6 reasons you should buy an Amazon Echo over an Apple HomePod

amazon echo over apple homepod
Bill Roberson/Digital Trends
Bill Roberson/Digital Trends

So the wait is over, and the Apple HomePod is finally available. We had high hopes for this smart speaker equipped with voice assistant Siri. But while the sound quality of the $350 device is incredible, to say we’re disappointed by its “smarts” is an understatement.

As our reviewer Caleb Denison points out in his Digital Trends review of the HomePod, it’s less of a smart speaker and more like a great-sounding speaker with half-baked artificial intelligence. Yikes.

Until Apple adds more capabilities to the HomePod and opens the door to more companies (more on that later), we’re going to recommend that you stick with an Amazon Echo device instead. Here’s why.

1. The Echo is much, much cheaper

You can get a second-generation Amazon Echo for $85, or a small-but-still-mighty Echo Dot for $40 right now. Even if you opt for a more expensive Echo device, like the Echo Show, Plus, or Spot, you’re still paying no more than $180. That’s about half the price of the HomePod, which is selling for $350 right now at Best Buy.

2. The Echo doesn’t care what kind of phone you have

You can download the Amazon Alexa app using any smartphone — iOS or Android — and be setting up your Echo device in no time. With the HomePod, you can only connect with an iOS device running the latest software. That means that if you don’t have an iPhone 5S or later, iPad Mini 2 or later, or iPod Touch 6th-gen or later, you’re screwed. No HomePod for you!

3. The Echo has versatile looks

The 2nd-gen Echo comes in six different colors, and you can switch out the shells of the Echo if you get tired of a single look. You can choose from fabric, metallic, or wood-like materials. If you want a different Echo, say with a screen, you can choose the Echo Show or the Echo Spot, which can show you videos and let you search through pictures. The HomePod comes in only black or white, with no other devices or screens available.

4. The Echo has queen Alexa

While it’s true that Siri started the voice assistant craze, Alexa has become the queen of voice assistants. Alexa can do so much — play games, shop, tell jokes, give traffic information, or even turn off lights and lock doors — all with just a voice command. Recent upgrades to the Alexa platform mean that you can set her up to recognize your voice over your partner’s (something Siri cannot do with the HomePod), and activate skills that range from having Alexa order you Starbucks in the morning or letting celebrity chef Gordon Ramsay yell at you about how bad your cooking is (if you’re into that).

But perhaps the biggest argument for an Echo is the sheer number of smart home devices that you can connect to. From thermostats to video cameras, there are literally thousands of smart home devices that are Alexa-compatible, with more on the way. The list of Apple HomeKit enabled devices is much shorter, although we can expect the list to grow now that the HomePod is available.

amazon echo vs apple homepod
Amazon
Amazon

5. The Echo lets you stream any music service

Is Pandora your poison, or are you serious about Spotify? Whether you have a preference for a streaming music platform or dabble in all kinds, all of it works on an Echo device. All you do is connect your accounts in the Alexa app and then you can tell her to play your Britney Spears playlist. Hey, we’re not judging.

The HomePod isn’t so versatile. The only streaming music you’ll get Siri to play for you on the device is from — you guessed it — Apple Music. You can get some streaming music via AirPlay to work, but for now, we’re waiting on Apple to relax their policies and let other platforms in.

6. The Echo lets you connect to other speakers and play multi-room audio

The one major thing that the HomePod has on the Echo is incredible sound — there’s no denying that. But all Echo devices have Bluetooth connectivity and/or a 3.5mm cable jack, so you can connect any high-quality speaker you want. Plus, if you have more than one Echo device, you can ask Alexa to play the same audio across all your speakers. Siri and the HomePod do not yet have that ability.

Product Review

Bigger. Smarter. Louder. The Echo Plus makes Alexa sound better than ever

Amazon’s second-generation Echo Plus speaker is the loudest, bassiest speaker in the Echo fleet. While featuring a smart hub with only Zigbee connectivity, other upgrades make this device a worthy smart speaker.
Smart Home

Amazon Echo vs. Echo Plus: Which should you get?

If you're trying to choose between the Amazon Echo or the Echo Plus, then this guide is for you. It compares the two Alexa-enabled speakers in cost, size, looks, functionality, and more.
Product Review

Alexa, annoy my neighbors! The Echo Sub brings the boom you've been missing

Amazon’s Echo Sub is aimed at Echo speaker owners looking to inject some room-moving bass into their smart speaker experience. We quickly learned that it’s a niche product, but one that does its odd job extremely well.
Smart Home

Here are the five new Amazon Echo devices available now

Shipping begins on five new Amazon devices, including the Echo Show, Echo Plus, Echo Dot, Echo Sub, and an Alexa-enabled smart plug. Here's a bit more about each device, as well as cost and how to buy.
Smart Home

May the force cook with you: New slow cooker sports Star Wars figures

We can't say it will make your pot roast tastier, but Uncanny Brands' $50 Star Wars Slow Cooker, decorated with cartoon figures of Luke, Leia, Darth Vader, and other characters, might make cooking it more fun.
Smart Home

Gas dryers vs. electric dryers: Knowing the difference could save you some dough

Whether you buy an electric dryer or a gas dryer may depend solely on your setup, unless you want to spend money to get a gas hookup for your home. But if you have a choice, there are some differences to take into account.
Smart Home

Is your smart home lighting too confusing? Intellect simplifies your controls

Leviton introduced Intellect, a new controls platform for smart home lighting. Intellect is the fifth brand to join Leviton's portfolio, alongside ConTech, Intense, Birchwood, and JCC.
Smart Home

These awesome treehouses will make you question life on solid ground

Check out these truly awesome treehouses from around the world. From a three-story treehouse in the Costa Rican jungle to a mirrored cube hidden among the trees of Sweden, we’ve got you covered.
Smart Home

Nest gets more colorful with three new options for its smart thermostat

Nest Parent company Alphabet announced this week that its Nest Learning Thermostat will soon be made available in three new, fancier colors: Mirror black, brass, and polished steel.
Smart Home

Publish a new Alexa skill this month and Amazon will give you an Echo Dot

Amazon' Alexa group announced a promotion encouraging new developers to publish a new Alexa skill in any country First-time developers who publish a new an Alexa skill prior to midnight October 31, 2018, will get a free Echo Dot.
Smart Home

August Smart Lock satin nickel model comes bundled with Wi-Fi Connect bridge

The August Smart Lock--one of our favorite smart locks--is now available in a satin nickel finish. August is selling the new model in a $220 bundle with the Wi-Fi bridge needed for remote access and voice command features.
Smart Home

LG’s Colosseo smart sofa is the comfiest piece of tech in your home

LG has partnered with Italian furniture brand Natuzzi to produce the Colosseo, a connected sofa with five custom scenarios to provide maximum comfort for watching TV, reading, or just relaxing.
Smart Home

Simplisafe steps outside the smart home with its Video Doorbell Pro

SimpiSafe is pushing into the smart home market by introducing a new high-tech video doorbell that includes 1080p HD monitoring and a dual-sensor motion trigger that combines a body heat detector and a motion detector.
Smart Home

Facebook’s new Portal device can collect your data to target your ads

Facebook confirmed that its new Portal smart displays, designed to enable Messenger-enabled video calls, technically have the capability to gather data on users via the camera and mic onboard.