Skip to main content

Like the hit Netflix documentary Lover, Stalker, Killer? Then watch these 3 great docs right now

Dave Kroupa in Lover, Stalker, Killer.

True crime documentaries almost always play well on Netflix, but Lover, Stalker, Killer is the rare doc to land on top of the most popular movies on Netflix. One of the reasons why may be that it features the man at the center of the story, Dave Kroupa, as both a participant and an actor in the reenactments of his own story. As Kroupa relates it, he was casually dating Shanna Elizabeth “Liz” Golyar before also seeing Cari Farver. And when Kroupa’s relationship with Farver went sour, he received numerous threats and harassing messages from her. But there’s far more to the story than that.

Unlike many other Netflix true crime stories, Lover, Stalker, Killer is only a feature length documentary. If you liked this film and you’re looking for your next true crime binge, then these three documentaries are the ones you should watch next.

American Nightmare

Promo art of a woman from Netflix's American Nightmare.

If you’ve ever seen the excellent David Fincher movie Gone Girl, than the real-life case of Aaron Quinn and Denise Huskins may sound familiar. American Nightmare recounts the 2015 home invasion incident in which Huskins was kidnapped and Quinn was forced to stay quiet. Police immediately suspected Huskins of killing his girlfriend. And when Quinn returned alive and relatively unharmed, the couple was accused of faking the entire ordeal.

Unfortunately for Huskins and Quinn, the media believed the police representatives who cast suspicion on them. But the real story has twists that the original investigators overlooked. And they also reveal that this living nightmare that the couple went through was only the beginning.

Watch American Nightmare on Netflix.

My Lover, My Killer

One of the couples featured in the documentary My Lover, My Killer.

The British documentary series, My Lover, My Killer, features 10 different couples whose relationships ran hot and cold. Tragically, all of the relationships featured on the show ended in murder.

The most striking thing about this show are the victims who couldn’t foresee ever being killed by their partners, even when there were red flags in the relationships. If they had been able to, perhaps their stories wouldn’t have ended so tragically.

Watch My Lover, My Killer on Netflix.

American Murder: The Family Next Door

An image of the Watts family from American Murder: The Family Next Door.

To a certain extent, all domestic murder stories become hard to watch when they recount the brutal fate of the victims. American Murder: The Family Next Door is no exception. This film covers the Watts family murders from 2018 by slowly piecing together a portrait of the family and the events leading up to their deaths.

As this documentary demonstrates, the portrayal of these crimes in the media doesn’t always match the details shared by the family of the victims or even their killer. It’s also unsettling to learn how the victims died and why, as well as what was done to their bodies in the aftermath.

Watch American Murder: The Killer Next Door on Netflix.

Editors' Recommendations

Blair Marnell
Blair Marnell has been an entertainment journalist for over 15 years. His bylines have appeared in Wizard Magazine, Geek…
Like Taylor Swift and Travis Kelce? Then watch these 3 great rom-coms right now
Taylor Swift plays the piano during her Reputation tour.

There are plenty of people who will watch the Super Bowl without really caring about who wins the game, but this year, an entire new fandom has suddenly found themselves intimately invested in the success of the Kansas City Chiefs. Following the news that Taylor Swift and Chiefs tight end Travis Kelce were dating, the internet has been abuzz as she has attended his games. Some fans were even wondering whether it would be possible for her to make it to the 2024 Super Bowl following her concert in Japan the day before the big game.

If you're at all invested in that relationship, though, you probably like a good romantic comedy. With that in mind, we've found three of the very best that will remind you, just like Travis and Taylor do, that love is still alive and well.
Set It Up (2018)
Set It Up | Official Trailer [HD] | Netflix

Read more
Like Netflix’s Alexander: The Making of a God? Watch these 3 historical movies right now
A solider in full armor prepares for battle.

Alexander: The Making of a God depicts the life of the legendary Greek conqueror and his rise to power. Part documentary and part scripted series, Alexander is bound to become one of Netflix's best shows or at least one of the most talked-about, especially as it depicts the titular character as not necessarily straight — something anyone with a bare minimum of historical knowledge will know is true.

Those who enjoy Alexander: The Making of a God might leave the show longing for more Ancient Greece content. My advice to them is to play Assassin's Creed: Odyssey, a game that brings 400 BC Greece to life with stunning detail. However, if they don't want to invest 100-plus hours into the game, they'd do well to check these movies out. With similar tones, themes, and characters, these movies will scratch the itch that Alexander: The Making of a King provokes.
In the Footsteps of Alexander the Great (1998)

Read more
Like the hit Netflix show Fool Me Once? Then watch these three shows right now
Michelle Keegan in Fool Me Once.

Netflix subscribers love their thrillers. That may be why the recently released Fool Me Once is now one of the most popular shows on Netflix. In this adaptation of Harlan Coben's hit novel, Michelle Keegan stars as Maya Stern, a woman who is emotionally bereft after the death of her husband, Joe Burkett (Richard Armitage). When Maya sees proof that Joe isn't dead, it sends her down a rabbit hole as she tries to figure out why his death was faked.

Once you've finished watching Fool Me Once, you should check out these three other shows on Netflix that you should watch. All of our picks are mysteries and thrillers, but only the first show on our list, Bodies, actually adds some sci-fi elements to the mix.
Bodies (2023)

Read more