Skip to main content

Google book scanning counts as ‘fair use’ says appeals court

google book scanning counts as fair use says appeals court books and ebooks
It’s been some time since Google’s book-scanning project was last in the news, but the tech giant has just won a crucial court victory enabling the endeavor to continue. The decision by the Second Circuit Court of Appeals in New York brings to an end a 10-year lawsuit filed by the Authors Guild, and confirms the scanning does not violate copyright law.

“We see no reason in this case why Google’s overall profit motivation should prevail as a reason for denying fair use over its highly convincing transformative purpose, together with the absence of significant substitutive competition, as reasons for granting fair use,” wrote Justice Pierre Leval, as Fortune reports. Over 20 million books have been scanned by Google as it looks to digitize the world’s literature and make it available online.

“Today’s decision underlines what people who use the service tell us: Google Books gives them a useful and easy way to find books they want to read and buy, while at the same time benefiting copyright holders. We’re pleased the court has confirmed that the project is fair use, acting like a card catalog for the digital age,” a Google spokesperson said in a press statement.

Google Books gives users an online portal through which they can search scanned books and read excerpts free of charge. Publishers claimed this infringed on copyright protection and the authors’ ability to make money from their work, a position that the U.S. courts have now refuted. If the decision had gone the other way, Google would’ve been facing the prospect of paying out billions of dollars in damages.

Leval said that the snippets shown by Google Books were large enough to give searchers a sense of the context of a particular passage while still being small enough to avoid copyright infringement. The Authors Guild now plans to take the case to the U.S. Supreme Court.

[Image courtesy of AntonMaltsev/]

Editors' Recommendations

David Nield
Dave is a freelance journalist from Manchester in the north-west of England. He's been writing about technology since the…
You can now use voice control for Sling TV on Google Nest devices
Live TV Streaming Services

Sling TV has long allowed you to watch your favorite shows live or stream them using your television or handheld device, but you couldn't use your voice to control the service until now. On Wednesday, Google announced that if you have a subscription to Sling, you can use voice commands to watch all of your favorite shows on your Google Nest devices. Even more exciting, you can now watch on more devices. If you have a Google device with a screen, like the Nest Hub Max, you can watch your favorite shows just like you would on your phone or tablet.

"Sling TV allows you to watch your favorite shows live or stream on portable devices. Watch live football games, don’t miss a float during the Thanksgiving Day Parade, and keep up with breaking news," Google employee Rachel Chambers said in an announcement. "Using a remote to flip channels and pause the TV is so 2018. With Sling now on Nest Hub and Nest Hub Max, you can control Sling with your voice."

Read more
New Android phones must support USB-C PD and Digital Wellbeing, Google says
wireless charging over distance barriers cover

According to a document acquired by XDA Developers, Google is now requiring that Android manufacturers support its Digital Wellbeing suite and the universal standard for fast charging, USB-C Power Delivery (PD), in any future Android devices.

The new requirements will apply to any manufacturer looking to use the Google Mobile Services (GMS) package -- which, since GMS includes the Google Play Store and all of Google's services, applies to pretty much every manufacturer outside of the Chinese market. While companies won't necessarily have to worry about updating their entire backlog of phones to accommodate Google's demands, every new Android device will be required to follow the new rule, and so will all phones updated to Android 9.0 Pie and Android 10 after September 3, 2019.

Read more
President Trump attacks Google and says he’s watching the company ‘very closely’
Donald Trump

In a series of tweets on Tuesday morning, President Donald Trump claimed without evidence that Google has an anti-conservative bias and accused the company of trying to ensure he loses the 2020 presidential election.

“[Far-right journalist Peter Schweizer] stated with certainty that [Google] suppressed negative stories on Hillary Clinton, and boosted negative stories on Donald Ttump [sic]. All very illegal. We are watching Google very closely!” the last of three tweets read. Trump gave no evidence that Google had worked to sway either the 2016 or 2020 elections.

Read more