Skip to main content

Pikmin 3 review

Pikmin 3 screenshot 22
Image used with permission by copyright holder
“Pikmin 3 doesn't have enough of a mainstream hook to sell a ton of Wii Us, but it's one of the best and sharpest-looking games to date for Nintendo's new console.”
Pros
  • Story mode is paced well and delivers a solid risk/reward balance for your explorations
  • Gorgeous visuals make the most of the Wii U hardware
  • Mission and Bingo Battle modes provide multiple extra hours of Pikmin goodness
Cons
  • Multi-group micromanagement isn't as fun as it could be due to the rather helpless AI
  • Occasional fixed camera moments lead to frustrations and many Pikmin deaths

“Why you can trust Digital Trends – We have a 20-year history of testing, reviewing, and rating products, services and apps to help you make a sound buying decision. Find out more about how we test and score products.“

Pikmin 3 is an odd choice for a Wii U savior. Strip away the cute, little plant-like aliens and you’re left with a highly technical real-time strategy game that ditches epic-scale warfare in favor of exploration and environmental puzzle-solving.

Recommended Videos

It’s a calculated choice for kicking off the second wave of first-party Wii U titles, one that speaks to Nintendo’s awareness of its audience: Wii U owners are hardened fans that want to be serviced as such. Who needs a less-than Call of Duty port when you can revisit a classic series that also happens to be the subject of a long-asked-about sequel?

Plant life

Pikmin 3 charts the travels of three brave explorers from the planet Koppai. The people of their home world are dying out, victims of their own ravenous appetites. With no resources remaining to sustain the Koppaian people, probes are sent out across the galaxy in search of new food sources. One probe, sent to planet PNF-404, comes back positive, and that’s where our trio of explorers comes in.

… a quality game that speaks directly to the majority of the Wii U-owning public.

Captain Charlie and his crew, engineer Alph and botanist Brittany, set out to chart the distant world and plunder its ample supply of fruit. Two problems crop up shortly after their arrival: first, the fruit is big – far too large for them to carry on their own – and second, there’s nowhere to put the fruit after they make an emergency crash landing and are separated.

The latter issue works itself out over the first third of Pikmin 3‘s story, essentially a light tutorial built around reassembling both the crew and their ship, and solving that first problem with the help of PNF-404’s indigenous Pikmin. The friendly, multi-colored, plant-like beings swarm in large numbers all around the planet, and they’re perfectly willing to follow your every order, whether it involves lugging an outsized chunk of fruit or marching ever-forward to their certain death.

They’re brave little fellows, if not too bright. With their numbers, they could easily take down the three fruit gluttons and have a little carnivorous feast of their own.

Strategic exploration

The heart of Pikmin 3 is its story mode, a 10-ish hour adventure that sees you assembling your crew, gathering fruit, and solving a mystery that fits into the series’ larger story arc. Using the three Koppaians and the four types of Pikmin they eventually learn to farm, you wander through five highly varied environments that offer a mixture of fruit-finding, puzzle-solving and straight-up combat.

The perfectly-paced tutorial introduces each of the four Pikmin types – red, fireproof warriors, black, crystal-busting tanks, lightweight yellow critters that channel electricity, and tiny, pink fliers – while providing ample time to grow accustomed to using each one before introducing the next. All of this happens while you reassemble your crew and figure out just what the heck is up with this crazy planet.

Pikmin 3 screenshot 32
Image used with permission by copyright holder

Ordering your Pikmin “troops” around is as simple as choosing the color you want – that’s how they’re divided up as they follow you – and literally throwing them, one at a time, at the target of your choice. Your color choice is often determined by the situation. Red Pikmin are great for taking on enemies, but electrical fences will fry them. That’s where the weaker yellow Pikmin are handy; they’ll happily head butt any electric barrier into oblivion at your request.

Each of the five climate zones you visit over the course of the story amounts to a massive playground that slowly reveals itself as you gain access to new Pikmin. One of the very first zones you visit is returned to roughly two-thirds of the way in, the mystery stripped from its abundance of previously inaccessible locations.

Pikmin 3 screenshot 31
Image used with permission by copyright holder

Only time and resources limit your play. Time in terms of the hours of daylight on PNF-404; you can’t explore at night, so it’s important to gather all of your Pikmin “in the field” – a maximum of 100 – into your party before each day concludes at sundown to keep them from being eaten. Each finished day also consumes one container of juice on your ship, so it’s important to use the daylight hours to ferry fruits back to your ship while you’re exploring.

Some fruit is simply out in the open for the taking, but most of it is tucked away behind puzzles and an assortment of enemies, ranging from tiny non-threats to towering bosses that often take multiple days to finish off (damage done to a boss is persistent). Fruit juices keep your Koppaians happy and animal corpses swell your reserve supply of Pikmin forces.

Many moving parts

The flow of risk/reward in Pikmin 3 is very satisfying, with a moderate level of challenge that stumps for as long as it takes you to spot some environmental cue that you previously missed. A handy “restart day” feature encourages experimentation; 100 Pikmin might perish in a failed experiment, but you can get them back and attack a particular problem from a different angle, wiser than you were before.

… easily the best-looking Wii U game yet by a wide margin. The spaces you explore teem… with secrets potentially tucked away around any corner …

The spirit of playfulness is only occasionally marred by technical shortcomings. There’s a fiddly camera to contend with, one that sometimes switches to a fixed perspective to highlight some Important Thing or another. Unfortunately, this can happen when there are enemies in the vicinity, and your little Pikmin army will quickly disappear off-screen while you struggle to move out of the fixed camera zone.

Using your full crew to explore in different directions can also be a pain. Chucking Pikmin at one obstacle or another never feels tedious, but certain puzzles that require splitting up your crew – and the complement of Pikmin swarming around them – get a little sloggy at times. Worse, this dividing of your forces highlights a larger problem with troop management in Pikmin 3.

While the game is fundamentally a real-time strategy exercise, players have the ability to pause at any time and set waypoints for individual crewmembers. They and their Pikmin followers will dutifully march to the destination you’ve set, but the AI isn’t sharp enough to deal with – or even simply avoid – any threats that appear along the way.

The concept of splitting your forces and dividing your exploration efforts is sound, but it stumbles in the execution. There’s rarely any benefit to dividing your group up unless a particular puzzle requires it. You just don’t have enough time in the space of a single game day to make an area “safe” and then effectively split up to explore. Some players might have the patience for multi-group micromanagement, but in our experience it often consumes more time than it’s worth. 

This is a minor complaint in light of the bigger success, which amounts to a gorgeous HD rendering of Pikmin play that longtime Nintendo fans adore. Pikmin 3 is easily the best-looking Wii U game yet by a wide margin. The spaces you explore teem with life, with secrets potentially tucked away around any corner and under any bit of shrubbery.

It’s not just the story either. A separate multi-stage Mission mode and a local multiplayer Bingo Battle offer twists on the longer-term play of the core game. Both offer a more focused approach to various aspects of the game, usually with tighter time constraints and the added bonus of bringing back other breeds of Pikmin that don’t factor into the main story. It’s a surprisingly hefty chunk of extra content, especially the Mission mode.

Conclusion

Pikmin 3 is a victory for Nintendo’s struggling Wii U. It signals recognition on the company’s part that the broad success that defined the Wii is absent now. The hardcore niche that’s embraced the new console wants games like Pikmin, and they can enjoy the best effort for the series to date in Pikmin 3. This isn’t the “killer app” that Nintendo so desperately needs to knock the undecided off of their fence-top perches, but it remains a quality game that speaks directly to the majority of the Wii U-owning public.

This game was reviewed on a Wii U console using a digital download code that was provided by the publisher.

Highs

  • Story mode is paced well and delivers a solid risk/reward balance for your explorations
  • Gorgeous visuals make the most of the Wii U hardware
  • Mission and Bingo Battle modes provide multiple extra hours of Pikmin goodness

Lows

  • Multi-group micromanagement isn’t as fun as it could be due to the rather helpless AI
  • Occasional fixed camera moments lead to frustrations and many Pikmin deaths

(This game was reviewed on the Wii U using a copy provided by the publisher)

Adam Rosenberg
Former Gaming/Movies Editor
Previously, Adam worked in the games press as a freelance writer and critic for a range of outlets, including Digital Trends…
Analogue’s 4K Nintendo 64 is coming next year, but you can preorder it next week
An Analogue 3D on a grab background. It looks like a black N64. In front are a controller and to the side are some N64 cartridges.

Analogue, the retro hardware emulation company, has officially delayed the Analogue 3D, its Nintendo 64 console. However, it released the first images of the console to tide us over until it launches next year.

The Analogue 3D was originally announced in October 2023 for a 2024 release, but the company announced Wednesday that it'll now be aiming for a release in the first quarter of 2025. It'll cost $250, come in black and white colors, and preorders will open up at 8 a.m. PT on October 21 on the Analogue website. This doesn't include a controller, but Analogue partnered with 8BitDo to create a Bluetooth N64 controller you can buy separately for $40.

Read more
Best Meta Quest 3 deals: Get Asgard Wrath 2 for free and more
A product shot of the Meta Quest 3 shown in dramatic lighting over a gradient background.

While VR isn't as big of a booming industry as some hoped it would be, there are a few great VR headsets out there you can snag that don't need you to also buy an expensive gaming PC. For example, the Meta Quest 3 is an entirely self-contained VR device that is supported by Meta, so it has a reasonably big library and a lot of options when it comes to games and apps. Not only that, but the Meta Quest 3 has some nice upgrades, such as better lenses and a great resolution, and there is even a subscription membership that gives you access to free games. Alternatively, if you'd rather go for something a bit more budget-friendly, you could check out these Meta Quest 2 deals.
Today's best Meta Quest 3 deals
Meta Quest 3 (128GB, Renewed Premium) -- $480 $500 4% off

If you buy the 128GB model of the Meta Quest 3 for its sticker price from Amazon or Best Buy, you'll also get a copy of Asgard's Wrath II. In this sequel to one of the most critically acclaimed VR games, you'll be battling gods and monsters in an epic action RPG using unique weapons and different combat styles. The VR headset comes with a pair of Touch Plus controllers with wrist straps.

Read more
Meta Quest 3’s Home Sports is a mixed reality take on Wii Sports
The key art for Home Sports.

Home Sports is a new Meta Quest 3 game from Demeo developer Resolution Games. Think Wii SportsĀ if it were a VR game with mixed reality elements.

Resolution Games has a solid track record with VR video games on Meta Quest and mixed reality games for headsets like the Apple Vision Pro. Now, it's leveraging that expertise to make a sports game collection, which Wii Sports proved is one of the most intuitive ways to get people to understand a funky gaming hardware concept. Using the Meta Quest 3's mixed reality features, Home Sports essentially turns your room into the play space for these sports.

Read more