Skip to main content

Alexa, Siri, and Google Assistant can hear silent commands that you can’t

Amazon Echo Plus review aux plugged in
Bill Roberson/Digital Trends

A series of studies have proven that it’s possible to secretly give silent commands to voice assistants like Amazon Alexa and Google Assistant without their owners ever knowing.

According to the New York Times, researchers in both China and the U.S. have carried out a series of experiments which ultimately proved that it’s possible to communicate silent commands that are undetectable to the human ear to voice assistants like Siri, Alexa and Google Assistant.

The findings call to light a variety of security concerns as they reveal just how vulnerable voice assistant data could be.

In one study conducted by Georgetown University and University of California, Berkeley in 2016, student researchers successfully hid secret voice commands with the help of white noise. The students were able to get smart devices to switch over to airplane mode and navigate to websites by hiding commands to do so in white noise that way played through YouTube videos and loudspeakers.

White noise essentially overrides any other sounds around it due to the fact that white noise is a mixture of all the sound frequencies the human ear can detect. By inserting a smart speaker command into white noise, the researchers essentially camouflaged the commands from human listeners.

Taking the research to the next level, some of the same Berkeley researchers published a paper this month, in which they demonstrated that they could insert silent commands into spoken text and music files. While you might think you’re listening to an audiobook or a piece of classical music, your smart speaker could be receiving a litany of commands telling it to change its settings or purchase items from your Amazon account.

So far, there’s nothing to suggest that such subliminal messages have been successful outside of a student research setting, but one of the Berkeley paper’s authors says he believes it’s just a matter of time: “My assumption is that the malicious people already employ people to do what I do,” he told the New York Times.

As the Times points out, voice recognition systems are set up to recognize each sound you make as a letter, which the system then collects into complete words and phrases.

What these research studies prove is that it’s possible to manipulate speech recognition gadgets by making minute changes to speech or other audio files. In doing so, you could essentially override the message the voice assistant is supposed to receive and substitute it with sounds that will be interpreted differently, thus giving the voice assistant a different command that would be virtually unrecognizable to the human ear.

According to the coverage in the Times, both Amazon and Google have taken measures to protect their smart speakers and voice assistants against such manipulations. Individual user voice recognition is one such protocol that could prevent such silent commands from being successful: if your smart speaker is calibrated to only respond to your voice, a silent command should, in theory, not have an effect on it.

Editors' Recommendations

Kayla Matthews
Kayla Matthews has written about smart homes and technology for Houzz, Dwell, Curbed and Inman. She is a senior writer for…
Alexa can now tell you when a package is delivered
Senior citizen using Alexa to stay connected

Amazon has always wanted to have Alexa become the end-all and be-all assistant. Thanks to a new update, it's one step closer. Alexa can now tell you if it sees a person or a package through one of your security cameras. Also, if you have an Echo Show or a Fire TV, Alexa can automatically pull up a live video feed of the subject.

Amazon recently allowed third-party companies to tap into this new feature by revealing a new API. As a result, companies such as Google, Ring, and Abode have already added person recognition to their video security doorbells. According to Amazon, all of Ring's video doorbells and cameras should be updated now, while Google's Nest Cam Indoor, Nest Cam Outdoor, Nest Cam Floodlight, and Nest Doorbell will receive the update soon. In addition, Abode's IOTA and Outdoor Camera will also receive the update.

Read more
Google Assistant and YouTube Music coming to Galaxy Watch 4
Watch 4 media controls.

Google is building on its close partnership with Samsung to bring the Galaxy Watch 4 deeper into the Android ecosystem, with new communication, productivity, and entertainment features.

In the coming weeks, new Galaxy Watch 4 owners will be able to install and set up Google Play apps during the initial configuration process, right out of the box. Your favorite apps from your Android smartphone will show up as recommendations on your new Watch 4, so you can quickly install them with a single tap without the need to hunt for them on the Play Store.

Read more
How to talk to Santa with Alexa and Google Assistant
How to get your last-minute requests to Santa with Alexa and Google Home
Alexa hey santa on Echo Show

We're all more connected than ever before, so naturally, that connectivity extends to how we communicate with the big guy in the red suit. If you have a Google Assistant-enabled device or one with Alexa digital assistant built in, you can talk directly to Santa during the holiday season. You can also listen to Christmas stories, sing carols, and find out if you're on the naughty or nice list, all just by asking.

Not sure where to begin? Check out the voice commands that will get you started with Google Assistant and Amazon's Alexa—and what sort of experiences they will launch. Pick which one looks like the most fun or try them all out.
Google Assistant and Santa Claus

Read more