Skip to main content

Dredd 3D Review: The Judge is back, better than ever

Dredd 3D reviewLet’s get this out of the way right at the start: To call Dredd 3D a remake of Sylvester Stallone’s laughable 1995 film is akin to calling Christopher Nolan’s Batman Begins a remake of Adam West’s Batman: The Movie. Neither film was created with its predecessor in mind, and both films are based on characters that existed long before they made their big-screen debuts.

Most importantly, however, is the fact that both Dredd 3D and Batman Begins offer what is arguably the most accurate, faithful big-screen interpretations of the comic-book characters that inspired them, and showcase exactly what’s made both characters so popular over the years.

Directed by Pete Travis (Vantage Point), Dredd 3D features Karl Urban (Star Trek, The Lord of the Rings trilogy) as Judge Dredd, one of the many stoic law-enforcement agents charged with protecting the residents of Mega-City One, a massive urban sprawl that stretches across the East Coast. After most of the world was rendered uninhabitable by the fallout of nuclear war, the surviving populace is now crowded into a series of high-reaching “city blocks” containing thousands of people, with the Justice Department’s roaming Judges delivering on-the-spot sentencing for law-breakers.

When Judge Dredd and his partner are called to one such city block to investigate a crime, their actions attract the attention of violent gangleader Ma-Ma (Lena Headey) who puts the entire building on lockdown and tasks her gang with making sure the judges don’t leave the facility alive.

Image used with permission by copyright holder

In the wrong hands, it’s a story that could feel too small for a character as popular as Judge Dredd, but Travis and screenwriter Alex Garland (The Beach, 28 Days Later) have done an impressive job of making it a perfectly-fitted introduction to both the main character and the dystopian world he inhabits. When surviving the day is a legitimate concern each and every day, there’s little room for humor and the sort of forced pathos that took the 1995 film so far astray from its source material, and this is a situation Dredd 3D seems keenly aware of, opting to fill out the story with wince-inducing ultra-violence that’s more appropriate for a bleak, savage environment like Mega-City One.

Still, Dredd 3D manages to mine quite a bit of beauty from this abundance of violence, with Travis showing an uncanny knack for slow-motion shots that are not only organic to the story (many of the characters use a drug that makes time seem to slow down), but also serve a real purpose in spotlighting certain elements of the action sequences. It’s an approach that directors like Zack Snyder would do well to study, as it elevates slo-mo from filmmaking gimmick to legitimate storytelling device.

As for Urban himself, the veteran actor goes a long way toward erasing memories of Stallone’s version of Dredd. Staying true to his comics counterpart, Urban’s Dredd is never seen without his helmet, and he manages to be a character you can root for despite sporting an ever-present frown and little-to-no emotion. Judge Dredd isn’t an easy character for an actor to inhabit if you stay true to his roots, as he’s devoid of any interest in human relationships and is almost robotic in his single-minded adherence to the law. Essentially, he’s more Robocop than actual living, breathing cop, but Urban does a brilliant job of making the character seem less a caricature and more the urban antihero and product of the environment he’s supposed to be.

Image used with permission by copyright holder

Headey also serves up a memorably vicious character in prostitute-turned-gangleader Ma-Ma, and Game of Thrones fans will probably see some similarities between the cold contempt for life she shows in this film and her take on Cersei Lannister, the calculating matriarch she plays in the HBO television series. Olivia Thirlby is relegated to a second- or third-tier supporting role in the film as Dredd’s psychic partner, Judge Anderson, though she makes the best out of the role and most importantly, doesn’t distract from Urban’s performance as Dredd.


Chock full of impressive action sequences and talented actors packed into a fantasticly detailed, grimy set, Dredd 3D is the movie the character has always deserved, and proves that you don’t need the intimidating budget and star-power of a Hollywood tentpole film to bring a character like Judge Dredd to life on the big screen.

Much like what Nolan and Bale did with Batman Begins, Travis and Urban have identified the most essential elements of the character and built a story around those qualities rather than the other way around. It’s an approach that anyone looking to make a comic-book movie would do well to embrace, and here’s hoping audiences give Dredd 3D the warm welcome it deserves.

Editors' Recommendations

Rick Marshall
A veteran journalist with more than two decades of experience covering local and national news, arts and entertainment, and…
3 PBS shows you should watch in June 2024
The cast of Grantchester.

One of the secrets of PBS' success is that many of its best shows actually originate from the United Kingdom. In fact, all three of our picks for the three PBS shows that you should watch in June 2024 are British originals. Grantchester and D.I. Ray are both mystery dramas, while the documentary about disco is produced by BBC and making its American debut this month.

These are just a few of the new shows on PBS in June. There's a lot to watch, especially if you want to go back and revisit the great PBS shows to watch in May as well. Remember, PBS is free. All you have to do is make time for it.

Read more
Don’t let these 3 June 2024 hidden streaming movie gems fly under your radar
The cast of The Wedding Banquet laying on the grass and smiling for the camera.

June brings new movies on Netflix, Amazon, Max, and pretty much every other major streaming service. Pride Month is also the perfect time to uplift and showcase new voices, and that includes venturing outside one's entertainment comfort zone and exploring new and underappreciated movies.

These underrated films are ideal for this momentous month. From undervalued and underseen gems of LGBTQ+ cinema to films that flew under the radar on their original release, these cinematic projects deserve more love from audiences. So celebrate Pride Month by giving them a chance -- ideally, you'll discover something new, not to mention you'll get to enjoy a film you might've not been aware of before.
My Beautiful Laundrette (1985)

Read more
I hated, hated, hated this 2023 movie that everyone else loved. Here’s why
5 football players sit at a table in Bottoms.

It's not a stretch to say that 2023 was a pretty great year for movies. Between successes like Oppenheimer and Barbie, acclaimed darlings like Poor Things and Anatomy of a Fall, and unexpected hits like Godzilla Minus One and Anyone but You, the film industry thrived last year. However, as usually happens, more than a few films earned far more acclaim than they should have, at least in this writer's opinion. I've written already about my dislike for Emerald Fennell's Saltburn, but that was a divisive film that had far more detractors than just me. On the contrary, Emma Seligman's teen comedy Bottoms received near-universal acclaim, and I can't, for the life of me, understand why.

Bottoms isn't necessarily bad, strictly speaking; it's not a true abomination like, say, Ghosted or The Flash. However, it's also not the teen triumph it was anointed to be by most critics and the internet. Instead, it's a rather average movie that is not nearly as subversive or clever as it pretends to be. In fact, compared to other entries in the raunchy teen genre, it's painfully mediocre, and the more praise it got, the more I disliked it. And while "hate" might be a strong word, especially when talking about a movie, it's a pretty succinct, if slightly exaggerated, way to describe my feelings towards Bottoms.
What is it exactly that we're looking at here?

Read more