Skip to main content

Snubbing the snubbers: Only 12 of the BBC’s 100 Greatest American Films won the Oscar

The Academy Award for Best Picture doesn’t necessarily always fall to the best films. That seems to be the contention of a new list compiled by the BBC, anyway.

In the BBC Culture list of the 100 Greatest American Films, only 12 on the list won the Oscar for Best Picture. Further, as Deadline’s Pete Hammond notes, 60 of the BBC’s honorees didn’t even receive a Best Picture nomination. The BBC, which compiled the list by polling 62 critics internationally, funded the project “to get a global perspective on American film.”

Recommended Videos

Citizen Kane — which was beaten out in the 1942 Academy Awards by John Ford’s How Green Was My Valley — topped the list. The rest of the top ten features many lauded classics: The Godfather (#2), 2001: A Space Odyssey (#4), Singin’ in the Rain ($7), Psycho (#8), and Casablanca (#9), to name a few, with four of the ten winning the Academy Award for Best Picture.

Like any list, there’s definitely room for dissection. Gone With the Wind barely made the list at #97, for instance. And Ben-Hur, which boasts an impressive 11 Oscars, was completely left off the list. Also missing were The Shawshank Redemption, any of the Lord of the Rings films or The Matrix, though other popular films like Groundhog Day (#71), and Back to the Future (#56) were recognized.

BBC Culture defined an “American movie” as one that received U.S. funding, rather than one by an American director. (If you were wondering, 32 of the films were helmed by foreign directors.) Hammond notes that the list seemed to favor certain directors — like Billy Wilder, Alfred Hitchcock, and Stanley Kubrick — over others.

Best-of lists surely spark controversy, but this is quite the knock against the the Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences, which host the Academy Awards each year. It certainly won’t make the Oscars any less important, but it’s one more reason to doubt the decisions of the powers that be.

Everyone has an actor or film in mind that didn’t get the recognition it deserved — Scorsese’s Goodfellas is a classic example employed to point out the famed award show’s flaws. Looking for the most recent questionable snub from the Academy? Many think Jake Gyllenhaal’s recent turn as the chillingly creepy Louis Bloom in Nightcrawler, for which the actor wasn’t even nominated, should’ve earned the actor a solid shot at gold last year.

Chris Leo Palermino
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Chris Leo Palermino is a music, tech, business, and culture journalist based between New York and Boston. He also contributes…
All the 2025 Best Picture Oscar nominees, ranked
Timothee Chalamet stands near a desert wall in a still from the movie Dune: Part Two.

Los Angeles smolders, but the show must go on, apparently. Delaying no further, the Academy yesterday announced the nominees for the 2025 Oscars — one year to the day from the last time they unveiled the contenders in every category. No Barbenheimer looms over our new Oscar season, try though entertainment journalists and social media users did to manufacture a sequel to that double-feature moviegoing event for the ages. This week's nominations narrowed a crowded race without pointing towards a certain winner. The Best Picture lineup was tougher to predict than last year’s, which conformed so entirely to expectations that the 2024 version of this very article could be written entirely in advance.

Easier than identifying the frontrunner for this year’s Oscar is picking a favorite. Perhaps even more so than usual, Best Picture runs the gamut from worthy to decidedly not. The best of the nominees was truly the best movie of the year. The worst would make for a historically blunderous end to the 97th Academy Awards. In between, we’ve got blockbusters not half as good as the big winner of 2024, Oppenheimer; a better-than-average example of a generally lukewarm genre, the musical biopic; and a staggeringly ambitious budget epic whose reach exceeds its grasp (but hey, the reach is admirable all the same). 

Read more
2025 Oscars: 5 movies to expect at next year’s ceremony
Gurney looking at Paul in Dune: Part Two.

We're not even 24 hours removed from the 2024 Academy Awards, and our attention has turned toward the 2025 Oscars. The 2024 Oscars will be remembered for Oppenheimer, which won the biggest prize, Best Picture. The ceremony was also a coronation for Christopher Nolan, who can now add Oscar-winner to his impressive resume after taking home Best Director.

What will be 2024's version of Oppenheimer? Could it Dune: Part Two, which could pull a Return of the King by dominating the technical categories before taking home Best Picture? Will George Miller's Furiosa win over the Academy like its predecessor, Fury Road, did in 2016? These are five movies we expect to see at the 2025 Oscars.
Dune: Part Two (2024)

Read more
5 best moments from the 2024 Oscars, ranked (plus one happy dog)
Ryan Gosling performs I'm Just a Ken in Barbie.

The 2024 Oscars have come and gone, and no one can say that the 96th Academy Awards show wasn't entertaining! Returning host Jimmy Kimmel kept things moving all night long, and there were some very funny moments, as well as poignant speeches, and one of the most dazzling musical performances that the Oscars has ever seen.

To mark the occasion, we've compiled a brief list of the five most memorable moments from the 2024 Oscars. And you may have already guessed which one landed at no. 1.
Honorable Mention: A meme is born
If you blinked, you might have missed the cameo by Messi, the very good dog from Anatomy of a Fall, with clapping paws added. It's destined to be a meme for the rest of eternity.

Read more