Skip to main content

Opinion: Ultrathin laptop wars: Sony Vaio Z and Lenovo Ultrabooks vs. Apple MacBooks

lenovo-ultrabook-u300s
Image used with permission by copyright holder

Apple casts a bigger footprint in PCs than its approximate 5-percent market share suggests. This is because it is the most profitable of the computer companies, and the most highly valued. Even without market share, those positions are highly envied by Apple’s competitors.

Steve Jobs idealistically modeled Apple after Sony, and while most copies are inferior to the original, Apple is clearly more successful than Sony. The fastest growing PC company, however, isn’t Sony or Apple (at least not in PCs). It is Lenovo, and the ThinkPad builder is getting on Intel’s Ultrabook wagon early to better challenge post-Jobs Apple.

Let’s talk about the coming wave of laptops from these three companies. Be aware I’m just looking at the hardware; I have no real desire to get into the no-win religious argument of Windows vs. MacOS this week.

Apple’s MacBook sets the bar

Apple is unique in the market in that the company builds few products, and uses marketing to drive customers to them. Steve Jobs was Apple’s focus group in that products were designed to meet his personal tastes, and this gave them a personal touch and connection to status that few other products outside of cosmetics (which use celebrities in marketing heavily) enjoy. But, even stronger than good celebrity endorsements, the Mac is (or was) truly built by and for Jobs. He isn’t, as most celebrities are, just a paid shill. That gives the line unusual power.

apple-macbook-air-side
Image used with permission by copyright holder

If you look at the design, thin is in. Apple also takes sharp control over costs, but when dollars and cents conflict with features and design, design generally wins. This allows Apple to hold onto decent volume while pretty much owning the premium position in the PC market. However, the MacBook Air product line does make tradeoffs; it is limited in both breadth and depth, like the one-size-fits-all approach most prominent in Apple’s iPad and iPhone lines.

Choices are limited by design to both maintain margins (reduce inventory levels), and to avoid confusing customers. You don’t buy a Mac for its performance (which is adequate), its durability or its security. You buy it because it is simple and it imparts status better than any other product. This is the bar that the Sony Z and the coming Intel Ultrabooks are attempting to meet. You’ll note I focused on the intangible benefits, because this is often what folks forget when they run against Apple.

The Sony Z

The Sony Z Series laptop is a typical halo product from Sony. Halo products aren’t expected to sell well; they are like show cars is to an automotive vendor : A showcase of that vendor’s capabilities. The problem with them tends to be price, as they drift to very expensive. Fully configured, the Sony Z Series comes in at around $2,000 while the comparable high-end MacBook Pro at 13 inches is $1,499. Typically Apple sets the high bar for laptop price at volume, and this is one of the reasons a halo product like the Sony Z will not sell in high volume. But the Sony is a better notebook (at that price it had better be, right?)

sony-vaio-z-case-open
Image used with permission by copyright holder

Where the Mac uses aluminum the Z uses carbon fiber; where the Mac has good sound, the Sony has active noise cancellation; where the Mac has a good built-in camera, the Sony has a high-end face-tracking capability. Where the Mac has good resolution (1280 x 800) the Sony has great resolution (1600 x 900), where the Mac weighs 4.5 pounds, the Sony weighs 2.5 pounds, (even with the 16-hour extended battery it is only 3.5 pounds). The Mac does have a Thunderbolt port and an optical drive built in that the Sony lacks, and has a Mini-DisplayPort jack rather than the less-flexible but more common HDMI port the Sony sports. In drives to hit price, the Mac has a magnetic 500GB drive, while the Sony has a vastly faster but smaller capacity 128GB Flash drive. The Sony has an optical drive dock and — this is unique to Sony, — the optional battery slice can be charged by itself, providing nearly unlimited off-plug power with multiple batteries. Finally the Sony has biometric security, which is generally preferred over the more common password-only protection.

sony-vaio-z
Image used with permission by copyright holder

In short the Sony is what you would get if you literally wanted the best of the best, and price were almost no object. But it is also,the precursor to the Ultrabooks, which are coming at more aggressive prices.

The Lenovo Ultrabooks

This week, Lenovo announced its high-end Ultrabook designs. The Ultrabook is a MacBook-targeted design class put forward by Intel earlier this year with targeted prices starting round $1,000, and having some of the same features showcased by both the Mac and the Sony Z series. The high-end product starts at $1,199 and comes with an SSD drive, while the low end starts at a more affordable $849 and doesn’t.

These products introduce Intel’s WiDi, technology which allows you to wirelessly broadcast a signal to a WiDi-equipped TV. Battery life is expected to be in line with the Macs at 6 or 7 hours. While the U300, like the Sony, leaves the drive off to get to a lighter weight, the U400 has built-in DVD-RW drive. The U400 has a dedicated (Radeon) graphics part, while the U300 uses Intel’s graphic solution. Weight is under 3 pounds, or between the Sony and Apple products.

lenovo-ultrabook-u300s-angles
Image used with permission by copyright holder

In short, the Ultabooks will have some of the Mac advantages and some of the Sony advantages at a vastly lower price point, and they show up in November.

What’s coming

Ultrabooks are likely the next big wave in notebook computers as vendors move to create ever thinner and lighter laptops. However, once Windows 8 launches, the designs are expected to get touch screens, and this means that future tablets (which start getting enough power next year to become more than just consumption devices), run into them like a freight train, and the children of this collision will start showing up this year.

In the end, Apple’s offerings, the Sony Z Series, and these coming Lenovo Ultrabooks showcase the direction the market is going in, and what we’ll all mostly be using in the next 3 to 5 years. Thin is clearly in, and the coming Windows 8 launch will be surrounded by these ultrathin products.

Guest contributor Rob Enderle is the founder and principal analyst for the Enderle Group, and one of the most frequently quoted tech pundits in the world. Opinion pieces denote the opinions of the author, and do not necessarily represent the views of Digital Trends.

Rob Enderle
Former Contributor
Rob is President and Principal Analyst of the Enderle Group, a forward-looking emerging technology advisory firm. Before…
The MacBook Air proves you don’t need AI to create a world class laptop
Apple MacBook Air 13 M4 front angled view showing display and keyboard.

Our review of the M4 MacBook Air has just dropped, and it’s fair to say it’s one of the best laptops money can buy. For the first time ever, we gave it full marks and a five-star score, with our reviewer dubbing it “as close to perfect” as any laptop they’d seen. There’s no question that it raises the bar for thin and light laptops.

You name it, the MacBook Air has it: impressive performance that belies its lightweight design, build quality that will stand the test of time, a quiet and fanless operation that ensures you can work in peace, a comfortable keyboard and expansive trackpad, and so much more.

Read more
I went hands-on with Apple’s M4 MacBook Air and the app performance blew me away
M4 MacBook Air

Apple is marching in with new products for the spring, including a new MacBook Air featuring the M4 chip, a new iPad Air, uniquely featuring the M3 chip, and a new Mac Studio desktop, with M4 Max and M3 Ultra chip options. While enthusiasts await the launch of the coveted M5 chip series devices, including the MacBook Pro and iPad Pro later this year– the tech brand has brought in the expected refresh of its early-year devices. Notably, the MacBook Air and iPad Air see yearly upgrades, while the Mac Studio is getting its first revamp since 2023.

While largely maintaining their external designs, most changes to the devices can be found by way of hardware and AI support upgrades. Apple is looking to showcase Apple Intelligence app integration as functional and accessible to users. The brand is competing on the market with many on-device AI experiences, such as Microsoft’s Copilot+ PCs and Chromebooks inundated with Google Gemini. 

Read more
10 years ago today, Apple launched a revolutionary MacBook that failed spectacularly
An Apple 12-inch MacBook on a desk.

Ten years ago today, Apple unveiled the 12-inch MacBook to the world, claiming it had “reinvented the notebook” for the better. The laptop almost instantly divided opinion, with fans and detractors at each other’s throats from the start. And sure, it was by no means perfect, but look a little closer and I think you’ll find a device that has had a monumental impact on the world of computing -- not just on Apple, but on the industry as a whole.

The 12-inch MacBook is often seen as a flop and as a product emblematic of the excesses of Apple’s Jony Ive era, where the design guru’s penchant for thinness and lightness ruled all. The fact that this MacBook was discontinued after just four years is seen as proof of this idea.

Read more