Open-world video games are getting too big for their own good

assassins creeds decade of reinvention ac1 07  e3 talal screenshots 160 assassin s creed jerusalem highpoint1

Video game worlds have certainly come a long way since their formative period in the 1980s, when it was impressive to just move in three dimensions rather than the limited 2D planes of the 8-bit and 16-bit era. As soon as technology made it possible, developers began turning video games from linear, guided experiences into choose-your-own-adventure stories, with open worlds just waiting to be explored and uncovered. Over the years, these have grown more detailed, more lifelike, and, most importantly, much larger.

It sounds like a perfect example of increased horsepower making games better, and there’s certainly something to be said for the massive, vibrant worlds created by companies like Bethesda and Rockstar Games; but as time has gone on, open worlds have begun to grow too big for their own good.

Assassin's Creed Odyssey review
Assassin’s Creed Odyssey

Far too often, players are given worlds so large that their sheer breadth and scale is considered a selling point, rather than the potential activities to be completed within it. It’s creating a cycle of “bigger is better” marketing that results in games that don’t feel more alive at all.

In fact, they often feel deader than ever.

The trendsetter

Though certainly not the first open-world game by any reasonable criteria, Rockstar’s Grand Theft Auto III helped to usher in a change in design philosophy that can still be seen in games nearly two decades later. Rather than simply send you to various parts of an enormous and static map to complete missions, Rockstar made you feel like a citizen in Liberty City.

Twice the size of our last game. Bigger than anything we’ve done.

Nearly any vehicle could be hijacked, allowing you to explore in style, and total chaos was just a few bullets away. It encouraged experimentation, and made travel a key component of the story. Without the open world, Grand Theft Auto III wouldn’t be the same game.

Rockstar has stuck with this approach over the years, making each and every one of its game worlds indispensable in the context of narrative. Grand Theft Auto V simply would not work if we didn’t have the opportunity to explore the swanky faux Beverly Hills in addition to the poverty-stricken urban areas in Los Santos, or the desert just outside the city.

Unlimited power

For other games, however, increases in technical power weren’t seen as an opportunity to make environments more alive or relevant to world-building, but rather as a chance to simply make them as big as possible. Bigger than Skyrim. Twice the size of our last game. Bigger than anything we’ve done before.

assassins creed odyssey beginners guide to getting started assassin s  20180928113801
Assassin’s Creed Odyssey

It certainly sounds great in a trailer, and it’s a nice back-of-the-box bullet point, but what does that actually mean in practice? Does it lead to a richer experience, and can the open world justify its own existence?

Too often this generation, the answer to both questions has been “no.” Open worlds are being chosen not because they can offer a better experience, but because they can offer a bigger experience.

Why does the game have to be this big, and does it improve the moment-to-moment experience?

Ubisoft has oftentimes been the guiltiest of this, with nearly all of its single-player and cooperative games featuring enormous worlds filled with “stuff to do” that doesn’t always translate to better games.

The Ghost Recon series is a perfect example. 2012’s Ghost Recon: Future Soldier was a largely linear, mission-based tactical shooter, but it still managed to provide player agency despite its linear design, and there were plenty of big-budget blockbuster moments in the story. It set a solid foundation on which future games could be built.

Instead, Ubisoft took a different approach with Ghost Recon Wildlands, a game the company boasted has its biggest open world in history. The entirety of Bolivia is explorable, and it’s certainly breathtaking to look down at the map from a helicopter seat, but Wildlands is often downright boring as a result of this scale.

Ghost Recon Wildlands review
Ghost Recon Wildlands

Going from mission to mission takes several minutes of driving or flying with only canned banter to keep you company, and the missions themselves often feel cut-and-pasted. Rather than each element being great, everything is thrown at the wall in the hope that a few things stick. Those moments still feel amazing, but you have to cut through a lot of garbage to get there.

This approach shows few signs of slowing down; Assassin’s Creed has fallen victim to it in the past two iterations as well. Vast, detailed, and downright gorgeous, both Origins and Odyssey offer a level of meticulousness rarely seen in video games, but they sacrifice pacing to achieve this. The games come to grinding halts as you must prepare your level, abilities, and equipment before entering a new zone, with the finish line so distant that it’s almost invisible.

Less is more

There isn’t an easy solution to this, and the answer certainly isn’t to stop making open world games or even stop increasing the size of their worlds, but we need to start looking at the “why” rather than the “what.” Why does the game have to be this big, and does it improve the moment-to-moment experience?

no mans sky tips version 1471340423 man s 20160808075708
No Man’s Sky

It’s why No Man’s Sky was such a disappointment at launch: billions of planets to explore, but the only draw was exploring more of them, rather than truly enjoying the time you spent on your current planet. Without that, why would you want to continue at all? It’s like hating the food at a restaurant and then complaining about the small portion sizes.

I hope to be proven wrong. Perhaps a massive open-world game will come along that justifies its size — and in the case of creative sandboxes like Minecraft, they occasionally do. But look at Rockstar’s most recent Red Dead Redemption 2 videos for some insight into why their open worlds are so engaging. They don’t harp on the size, but rather what you can do, and the natural progression of your actions despite the many available options. The game is an open world because of the activities it holds. The activities aren’t included because it’s an open world.

That distinction is at the heart of a truly great open-world game, and those can’t be created simply by increasing their scope.

The views expressed here are solely those of the author and do not reflect the beliefs of Digital Trends.

Product Review

'Marvel's Spider-Man' slings and swings its way to the top of the superhero heap

Insomniac's entry into the superhero genre has a big suit to fill, but ‘Marvel's Spider-Man’ is a phenomenal action game, a strong Spider-Man story, and an open-world game that has plenty to do without getting boring.
Movies & TV

Ice meets fire in HBO's latest 'Game of Thrones' season 8 teaser

With the eighth and final season looming, Game of Thrones fever has officially become a pandemic. Our list of all the relevant news and rumors will help make the wait more bearable, if you don't mind spoilers.

PS4 vs. Switch: After weighing the pros and cons, which one comes out on top?

Nintendo Switch versus PlayStation 4: Which one has better overall value? We break down the pros and cons of each platform to tell you which of these consoles is truly worth the money.

Which new iPhone is the best? iPhone XS vs. iPhone XS Max vs. iPhone XR

Apple has three new iPhone models to choose from this year, making the choice a little harder than usual. What's the difference between the iPhone XS, the iPhone XS Max, and the iPhone XR, and which is best?

‘Street Fighter V’ players will get bonuses if they allow in-game ads

Capcom will show in-game advertisements on Street Fighter V starting December 11. Players may choose to deactivate the ads, but they will miss out on some bonuses and content if they do so.

‘The Walking Dead: The Final Season’ returns with Episode 3 next month

Skybound Games revealed the release date for Episode 3: Broken Toys of Telltale Games' The Walking Dead: The Final Season. Clementine's story will be getting the ending that it deserves after all.

Take-Two Interactive takes down another ‘GTA Online’ modder, seeks $150K

Take-Two Interactive and Rockstar Games have filed a lawsuit against the GTA Online modder behind the software named Elusive. The publisher is continuing its crackdown against GTA Online mods.

‘Fortnite’ streamer reportedly arrested after abusing wife while on Twitch

An Australian Fortnite streamer who goes by the name MrDeathMoth abused his pregnant wife while he was live on Twitch. An anonymous cybersecurity expert took matters into his own hands, resulting in the arrest of the streamer.

Miss Black Friday but still need an Xbox? Walmart has you covered

Black Friday and Cyber Monday have both come and gone, but you can still save some cash on a new Xbox One bundle at Walmart. Both the Xbox One S and the Xbox One X are on sale now.

Relive Nintendo’s handheld golden age with the 25 best Game Boy Advance games

The Game Boy Advance was the swan song of the Game Boy era. It also happened to have a boatload of amazing games. We decided to countdown our 25 favorite GBA games. Check it out and let us know your favorites in the comments below!

The most common Nintendo 3DS problems, and how to fix them

The Nintendo 3DS has seen its fair share of issues since it launched in 2011, including poor battery life and fragile Circle Pads. Here are some of the most common, as well as the steps you can take to solve them.

The Epic Games store is already luring indie studios away from Steam

The Epic Games Store is less than a week old, but it's already making waves among indie studios. Multiple studios have announced that their games will be timed exclusives on the Epic Games Store, with one studio forgoing Steam completely.

Bundle up for the huge ‘Monster Hunter: World’ expansion coming in 2019

Monster Hunter: World is getting a major expansion in fall 2019 called Iceborne. The expansion will be similar in scope as the Ultimate versions of previous Monster Hunter games, featuring new quests, monsters, weapons, and armor.

How to keep a PS4 in your pocket with the PlayStation Mobile app

Sony built the PlayStation 4 with smartphone and mobile integration in mind. Take a look at our guide for connecting your smartphone or tablet to a PS4, so you can browse profiles, trophies, and other content directly on your mobile device.