Skip to main content

The petitions are right. The Surface Duo should run Windows 10X

Over 1,500 people have signed a petition for Microsoft to make a Surface Duo that runs Windows, not Android.

That probably won’t pressure the company to make such a device. But the petition has a point.

Why doesn’t Microsoft’s long-awaited return to smartphones run its own software? It’s especially strange given that Microsoft debuted capable dual-screen software on the Surface Neo at the same press conference. Is Android really a better option than Windows 10X?

It’s no Surface Phone

Microsoft

The announcement of the Surface Duo was one of the more surprising and exciting moments in tech this year. But when Microsoft revealed it will be an Android device, I was confused. Android? That’s what we’ve waited years for? An LG G8X with a Windows logo on the front?

The move is being celebrated by Windows fans with painful memories of Windows Phone and Windows RT. Microsoft has made serious mistakes in the past, shoving its own operating systems onto devices that couldn’t handle it.

But who’s interested in another Android phone in 2019? The first dual-screen Android devices, like the Samsung Galaxy Fold, already exist. Will the trend still feel new by the time Microsoft gets around to releasing the Surface Duo?

I’m far more interested in is Windows 10X, and specifically, Windows Core OS. It’s the first completely modular operating system, designed to work with any device, no matter how strange. As the petitioners have said, it seems like the perfect fit for the Surface Duo. Using it would give the Duo a unique feature that no other company can replicate.

Has Core OS already failed?

Microsoft Newsroom/Microsoft

I’m waiting to spend more time with Windows 10X and the Surface Neo, but its unique design looks impressive from what I’ve seen. It’s a flexible device, one that adapts to your circumstances without compromise. In theory, at least, it beautifully handles a wide range of applications and multiple usage modes.

That’s what Core OS technology was built to allow. It’s the reason Windows 10 can run on devices as diverse as the HoloLens headset and Surface Hub 2. Scaling it down for a smartphone shouldn’t be a problem. Microsoft has stated that Win32 apps will run in a container in Windows 10X. When asked, the company told us there’s no reason Android apps couldn’t function in the same way. That’s the app problem handled, check and check.

So, if the stumbling block isn’t apps or software, why can’t the Duo run Windows like its big brother, the Neo? There’s only one explanation.

Microsoft doesn’t have the guts.

Windows, Surface, and Microsoft lives in the shadow of one of the largest blunders in the company’s history. Microsoft CEO Satya Nadella and Chief Product Officer Panos Panay have worked to undo the damage done by Windows 8, Windows RT, and Windows Phone. They’re no doubt leery about reversing that goodwill with an overly ambitious device.

Microsoft

But Microsoft is a different company in 2019 than in 2016. It has a rich portfolio of hardware, a positive brand in the Surface, and a ton of cash in the bank. Now is the time to unveil a new vision for its products and services.

There’s no room for another Android phone, but there is definitely room for something new. Not a third option to the duopoly like Windows Phone was, but an alternative to smartphones as a whole. A proper 2-in-1 that could bridge a gap in the same way the Surface Pro does today. Microsoft may have found a clever way to do that using Android, but even if they’ll do, I’ll always wonder what could have been.

Based on Microsoft’s lack of confidence in its own software, I’m resigned to believe them. Maybe what it’s cooked up in Windows 10X and Core OS isn’t so revolutionary after all.

Luke Larsen
Former Senior Editor, Computing
Luke Larsen is the Senior Editor of Computing, managing all content covering laptops, monitors, PC hardware, Macs, and more.
Microsoft is backpedaling on future Windows 10 updates
The Windows Update screen in Windows 10.

Windows 10 is on its way out, with support ending in October 2025. That isn't changing, though Microsoft's approach to rolling out new features in the meantime definitely has. In a surprising move, Microsoft announced in a June 4 Windows Insider Blog post that it is bringing a Beta Channel for those Windows Insiders currently running on Windows 10 version 22H2.

This means that despite the end of support, Windows 10 users will continue to get some new features that were initially restricted to Windows 11, such as the new Copilot app. It's also possible that other features may be on the way, but Microsoft has not released any further information on the subject. It was originally stated that Windows 10 version 22H2 would be its final feature update, but that appears to not be true anymore.

Read more
Scores of people are downgrading back to Windows 10
The screen of the Galaxy Book4 Ultra.

Microsoft continues to struggle with the adoption of Windows 11 among its users. Recent data from Statcounter reveals a notable decline in the operating system’s market share, specifically compared with Windows 10.

After reaching an all-time high of 28.16% in February 2024, Windows 11 has experienced a drop, falling below the 26% mark.

Read more
The Surface Pro 10 sounds amazing, and it may be coming soon
The back of the Surface Pro 9, with the kickstand pulled out.

Microsoft could be getting ready to reveal the Surface Pro 10 and Surface Laptop 6 sooner than expected. Reporting from Windows Central's Zac Bowden indicates the devices might be announced on March 21, and could feature both Intel Core Ultra and Snapdragon X Elite chips under the hood, along with some design tweaks.

These new Surface devices are expected to go all-in on AI features in Windows 11. More important is that we could see the next Surface Laptop in a new ARM-based variant in addition to one with a traditional Intel Core Ultra CPU. This change in chips should not only bring more choice like the Surface Pro 9 did, but also performance gains that can help the devices rival what Apple has accomplished with the iPad Pro, as well as the new MacBook Pro with the M3 chip.

Read more