Germany bans sales of children’s smartwatches due to eavesdropping fears

By Steven Winkelman November 17, 2017

Simon Hill/Digital Trends

Kurio Kids — Simon Hill/Digital Trends

Germany’s national telecommunications agency, the Federal Network Agency, on Friday banned the sale of children’s smartwatches and advised parents to destroy any devices they may currently have. The watches were classified as “prohibited listening devices” by the agency, which said these devices could be used by parents to listen to their children without their knowledge.

While the agency did not mention security concerns in its announcement, it comes nearly a month after the European Consumer Organization (BEUC) issued a report citing privacy and safety concerns with many of the smartwatch manufacturers. In its report, published last month by the Norwegian Consumer Council, the BEUC warned parents these devices may have vulnerabilities that could make stealing data or hacking the device relatively easy. The organization even found one of the smartwatches providing unencrypted location information to servers in China.

Recommended Videos

Children’s smart devices, such as smartwatches, cameras, and other toys, are internet-enabled devices that capture and transmit data to third-parties. The watches frequently use cameras, microphones and GPS trackers to allow parents to track their children in real time. If this data is not properly transmitted or stored, however, attackers could use this information to track and contact children without their parent’s consent.

Smartwatches are not the first children’s device to be prohibited by the Federal Network Agency. Earlier this year, the agency banned the My Friend Cayla smart doll over fears the device could be hacked and children’s data illegally collected.

Although German authorities banned children’s smartwatches, the U.S. is being more conservative, issuing a public service announcement earlier this year. The announcement, issued by the FBI, warned children’s smart devices can “record and collect conversations within earshot of the device. Information such as the child’s name, school, like and dislikes, and activities may be disclosed through normal conversation with the toy or in the surrounding environment.”

The FBI urges parents to use the devices with caution and examine user agreements and privacy practices, as well as know where their data will be stored.. It also urges parents to ensure devices are turned off when not in use.

Editors' Recommendations

Topics

Steven Winkelman

Former Digital Trends Contributor

Steven writes about technology, social practice, and books. At Digital Trends, he focuses primarily on mobile and wearables…

News

Casio’s newest PRO TREK smartwatch finally adds heart rate monitoring

Serious runners and outdoor athletes look to a handful of brands when they want the best wearable to connect them with the outdoors and track their ventures throughout. While Casio may have a place in such discussions, the lack of a heart rate monitor on its wearables seriously hindered that consideration for some. Finally, the newly announced PRO TREK WSD-F21HR changes this with Casio’s first hear rate-enabled smartwatch.

Focused on tracking and facilitating runs, cycles, and climbs via GPS and heart rate monitoring, this $500 Google WearOS-running wearable offers the durability, usability, and range of sensors needed to help you keep track of your exercise and the world around you.

Wearables

It has LTE and a voice assistant, but the DokiPal kid’s smartwatch is a letdown

We're seeing a wave of new smartwatches designed for kids hitting the market, but the DokiPal claims superiority as the first to support 4G LTE and an integrated voice assistant. The sound idea behind the rise of kids smartwatches is that they act as a basic phone for youngsters who aren't ready for a proper phone yet. Parents can track their child's location and call or message them and because the watch is strapped to their wrist, meaning there's less risk it's going to be lost. The DokiPal also offers basic fitness tracking, geofencing, a camera and photo editor, and IP68 water resistance.

The DokiPal is one of the most expensive kids smartwatches out there at $179 and, if you want to use the data-only 4G LTE Doki SIM, you're looking at paying $10 per month on top. Hong Kong-based Doki Technologies recommends the DokiPal for kids aged five years and up. I tested it with my 10-year-old son Malcolm to see how well it works.

Wearables

Xplora 3S impressions: A kids smartwatch for calls and location tracking

The Xplora 3S smartwatch keeps you connected to your kids and alerts of trouble

The kids smartwatch scene has taken off in the last few years with a host of companies clamoring to get in on the action. Some of these smartwatches are designed to entertain, while some are billed as a way to stay in touch and track your children. The Xplora 3S falls into the second camp. Xplora is suggesting the 3S might serve as your child's first smartphone, because it can accommodate a SIM card to make and take calls. It's also waterproof, tracks steps, has a camera, and supports location tracking with a geo-fence feature.

At 100 British Pounds (around $125), the Xplora 3S is quite expensive and you have to pay for cell service on top of that. On the other hand, it's significantly cheaper than all of our suggested phones for kids and it's harder to lose, since it's strapped to your little angel's wrist. I tried out the Xplora 3S with my seven year-old daughter Amy to see how well it works.
Durable design
It's no Apple Watch, but the Xplora 3S is a well-built smartwatch that feels durable. Like a lot of kid's tech, it comes in an unimaginative choice of blue or pink. It's fairly light at 50 grams, and it's comfortable to wear, according to Amy, though it inevitably looks big on a child's wrist. Xplora suggests the 3S can be used by kids from age 3 to 12 years.