family and friends. Ever since I got the original iPhone, I’ve turned my love for writing into writing about technology, specifically mobile phones. Though I’ve pretty much been iPhone-only for most of my career, since I started at Digital Trends, I’ve been opening up to the world of Android.

Now that I’m checking out both iPhone and Android phones, the world of apps for me has expanded quite a bit. But regardless of what device I’m using, there are some apps that I need before anything else. Here are the first apps that I install when I get a new phone.
1Password (iOS and Android)

Read more
This Galaxy S23 Ultra case gives Samsung users a huge iPhone 14 feature
A person holding the Samsung Galaxy S23 Ultra.

Samsung has finally revealed the next generation of Galaxy smartphones: the Galaxy S23, S23 Plus, and S23 Ultra. Though you can preorder the Galaxy S23 right now, the phones won’t be shipping until February 17, 2023. But you can always start prepping for your shiny new toy by picking up some of the best Galaxy S23 cases and S23 screen protectors right now.

I did notice one interesting case from Spigen, one of the more well-known and popular case makers with plenty of affordable offerings. I’m specifically pointing out the Spigen Ultra Hybrid OneTap MagSafe Ring case for the S23 Ultra. I’m not sure why this case is only for the Ultra and not the regular S23 or S23 Plus, but it is doing something that I wish all case manufacturers would do — for both Android and iPhone. And, yes, it's one of the best Galaxy S23 Ultra cases on the market.
Bringing the iPhone's best feature to the S23 Ultra

Read more
The 11 best gifts for iPhone users you need to buy this year
A variety of Sanrio and Care Bears Sonix iPhone 13 Pro cases

The holiday season is quickly approaching, and you know what that means: gifts, gifts, and more gifts! While it’s always great to be on the receiving end of gift giving, it’s only fair that you reciprocate, too.

If someone you know is an avid Apple fan and is constantly on their iPhone, what should you gift them? Here are some of the coolest gifts you can get for iPhone users, regardless of model.
Mous iPhone case

Read more