Skip to main content

All 3 big console companies will require loot boxes to disclose odds of winning

Loot boxes in different games like Fortnite, Rocket League, PUBG, Dota 2
Nate Barrett/Digital Trends

Loot boxes have been a controversial inclusion in video games ever since they began appearing in shooters like Overwatch, but the process of opening them could be a little more transparent on consoles in the future. Microsoft, Nintendo, and Sony will soon require loot boxes in games to disclose the odds of winning, which could encourage publishers to adjust the numbers.

According to GamesIndustry.biz, Michael Warnecke, Entertainment Software Association chief counsel of tech policy, made this information public during the Federal Trade Commisssion’s Inside the Game workshop on August 7. Warnecke said the new policies on all three companies’ systems would require that games share the chance of obtaining rare items.

Some games have already implemented systems like this on consoles, including MLB The Show 19. Doing this voluntarily could be an attempt by game publishers to avoid government action being taken. A bill to ban the sale of loot boxes to minors has already been introduced, with its sponsors likening the mechanic to gambling. The ease of use for playing games on consoles, mobile, and even PC seems to have encouraged players spend real money without so much as a second thought.

MLB The Show 19 review

Not only would new games have to include this information, but games that received updates adding loot boxes would also be required to do so. This is a release strategy we’ve seen from several AAA games in the past, which hold off on implementing microtransactions until reviews have been published and the initial launch hype has passed.

Warnecke added that third-party publishers are also taking steps to do the same, but reaction has been mixed at best for loot boxes included in paid retail games. Middle-earth: Shadow of War launched with a marketplace built around loot boxes back in 2017, but eventually removed the system completely after players felt it compromised the core gameplay experience.

The backlash against loot boxes in other games has been even greater, often because players feel they encourage “pay to win” gameplay rather than competition based on skill. Also released in 2017, Star Wars: Battlefront II was heavily criticized for the loot box system it included for upgrading your characters. This system was also replaced by a much more basic, cosmetic-level microtransaction system.

Editors' Recommendations

Gabe Gurwin
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Gabe Gurwin has been playing games since 1997, beginning with the N64 and the Super Nintendo. He began his journalism career…
Hawaiian state bill would ban sale of loot box-enabled games to minors
ea e3 2017 assault theed multiplayer demo star wars battlefront ii

Game on. Together we can stop predatory gaming practices

Video game loot boxes -- randomized item backs often obtainable through real cash or "premium currency" -- soared in popularity in 2017, with everything from Star Wars Battlefront II to Forza Motorsport 7 using some version of the concept. It's incredibly easy to purchase loot boxes on gaming consoles, but if a new bill out of Hawaii is passed, minors in our 50th state won't be able to buy games that include them.

Read more
App Store guidelines require developers to disclose loot box reward chances
L

2017 has been the year of the loot box. The digital mystery crates have made their way into everything from Middle-earth: Shadow of War to Star Wars: Battlefront II, and for mobile games, they've been particularly pervasive. Often, the rates of success for receiving high-quality items from these loot boxes aren't made public, but a new guideline for the App Store is changing that.

In the updated App Store Review Guidelines, Apple has added an additional requirement under the "In-App Purchase" section, which explicitly states developers must be transparent about the success rates for their loot boxes.

Read more
Game publisher Take-Two doesn’t think that loot boxes are gambling
L

Loot boxes in video games have been a contentious topic over the last few months, as more and more titles relegate progression systems and rewards to what is essentially a randomized form of gambling -- but if you were to ask Grand Theft Auto V and NBA 2K18 publisher Take-Two about loot boxes, it would have a different definition of gambling.

Speaking at a Credit Suisse event (via GameSpot), Take-Two president Karl Slatoff said that the company "[doesn't] view [loot boxes] as gambling," echoing statements made by the Entertainment Software Board.

Read more