Tesla slams safety agency after Model S falls short of top crash test rating

The Tesla Model S fell short of a top rating in recent Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS) crash tests, and Tesla isn’t happy.

In a recent IIHS test of large sedans, the Model S failed to earn the group’s coveted Top Safety Pick+ award due to low scores in some areas, including an “Acceptable” in the small frontal overlap crash test. Cars must receive the top “Good” score in all categories to earn Top Safety Pick+ status. Out of the group of six cars tested, the Lincoln Continental, Mercedes-Benz E-Class, and Toyota Avalon earned the top rating, but the Model S, Chevrolet Impala, and Ford Taurus did not.

Tesla quickly responded. In a statement to Business Insider, a Tesla representative seemed to downplay the value of the IIHS crash tests, saying that the “most objective and accurate independent testing of vehicle safety is currently done by the U.S. government.” The federal government has given both the Model S and Model X high marks in its crash tests.

Other automakers, not to mention car buyers, would probably dispute Tesla’s position, as the IIHS crash tests are generally considered an important safety benchmark. They are also in some ways tougher than the crash tests conducted by the U.S. National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA).

The NHTSA does not conduct the small frontal overlap crash test in which the Model S failed to earn a top rating. This test is meant to simulate a collision with the corner of another vehicle, or a fixed object like a tree or utility pole, in which relatively little of the vehicle’s front end can absorb the force of impact. These types of crashes are responsible for an outsize amount of injuries and deaths, according to the IIHS.

In 2016, the Model S earned an “Acceptable” rating in the small frontal overlap test. The main reason behind the low rating was a seatbelt that allowed the crash-test dummy’s torso to move too far forward, allowing its head to strike the steering wheel through the airbag, the IIHS said. Tesla changed the seatbelts on all cars built after January, but the same problem occurred in the 2017 test, the IIHS said. So the rating didn’t change.

The Model S also received a lower rating for structural integrity in the 2017 test than in the previous test. In a crash, the body structure deforms and can get pushed into the passenger space, which the IIHS calls “intrusion.” In the 2017 test, “maximum intrusion increased from less than 2 inches to 11 inches in the lower part [of the driver’s space] and to 5 inches at the instrument panel,” the IIHS said. The Model S was ultimately given an “Acceptable” rating for structural integrity.

In addition, all available headlights on the Model S were rated “Poor,” although Tesla is in good company when it comes to low scores in this area. The IIHS also didn’t rate the Model S for autonomous emergency braking, which is required to earn the “+” in “Top Safety Pick+.” That’s because the software to enable the feature was only recently released for the newest cars.

Cars

Automakers are spending billions on self-driving technology people are afraid of

Automakers are spending billions of dollars on developing the technology that will power self-driving cars, but research shows consumers have no interest in giving up control. Will they ever recoup their investment?
Cars

Fisker plans sub-$40,000 electric SUV with 300 miles of range for 2021

Fisker Inc. plans to launch an electric SUV with a base price of under $40,000, and a range of around 300 miles in 2021. The unnamed vehicle could compete with the Tesla Model Y, if it ever gets into production.
Cars

Can electric cars be S3XY? Tesla says yes with the new Model Y crossover

Tesla introduced a crossover named Model Y at its design studio in Los Angeles. It's a more spacious alternative to the Model 3 it shares 75 percent of its parts with, and is a smaller sibling to the Model X.
Cars

Sibling rivalry: The Tesla Model Y takes on the Tesla Model 3

Tesla expanded its lineup with a fourth car named Model Y. It's an electric crossover positioned as a more spacious alternative to the Model 3. The two cars share about 75 percent of their components, but they're aimed at different buyers.
Product Review

Motorola's sexy Moto G7 will change the way you look at budget phones

With glass curves, a large display, and an eye-catching price tag the Moto G7 will turn plenty of heads in the budget smartphone market. We tested it out to see if Motorola has done enough to top the value charts.
Cars

Adventurous and electric, Porsche’s second station wagon will arrive in 2020

The Mission E Cross Turismo concept Porsche unveiled during the 2018 Geneva Auto Show will morph into a production model tentatively named Taycan Cross Turismo. This 600-horsepower electric station wagon will arrive in showrooms by 2021.
Cars

Unrestrained by heritage, Polestar sets its sights on becoming a digital brand

With no heritage to worry about, Polestar is free to move full-speed ahead towards its goal of becoming a digital brand. All of the company's upcoming models will be electric, and they will inaugurate an Android-powered infotainment system.
Cars

Mustang-like and electrified. What did Ford just show a preview of?

Ford posted an enigmatic picture of a blue Mustang emblem on a black background right as Tesla prepared to introduce the Model Y. Is the Blue Oval teasing a hybrid Mustang, or is it previewing a Mustang-inspired, battery-powered crossover?
Cars

Amazon and Kia team up to simplify EV home-charging station installs

Kia Motors announced a new program with Amazon for electric vehicles. Customers planning to purchase a new Kia EV or PHEV can check out recommended Level 2 240-volt home charging stations and arrange installation in their homes.
Cars

Audi’s traffic light information system shows the challenges facing V2X tech

Audi’s traffic light information system is among the first commercial applications of potentially game-changing V2X tech. So how does it work in the real world? We spent a few days getting stuck at red lights to find out.
Emerging Tech

Awesome Tech You Can’t Buy Yet: Write music with your voice, make homemade cheese

Check out our roundup of the best new crowdfunding projects and product announcements that hit the web this week. You may not be able to buy this stuff yet, but it sure is fun to gawk!
Cars

Tesla gives us a cryptic look at its cyberpunk, Blade Runner-inspired pickup

Tesla has started designing its long-promised pickup truck. The yet-unnamed model will come with dual-motor all-wheel drive and lots of torque, plus it will be able to park itself. It could make its debut in 2019.
Cars

2020 Cadillac CT5 luxury sedan gets turbocharged power, chiseled looks

The 2020 Cadillac CT5 replaces the CTS in the General Motors luxury brand's lineup. Cadillac will unveil the CT5 at the 2019 New York Auto Show in April. Until then, it's keeping most details under wraps.
Cars

Bentley’s 542-horsepower Continental GT V8 is the best kind of downsizing

The Bentley Continental GT V8 has fewer cylinders than its W12 sibling, but Bentley expects it to offer better gas mileage and more agile handling. The V8's top speed of 198 mph is also pretty darn fast.