Skip to main content

British government doesn’t consider loot boxes as gambling, for now

A British politician confirmed the government’s position that in-game loot boxes are not gambling. For now, they have elected to leave the practice outside of the jurisdiction of the British Gambling Commission, suggesting that it would only consider items gambled outside of a game — where they have “monetary value” and would be in need of a license.

The idea of what constitutes gambling in games has become a much-discussed topic in recent years. Sites that allowed gamers to bet in-game items against one another in a coin-coss drew attention and condemnation last year, but the topic of more recent discussion has been in-game loot boxes. The kind that you unlock and commonly pay for with real money, which have a random reward.

Recommended Videos

Although many defend the practice as optional, others have drawn comparisons between the practice and gambling, which could be problematic considering games that utilize the feature, like Overwatch, have low age restrictions. Like the Entertainment Software Rating Board though, the British government is not quite as concerned. When asked about loot boxes and “in-game gambling,” conservative Parliament member Tracey Crouch responded that the government doesn’t currently classify such practices as gambling.

“Where items obtained in a computer game can be traded or exchanged outside the game platform they acquire a monetary value, and where facilities for gambling with such items are offered to consumers located in Britain a Gambling Commission license is required,” her response reads. “If no license is held, the Commission uses a wide range of regulatory powers to take action.”

She did make a point to suggest that the government’s main aim with its gambling legislation was in “protecting children and vulnerable people,” and highlighted the Gambling Commission’s targeting of websites that facilitate item gambling earlier this year — referring to sites like CSGOLotto.

As part of her response, Crouch linked to a March position paper from Britain’s Gambling Commission on the subject of gambling and games. In it, the commission highlights that “betting, gaming or participating in a lottery,” is the existing definition of gambling, though suggested that merely involving expenditure and chance did not necessarily constitute it.

It later clarifies by specifically mentioning crates, keys, and chests with randomized content. It highlights that although the practice, “bears a close resemblance, for instance, to the playing of a gaming machine,” it is not in-fact, gambling. The commission only considers the practice to require a gambling license if those items can be traded outside of a game for monetary compensation.

“Where prizes are successfully restricted for use solely within the game, such in-game features would not be licensable gambling, notwithstanding the elements of expenditure and chance,” it reads.

The commission and Crouch, however, have both said they will continue to monitor the industry and consider the matter still under review.

Jon Martindale
Jon Martindale is a freelance evergreen writer and occasional section coordinator, covering how to guides, best-of lists, and…
3 new Game Pass games to play this weekend (June 20-22)
Queen Aleksandra near a giant metal enemy.

Today marks the first official day of summer, so what better way to beat the heat than with some cool new Game Pass games? The middle and end of the month tend to be a bit slower for new games, but this week has not just one, but two day one additions to sink your teeth into. What makes my job of picking the best ones even easier is the fact that I am spoiled for choice in terms of variety. I have a great new co-op shooter, a deliciously dark action roguelike, plus a throwback platformer that anyone can enjoy. Each one can dominate your weekend, so let's skip right to the good stuff and talk about the three Game Pass games I know you will love playing this weekend.

FBC: Firebreak

Read more
Death Stranding 2 preload guide: release date, file size, and more
Sam under a massive moon in Death Stranding 2.

We're on the cusp of seeing what Hideo Kojima has in store for us in Death Stranding 2. The trailers so far promise a grander and even more unpredictable experience with one-of-a-kind characters and gameplay like nothing else. Like any good porter, you need to make sure you're fully prepared before heading out on this trek. We're not talking about balancing your weight or putting on fresh shoes, but preloading the game so you can set out as soon as the game unlocks. Death Stranding 2 looks like it will have some of the best graphics on PS5, which means it is a chunky file to download. Here's all the preload information you need, including the release date, file size, and more.

Death Stranding 2 release date

Read more
FBC: Firebreak review: co-op Control spinoff is a a lot of work for little payoff
Three players pose together in FBC: Firebreak.

You start a new job. It’s nothing special; you’re just a low rung paper pusher. The starting pay is meager, but it’s enough to pay the bills. Your boss says that he sees a bright future for you in this company. Work hard and you’ll get a promotion. More money. More perks. More power. You bust your butt to hit every milestone you can, occasionally getting a small holiday bonus or a few extra vacation days. Your day to day only improves in small increments, but you keep reaching for the next rung of the corporate ladder in hopes that the view from the top will be worth it one day.

That experience isn’t so dissimilar to how I’ve felt playing FBC: Firebreak, a shooter that feels like a second job. Remedy Entertainment’s foray into co-op action, a spinoff of its 2019 hit Control, brings a playful pitch to the board room. It imagined what the average Joes of its interconnected universe do while Jesse Fayden is living out a superhero fantasy. It’s a celebration of the mundane that hands out Employee of the Week plaques to any player willing to clock in for a dead end job with a smile on their face.

Read more