Skip to main content

Google tells European Commission that Android offers 'choice at every turn'

google android choice at every turn nougat
Image used with permission by copyright holder
Google has published an open response against anti-competitive claims made by the European Commission regarding its Android mobile operating system, and its argument focuses heavily on “choice.”

“The Commission’s case is based on the idea that Android doesn’t compete with Apple’s iOS,” writes Kent Walker, a senior vice president and general counsel at Google. “We don’t see it that way. We don’t think Apple does either. Or phone makers. Or developers. Or users. In fact, 89 percent of respondents to the Commission’s own market survey confirmed that Android and Apple compete. To ignore competition with Apple is to miss the defining feature of today’s competitive smartphone landscape.”

As to Android, Google says, “no manufacturer is obliged” to pre-load any Google apps — the Google suite is offered so that users will get a “familiar set of basic services,” but manufacturers can pre-install rival apps as well. The Mountain View, California company says that while the European Commission doesn’t think Google should offer any pre-installed services, competitors “not only do the same, but they allow much less choice in the apps that come with their phones.”

Through a variety of GIFs, the search giant shows off how open to choice Android is when compared to Windows and iOS. The firm contends that 39 out of 39 pre-installed apps on the iPhone are from Apple, and that 39 out of 47 pre-installed apps on Windows 10 mobile are from Microsoft. On the Samsung Galaxy S7, however, only 11 out of 38 pre-installed apps are from Google.

But the European Commission nevertheless has a problem with Google Play, namely that it’s a must-have on Android devices produced by other manufacturers. This gives Google an edge in its bargaining position when it comes to deploying its services on these devices. Google’s counterargument is that the Play Store carriers plenty of competing, third-party apps that are thriving.

For example, apps like Snapchat, Dropbox, and Spotify directly compete with some of Google’s services that come pre-installed, like Play Music and Drive, yet they manage to pull in millions of users on the Android platform.

“Our apps suite approach explicitly preserves users’ freedom to choose the apps they want on their phones,” Kent writes.

Google also says it works with manufacturers to ensure a minimum “level of compatibility” so that developers can ensure their apps will work on a multitude of devices — so that the operating system isn’t privy to fragmentation.

“That flexibility makes Android vulnerable to fragmentation, a problem that plagued previous operating systems like Unix and Symbian,” says Kent. “When anyone can modify your code, how do you ensure there’s a common, consistent version of the operating system, so that developers don’t have to go through the hassle and expense of building multiple versions of their apps?”

Along with maintaining a base level of compatibility, the search giant says it also offers all its services for free, without any licensing fees, and that’s a benefit that affects phone makers and consumers.

With Google’s response in, we’ll have to wait for the European Commission to look it over and make a decision.

Editors' Recommendations

Julian Chokkattu
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Julian is the mobile and wearables editor at Digital Trends, covering smartphones, fitness trackers, smartwatches, and more…
Google Chrome is getting the Android tablet update you’ve been waiting for
Google Chrome app on s8 screen.

Google today announced the release of its redesign for the Chrome app on Android tablets. After long being neglected on the big screen, especially in comparison to Apple's or Samsung's browsers, Google says it'll be rebuilding the browser to help you get work done faster with a tablet or other large-screened device.

These updates can be broken down into design and functionality improvements, and we'll be kicking things off with the redesign. The first change adds a new side-by-side design when using Chrome paired with another app. This comes with an auto-scroll back feature so you can swipe between tabs, hiding the close buttons when your tabs are too small to prevent mis-taps — plus the inclusion of a restore feature.

Read more
Google is paying a historic $85 million fine after illegally tracking Android phones
Google Logo

Google will be paying Arizona $85 million in a settlement over a 2020 lawsuit that claimed the company was illegally tracking Android users for targeted advertising.

According to a report from Bloomberg, Attorney General Mark Brnovich filed a lawsuit in May 2020 claiming that Google violated the state's Consumer Fraud Act by gathering location data from Android users, even after people turned off their location settings. At the time, Google's own employees were confused about its privacy controls, admitting that it could use some fine-tuning so that when users deny the company permission to track their data, it has to respect their decision.

Read more
Google wants you to know Android apps aren’t just for phones anymore
Person holding Samsung Galaxy smartphone showing Google Play Store.

When most people think of the Google Play Store, the first thing that comes to mind is smartphones. However, the spread of the Android ecosystem is far broader than that, and Google is taking steps to increase awareness of this and make it easier for folks to find apps on the Play Store for their smart TVs, watches, and even cars.

In a blog post today, the Google Play team announced three significant changes that should make it easier for Android fans to discover apps for all their devices, right from their phone. This includes recommendations of apps for non-phone devices, a search filter to focus on only games optimized for non-phone devices, and even a remote install feature that will let you deliver those apps to your Android TV, Wear OS watch, or Android Automotive-equipped car.

Read more