The day Justice Scalia helped save video games

how scalia saved video games justice
U.S. Mission Geneva
The unexpected death of Supreme Court Justice Antonin Scalia on Saturday created shock waves, throwing a politically charged replacement battle on top of what is already one of the most fraught presidential primary races in living memory. An incisive legal scholar and constitutional originalist, he served on the country’s highest court for nearly three decades, leaving behind a divisive legacy as one of the most conservative voices in the modern Supreme Court.

Scalia courted no shortage of controversy, particularly for opinions on homosexuality that many view as regressive, but one count of unexpected praise came this past weekend in a statement from the Entertainment Software Association, noting his majority opinion in a 2011 case that enshrined video games under First Amendment protection as a form of free expression:

The Entertainment Software Association joins those who salute the service and mourn the loss of Justice Scalia. In 2011, when our industry defended the rights of creators and consumers of video games before the U.S. Supreme Court, it was Justice Scalia who authored the historic majority opinion. He declared, with no ambiguity, that video games, like books, movies and other forms of expression, are deserving of First Amendment protections. It was a momentous day for our industry and those who love the entertainment we create and we are indebted to Justice Scalia for so eloquently defending the rights of creators and consumer everywhere.

“Literature draws the reader into the story, makes him identify with the characters …. to experience their joys and sufferings.”

In 2005 California passed a law that restricted the sale of violent video games to minors as it would cigarettes or alcohol. It was immediately challenged by the Video Software Dealers Association and blocked by a District Court injunction ruling it unconstitutional. Then-governor Arnold Schwarzenegger (ironically famous for starring in violent, mass market films) vowed to fight the ruling, bringing the case to the 9th District Court of Appeals, which upheld the District Court’s ruling. In 2010 it moved up to the Supreme Court, and in a 7-2 decision for Brown vs. Entertainment Merchants Association, Scalia wrote the majority opinion that upheld the lower courts’ rulings. In his opinion, Scalia argued that, as an expressive medium, games should fall under the same protections that the First Amendment grants to other types of creative speech:

Like the protected books, plays, and movies that preceded them, video games communicate ideas — and even social messages — through many familiar literary devices (such as characters, dialogue, plot, and music) and through features distinctive to the medium (such as the player’s interaction with the virtual world). That suffices to confer First Amendment protection. Under our Constitution, “esthetic and moral judgments about art and literature … are for the individual to make, not for the Government to decree, even with the mandate or approval of a majority.”

The state of California argued that video games deserved special consideration as an interactive medium, and thus somehow more likely to provoke violence in impressionable children that play them. The argument about the potential dangers of violent video games went back to the 90s, when the rapidly-increasing graphical fidelity of ultra-violent video games like Mortal Kombat provoked outrage among parents and conservative activists. That initial outcry led to the creation of the ESRB ratings system, but the debate raged on.

Scalia’s opinion pointed out that decades of research studies looking for a causal link between violent video games and real-world behavior “have been rejected by every court to consider them, and with good reason: They do not prove that violent video games cause minors to act aggressively (which would at least be a beginning).” Writing more broadly, he argued that the interactive nature of video games was not fundamentally different from the ways that older narrative media invited audience investment: “The better it is, the more interactive. Literature when it is successful draws the reader into the story, makes him identify with the characters, invites him to judge them and quarrel with them, to experience their joys and sufferings as the reader’s own.”

Although the 2011 ruling set a powerful legal precedent for the video game industry, the debate about the influence of games and gaming culture has continued, particularly now in the context of GamerGate and the toxic discourse bred by online anonymity. On the other hand, the U.S. Government has started to change its tune, with the White House recently signaling its intent to move the discussion from games’ negative effects to their possible positive effects for social change and as a rapidly growing industry sector.

Scalia’s legacy is divisive to say the least, but on this one issue he managed to eloquently voice the progressive side of history and play an important role in ensuring that video games are able to flourish and evolve as other forms of media did before them.

Gaming

Epic Games sues ‘Fortnite’ YouTuber creators over cheating software

Epic Games has filed a lawsuit against two YouTube users for their role in promoting cheating and hacking tools for Fortnite via a YouTube channel and personal website. As of now, the channel is still live.
Emerging Tech

What the heck is machine learning, and why is it everywhere these days?

Machine learning has been responsible for some of the biggest advances in artificial intelligence over the past decade. But what exactly is it? Check out our handy beginner's guide.
Movies & TV

'Prime'-time TV: Here are the best shows on Amazon Prime right now

There's more to Amazon Prime than free two-day shipping, including access to a number of phenomenal shows at no extra cost. To make the sifting easier, here are our favorite shows currently streaming on Amazon Prime.
Movies & TV

The best shows on Netflix in October, from 'Mindhunter’ to ‘The Good Place’

Looking for a new show to binge? Lucky for you, we've curated a list of the best shows on Netflix, whether you're a fan of outlandish anime, dramatic period pieces, or shows that leave you questioning what lies beyond.
Movies & TV

The best movies on Netflix in October, from 'The Witch’ to ‘Black Panther’

Save yourself from hours wasted scrolling through Netflix's massive library by checking out our picks for the streamer's best movies available right now, whether you're into explosive action, subdued humor, or anything in between.
Gaming

Tired of waiting for the PlayStation Classic? Try one of these PS1 emulators

It's not always easy to get ahold of original PlayStation titles due to pricing and general availability. Emulators can solve that problem. Here are the top five PlayStation emulators.
Emerging Tech

Light-swallowing room promises Call of Duty fans the blackest of ops

What's it like to be in a room fully painted with the world's darkest material, Vantablack? The makers of one of the year's top video games teamed up with Vantablack scientists to find out.
Gaming

The hottest Nintendo Switch games you can get right now

The Nintendo Switch's lineup started off small, but games have steadily released as the console continues through its second year. Here are the best Nintendo Switch games available now, from Super Mario Odyssey to Fortnite.
Gaming

Terrifying clowns try to kill you in this teaser for ‘PUBG’ Halloween event

PlayerUnknown's Battlegrounds seems to be getting a frightening Halloween event. In a brief teaser, we get a glimpse of two masked assailants, creepy nurses, and an utterly terrifying clown that looks something like Pennywise.
Gaming

Huawei thinks its Mate 20 X is better than the Nintendo Switch

Huawei positioned its Mate 20 X, a gaming-centric smartphone, as a Nintendo Switch killer, calling it "the best portable gaming machine." The Mate 20 X has better design specs than the Switch, but it also comes with a steep price.
Gaming

Eat your way to a limited-edition Xbox One X in new Taco Bell contest

If you like the idea of a limited-edition Xbox One X that makes Taco Bell's famous "bong" sound every time it starts up, then you need to enter a new contest launched by the fast-food chain and Microsoft without delay.
Gaming

You can preload ‘Red Dead Redemption 2’ soon, and you definitely should

Red Dead Redemption 2's launch is quickly approaching. If you're planning on buying a digital version, you should keep in mind that the file size is roughly 90GB. Thankfully, you can preload the game starting October 19
Gaming

These guns will literally blow away the competition in Black Ops 4's Blackout

Finding a good weapon in Black Ops 4's Blackout mode is hard, especially when there are so many options. Whether you like to get up close or keep some distance between you and your enemies, here are the best guns in Blackout.
Gaming

Wings on the bus: ‘Fortnite’ Battle Bus now sends you to your death even faster

A new update for Fortnite: Battle Royale has made the starting Battle Bus significantly faster, meaning you can get killed by a better player even faster than you could up until now.