Forget used games, killing borrowed games is the bigger issue

mass effectAs a kid, a little piece of me truly hated Ninja Gaiden. That damn game was the bane of my existence for weeks, and I still have dreams about murderous birds swooping down out of the sky, hell-bent on sending me to my doom. It taunted me. Then one day my friend and I stayed up and played that game through the night until finally we beat it. I still consider it a crowning achievement on my gaming resume, and since then I’ve played almost every Ninja Gaiden game released. Yet I never actually owned the original myself, I borrowed it from another friend (who had seriously considered smashing the game out of frustration).  

The act of borrowing games is a time honored tradition among gamers. It has introduced people to more than a few titles that would otherwise have remained lost in the shadow of the games with huge advertising budgets. With the new generation of consoles, this tradition could die. 

If you somehow missed the news, Microsoft is toying with the idea of charging a hefty fee to play used games. The gaming community has taken it… well, saying it took it “badly” is like saying Justin Bieber’s fashion style is a “little unusual.” The rumored fees would be a kick to the collective privates of the used gaming market, but from a technical standpoint, the way that the hardware would do this would create severe collateral damage. By locking games to a single profile, it would end the practice of borrowing and loaning games.

If you want to buy BioShock Infinite, you can find it on Amazon right now for $39.99, just $10 more than a used copy. Thanks to competition and sales, gaming will survive without used games (grudgingly). Killing the ability to loan a game out, however, will have more significant consequences. 

What details Microsoft has let slip are somewhat confusing, partly because the company continues to contradict itself. It currently claims that it will support used gaming and more details are coming soon. How it will support used gaming, however, is still unclear. Sony, meanwhile, has quietly sidestepped the entire topic, happily letting Microsoft be known as the destroyer of used games and the crusher of dreams. It may end up doing the exact same thing, but for now Microsoft is the one holding the lightning rod.

The focus of both the media and most fans has specifically been on the ability to purchase used games, and what this means for the used game market. Right now, the future of used gaming seems bleak, and the GameStops of tomorrow may look like a post-apocalyptic wasteland, as once-helpful clerks battle to the death over the last bag of Skittles, hoping to ward off starvation for one more day. Of course, it could all turn out to be based on incorrect information. Equally likely, Microsoft could glimpse the digital torches and pitchforks coming its way and abandon its plans. Sony, meanwhile, could then shake its head disapprovingly at Microsoft, while silently shredding its folder marked “Plans for Used Games.” 

Whatever Microsoft decides, the Xbox One has been designed so that you will install games directly to your hard drive, eliminating the need for a disc afterward. (Sony has yet to confirm or deny this design for the PlayStation 4). To prevent rampant piracy, the console will require authorization. Without it you could just pass the disc to everyone you’ve ever met, and they could just install it and pass it on. It would almost be an insult to all the people that worked so hard at pirating games over the years. It would ruin the gaming industry.The easiest solution would be to require users to keep the disc in the optical drive as a proof of ownership, as many PC games have done for years, but that might not be the case. No matter what happens with used games, that seems to spell doom for the borrowing of games, as well as rentals. Sorry, GameFly.  

You’ll still be able to take a game to a friend’s house (or an enemy’s house, I suppose – no judgment here) and play it on their console, but you will need to sign in to your personal profile. Gamers wanting to play the same games from a different profile would need to pay a hefty fee, probably full retail, which defeats the point.

transformersThe average salary of a person 25 or older working full time is between $31,000 and $56,000, depending on their level of education. With new games costing $60, and used games at $40 or more for big releases that are still relatively new, there are plenty of titles that people just aren’t going to spend their hard-earned money on. For example, I loaned a buddy the game Transformers: War for Cybertron. He is an old-school fan of the original cartoon show (you know, the really cool original one that proceeded the dumb CGI ones?), but not to the degree that he eagerly awaits Transformers properties. He doesn’t have a Decepticon tattoo or anything. But he was enough of a fan that he was happy to play the game.

War for Cybertron was a good game; not a great one, but good enough game that few people would actually regret playing it. When its sequel Fall of Cybertron came out, my buddy actually did buy that one (used). Hopefully the point is obvious: If I hadn’t loaned him the original, he wouldn’t have bothered with the sequel. There are thousands of stories like this, and they all run the risk of never happening in the future.

The death of game lending cuts deeper into what makes a console different from a PC as well. While PC gamers can proudly claim that their games look better, run smoother, and in some cases even cost less thanks to services like Steam, they are more complicated too. A PC gamer will wear that as a badge of honor, but it also isolates them. Consoles could always boast simplicity and accessibility, but it looks like that might not be the case for long.

Loaning games to friends is an old tradition with quantifiable benefits, just like loaning books and music. A person who borrows a game is exposed to the product enough to make a decision about the people who made it. Used gaming still requires an investment, so there is still a fair amount of care given when buying a pre-owned title. Borrowing a game costs nothing, and it nurtures the console community. Removing that ability changes the nature of the industry and makes it more insular.


I will tell you right now, as God as my witness, I will never pay one single penny for a dancing game. Not ever. That doesn’t mean I won’t ever play one though, especially if I have a party at my place. Borrowing it from a friend is easy, but having a dancing game won’t make or break my party. On a similar note, I probably would never have tried, and then subsequently become obsessed with Katamari Damacy if I hadn’t borrowed it from a friend. A Japanese game about a drunken King of All Cosmos losing all the stars and forcing his tiny, indentured son to recreate them with balls of junk? Ok, that actually sounds kind of intriguing, but the point remains.

It isn’t the blockbusters that are going to suffer if people can no longer borrow games, it’s the games from midsize publishers. The elusive “sleeper hits” we all love to talk about will just be sleepers, because they’ll never get the gamer-to-gamer exposure that used to make them hits. Games will either be smaller releases like indie and digital-downloads, or have major backing. Publishers won’t even bother releasing games that won’t be instant hits, because the chance for them to slowly grow will be significantly curtailed. If people can no longer borrow (or even rent) games, and used titles carry a heavy price tag, the retail shelf life plummets.

Forget used games, the death of borrowed games is the real game changer. I normally stay away from puns, but dammit, it’s apt. Losing the ability to loan games to friends and borrow others in return makes gaming something different. It makes it less inclusive, and also increases the costs of gaming as a hobby to new heights. Charging for online passes is one thing – multiplayer is generally a secondary feature, and when it isn’t, most people who want it are fine buying new (or paying the online fee) because of the amount of time they put in. That seems like a fair compromise. 

Shakespeare famously wrote in Hamlet, “Neither a borrower nor a lender be.” Of course Shakespeare never played the Mass Effect trilogy. He probably wouldn’t have liked the ending, but otherwise he might have dug it – once he got over the shock of our modern amenities like indoor plumbing and the witchcraft that creates electricity, of course. After playing the first Mass Effect, I was on the fence about investing 20+ hours in the second despite all the recommendations. The third was on the way and looked great, but while I loved the story of the original, the busy work – aka that damn Mako – nearly derailed it for me. I eventually yielded and borrowed Mass Effect 2 from a buddy, and I loved it. When the third came out, I dropped a fair amount of change on the multiplayer microtransactions, not to mention the DLCs, ensuring BioWare still got a piece out of me. Borrowing games leads to a healthier industry.

Sure, I could watch it on TV, but I can't reset it when my team is losing.

I have always wanted to try out a rugby video game. But I can promise you, Nintendo and Sony, if you won’t let me borrow a friend’s copy or even rent one, I will go rugby-less. Preventing gamers from passing games around or even buying used titles at a discount won’t increase profits. People aren’t going to suddenly laugh and think “well played, Microsoft and Sony.” You won’t convince many people to buy a game that they weren’t going to anyway simply because of the threat of never playing it. Instead you will lose those gamers. And with them will go gaming as we know it. 

The views expressed here are solely those of the author and do not reflect the beliefs of Digital Trends.


The Razer Core X Chroma is the best external GPU you can buy

The third entry in Razer's lineup of external graphics card enclosures, the Core X Chroma, brings together the best of its previous options in a single package. With RGB lighting and extra USB ports, is this the best you can buy?

Immerse yourself in a new universe with these incredible PSVR games

The PSVR has surpassed expectations and along with it comes an incredible catalog of games. There's plenty of amazing experiences to be had so we've put together a list of the best PSVR games available today.

New Need for Speed and Plants vs. Zombies games could be shown by EA at E3 2019

EA is doing things a bit differently for its fan-oriented EA Play event. Multiple livestreams will air on June 8, replacing the traditional press conference format. We expect to see Star Wars: Jedi Fallen Order and much more.

Animal Crossing could make an appearance during the Nintendo Direct at E3 2019

Once again, Nintendo will air a Nintendo Direct during E3 2019 rather than take the stage. The showcase will feature games launching in 2019, so expect The Legend of Zelda: Link's Awakening, Luigi's Mansion 3, and much more.

These are the must-have games that every Xbox One owner needs

More than four years into its life span, Microsoft's latest console is finally coming into its own. From Cuphead to Halo 5, the best Xbox One games offer something for players of every type.

Activision reveals game modes, multiplayer maps for Call of Duty: Mobile

Activision revealed the first five modes for Call of Duty: Mobile. The publisher also highlighted five maps from previous entries in the franchise, but said that the game will not only feature multiplayer modes.

The Astro A40 TR and Mixamp Pro TR turn the volume up on pro gaming audio

The A40 TR and Mixamp Pro TR are Astro's latest entries to professional grade gaming gear. The two accessories hold their own alone, but together their true potential is fully realized.

These Xbox One exclusives are the definition of quality over quantity

Xbox One has a prestigious collection of handpicked titles that you can't play on other consoles. Here are the latest and greatest Xbox One exclusives, including some that are also available on PC

The best Nintendo Switch games, from Breath of the Wild to Rocket League

The Nintendo Switch's lineup started off small, but games have steadily released as the console continues through its second year. Here are the best Nintendo Switch games available now.

Give your PC a new lease of life by upgrading its core components

Older PCs can still be great tools for work and play, they just need a little upgrade now and again. Here are the best upgrades you can make to your PC to make it feel fresh and fast once again.

You're not a true fan without these Nintendo Switch exclusives

Who doesn't love a good Nintendo game? If you're looking for great first-party titles for your Nintendo Switch, take a look at our list of the very best exclusives available right now.

Treyarch takes over 2020 Call of Duty, will make Black Ops 5

Treyarch is taking over development for the 2020 Call of Duty, which will be Black Ops 5, Kotaku reported. Raven was initially leading the project alongside Sledgehammer, but the two studios frequently got into arguments.

World of Warcraft Classic beta testers confusing old-school features for bugs

Blizzard released a "not a bug" list for World of Warcraft Classic, as beta testers apparently kept reporting intended features. The list includes the "Your skill in Protection increased to 15" message that appears upon leveling up.

Next Apex Legends patch will fix Gibraltar’s sticky shield and hit registration

Respawn is set to roll out a new patch for Apex Legends early this week. The update will look to fix several issues in the game, including Gibraltar's sticky shield, the Fortified passive ability, and incorrect hit registration.