Fisticuffs: BMW exec takes jabs at the Tesla Model S

By Davis Adams January 28, 2014

fisticuffs bmw exec takes jabs tesla model s 2014 i3 exterior front right angle — Image used with permission by copyright holder

Can’t we all just get along?

There’s no doubt that automakers have a tendency to feel a little bit of friendly rivalry between brands; after all, that’s why we call them competitive in the first place. However, as more and more electric vehicles find their way into production, it seems like the tension is especially high. This time, it’s BMW and Tesla that aren’t playing well in the sandbox.

Months back, Bloomberg reported that Tesla CEO Elon Musk mentioned that BMW had “room to improve the i3,” suggesting that the small electric car didn’t quite measure up to Tesla’s larger, more refined Model S.

BMW North America President Ludwig Willisch has returned fire, according to a recent interview with BusinessInsider. In the interview, Willisch points out that BMW’s new i3 is made of higher-strength, lighter-weight materials, from a considerably more environmentally-conscious process.

“We start off by producing carbon fiber in Moses Lake, Washington, with hydropower,” said Willisch. “Then we use fully recyclable materials to build the car. We build the car with wind power. So the whole production cycle is fully sustainable.”

Willisch also goes on to point out that the i3 maintains BMW fun-to-drive personality, for a considerably more affordable price than the Model S. After all, the BMW i3 can be had for just over $35,000 after the federal tax credit, while the cheapest Tesla still rings in at over $63,000.

Regardless of whose car is better and which one really makes the most sense to drivers today, we’re just excited to see more electric cars finding their way to the streets. For our garage, we’ll have an i3 and a Model S, and we’ll take the BMW i8 when it arrives, too, thanks.

Editors' Recommendations

Topics

Tesla

Former Digital Trends Contributor

Whether you're talking about gadgets or cars, Davis always seems to prefer "next year's models." He's a neophile to the core…

Cars

The BMW i4 is more luxurious than the Tesla Model S, and costs way less

2022 BMW i4 M50

The Tesla Model S is the original cool electric car. It did away with the concept that EVs had to be nerdy, small, low-range cars — and instead offered a sleek and stylish design, as well as a modern interior. But over the years, a ton of competition has popped up, and these days, the Model S has to go up against some seriously great cars.

Like, for example, the BMW i4.

Cars

Tesla Model 3 vs. Tesla Model Y: Bigger or cheaper?

A Tesla 3 sits parked beside an urban waterfront.

Tesla has a bit of a head start on the competition. Say what you will about panel gaps and its CEO, there's no denying that Tesla made the electric car cool -- and all in the pursuit of making them affordable enough to mass produce. And, while its lowest-priced cars aren't cheap, Tesla largely achieved that goal. The Tesla Model 3 and Model Y are its most affordable cars right now, and they offer that unmistakable Tesla design, with good battery and charging tech, plus a focus on a high-tech infotainment system.

But which of the two cars is actually better? Or, if neither is better, which is right for your needs? We put the two head-to-head.
Design
Tesla uses a relatively uniform design language across its lineup, and the result is that the Tesla Model 3 and Model Y look very similar. In fact, the Model Y looks exactly like what it is: a larger version of the Model 3.

Cars

Volkswagen ID.4 vs Tesla Model Y

volkswagen id4 vs tesla model y 2021 id 4 blue charging

The electric car world is seriously heating up, with a number of high-end electric crossovers now available, albeit still at a higher price than comparable gas-powered cars. The Tesla Model Y is one of the first of these, offering the Tesla design, a high-tech software experience, and more. But another one of the older of these models is the Volkswagen ID.4, which was first released in 2021 and also offers among the better electric car experiences out there.

Can the ID.4 compete with one of the best-selling electric cars out there? We put the two head-to-head to find out.
Design
The first thing to compare between these two cars is design, and they take a slightly different approach.