Skip to main content

Hawaiian state bill would ban sale of loot box-enabled games to minors

Game on. Together we can stop predatory gaming practices

Video game loot boxes — randomized item backs often obtainable through real cash or “premium currency” — soared in popularity in 2017, with everything from Star Wars Battlefront II to Forza Motorsport 7 using some version of the concept. It’s incredibly easy to purchase loot boxes on gaming consoles, but if a new bill out of Hawaii is passed, minors in our 50th state won’t be able to buy games that include them.

Senate Bill 3025, which has an identical companion bill in the Hawaiian house of representatives, comes a few months after state congressman Chris Lee openly condemned loot boxes in video games, calling the system Electronic Arts previously used in Star Wars Battlefront II a “Star Wars-themed online casino designed to lure kids into an addictive cycle of gambling money for a chance to win game upgrades.”

Should the bill pass, videos games “that contain a system of further purchasing a randomized reward or virtual idem that can be redeemed to directly or indirectly receive a randomized reward” — loot boxes — could not legally be sold to anyone under 21. This system doesn’t prohibit the sale of games that contain traditional microtransactions, however.

“Unlike at casinos, there is rarely disclosure of the odds of winning items of value in loot boxes or in-game gambling-like mechanics,” the bill said. “There are no gaming commissions to ensure players are being treated fairly and not exploited by gambling-like mechanics which do not pay out as advertised.”

A second set of bills in both the Hawaiian House and Senate applies to consumers regardless of age. They would require video game publishers to “prominently” disclose the probability rates of winning randomized items. The Entertainment Software Rating Board, which gives video games an age rating such as “Everyone,” “Teen,” and “Mature,” based on their content, doesn’t currently view the system as gambling. It’s a self-regulatory board established by the Entertainment Software Association, which has every major publisher among its members — it would be against the group’s interests to classify the systems as gambling, as it would hurt the individual publishers’ bottom lines.

Time will tell if similar bills are necessary elsewhere in the United States and around the world. Following disappointing financial results for Star Wars Battlefront II, Electronic Arts CFO Blake Jorgensen blamed the game’s performance on controversy surround its loot box system.

Editors' Recommendations

Gabe Gurwin
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Gabe Gurwin has been playing games since 1997, beginning with the N64 and the Super Nintendo. He began his journalism career…
Senator’s loot crate bill has the video game industry nervous
US senator loot box bill ban microtransactions

Monetization in games has spiraled out of control in the last few years, and the loot box is one of the biggest culprits. Companies have flirted with pay-to-win mechanics implemented via loot boxes and even limited them to visual flair -- but for some, it's all just gambling in the end.

Now the U.S. may follow countries like Belgium, which has made loot boxes illegal. U.S. Republican Senator Josh Hawley of Missouri said in an interview with Kotaku that a new bill he has introduced to regulate them has the game industry “concerned.”

Read more
U.S. Senate presses FTC to investigate video game loot boxes

Loot boxes have been the subject of controversy over the last few years, with games like Star Wars: Battlefront II coming under particularly heavy scrutiny for including gambling-like mechanics in competitive multiplayer. Countries in Europe, including Belgium, have already taken steps to combat loot boxes, and it appears the United States Federal Trade Commission will now follow suit.

During a U.S. Senate Commerce, Science, and Transportation subcommittee hearing on Tuesday, Sen. Maggie Hassan of New Hampshire asked FTC commissioners about "additional oversight" regarding loot boxes and how they can appeal to children.

Read more
‘Star Wars Battlefront II’ ditches paid loot boxes for good
star wars battlefront ii performance guide battlefront ii performance guide presets 4k low

Star Wars Battlefront 2 The Last Jedi Season

Electronic Arts ran into some pretty big issues with the launch of Star Wars Battlefront II. Following public backlash toward the publisher's use of paid loot boxes in the game, EA eventually removed microtransactions temporarily in order to revamp the Battlefront II progression system. Now, the new system is ready for release, and players are going to be very happy: Paid loot boxes are gone for good.

Read more