Skip to main content

Facebook forced to face class action lawsuit over children’s online purchases

Fire HD 6 Kids Edition
Facebook must change how it handles online transactions made by minors. That’s the message a group of plaintiffs estimated in the hundreds of thousands have for the social network, and now they can push forward with their nationwide class-action lawsuit against the social network, reports Reuters.

U.S. District Judge Beth Labson Freeman in San Jose, California gave the plaintiffs the thumbs-up earlier this week to push forward with their lawsuit, which asks for Facebook to provide refunds for those whose children spent their money without their permission. J.R. Parker, a lawyer for the plaintiffs, was pleased with the decision.

Related Videos

Facebook believes the lawsuit lacks any merit, and said the plaintiffs’ claims were very disparate.

“We’re very pleased with the decision,” Parker told the outlet. “The difference between Facebook and other businesses is that the company is on actual notice of a user’s age, but treats children the same as adult users when it comes to taking their money.”

According to the judge, while the people can’t pursue refunds as a group — since their situations would vary on a case-by-case basis — they can seek individual refunds. The lawsuit, originally brought forth in April of 2012, said Facebook allowed children to use their parents’ credit and debit cards to purchase Facebook Credit, the social network’s now-defunct virtual currency. The lawsuit also said Facebook violated California law by not allowing refunds, thanks to its “all sales are final” policy.

The lawsuit was brought forth by two children and their parents. One child was allowed to spend $20 on Ninja Saga using his mother’s credit card, but was later charged several hundred dollars for purchases with “virtual, in-game currency.” The other child used his parents’ debit card without permission, spending $1,059.

Facebook believes the lawsuit lacks any merit, and said the plaintiffs’ claims were very disparate. With the lawsuit now moving forward, Facebook said it will defend itself vigorously.

Judge Freeman said California law protects parents and their children in instances where children “occasionally use their lack of judgment” when purchasing things they shouldn’t have bought in the first place.

“Though some minors undoubtedly may wish to continue making purchases through credit or debit cards they do not have permission to use, such a desire cannot prevent the named plaintiffs from bringing suit to demand that Facebook’s policies comply with the law,” said the judge.

Unfortunately for Facebook, this isn’t the first time a company has come under scrutiny for this. Apple found itself in a very similar situation at the start of 2014, and the company eventually had toreimburse customers to the tune of $32.5 million. Google also agreed to issue refunds to similarly affected customers to the tune of $19 million, while also making changes to the Play Store to make it more difficult for children to make in-app purchases without permission. Amazon, meanwhile, was sued by the FTC, though there is still no resolution to the case.

Editors' Recommendations

Your Apple Card will soon get its own savings account – here’s what it looks like
Apple Card Savings

Apple just announced that Apple Card users will be able to grow accumulated Daily Cash rewards by depositing the money into a savings account with high-yield rates from Goldman Sachs. This new feature will be rolling out in the coming months, so it is not immediately available.

Apple Card launched in 2019 as a partnership between Apple and Goldman Sachs. While you could get a premium, titanium card with no numbers or information on it (besides your name), the main focus of Apple Card was Apple Pay. The Apple Card lives in the Wallet app, where you can view your balance and transactions, make payments, view statements, and more.

Read more
Meta found over 400 mobile apps ‘designed to steal’ Facebook logins
Social media mobile apps on a smartphone screen, all on a textured gray fabric background.

If you frequently use your Facebook login to sign into new mobile apps you've installed, you may want to pay attention to Meta's latest announcement.

On Friday, Facebook's parent company Meta published a blog post written by its Director of Threat Disruption David Agranovich, and Ryan Victory, a Malware Discovery and Detection engineer at Meta. The post detailed Meta's discovery of over 400 mobile apps "that target people across the internet to steal their Facebook login information." Essentially, Meta found hundreds of mobile apps that were "designed to steal"  the login information of Facebook users by having those users log in to these apps with their Facebook login information.

Read more
Google is paying a historic $85 million fine after illegally tracking Android phones
Google Logo

Google will be paying Arizona $85 million in a settlement over a 2020 lawsuit that claimed the company was illegally tracking Android users for targeted advertising.

According to a report from Bloomberg, Attorney General Mark Brnovich filed a lawsuit in May 2020 claiming that Google violated the state's Consumer Fraud Act by gathering location data from Android users, even after people turned off their location settings. At the time, Google's own employees were confused about its privacy controls, admitting that it could use some fine-tuning so that when users deny the company permission to track their data, it has to respect their decision.

Read more