Skip to main content

Three tech Davids taking on Goliaths, and winning

It never ceases to amaze me how many companies have tried and failed to beat Apple, Intel and HP, wasting millions of dollars running head on at these now dominant firms. But every company has a weakness. Often you just have to figure out either where that firm’s blind spot is, or where they are simply unwilling to go. AMD, Dell, and Kodak have all learned the hard way that running head on at a dominant company doesn’t work, and all three have recently demonstrated strategies that flank their unbeatable competitors. Success still isn’t certain, but the odds are vastly better than they ever have been that these firms could now make gains that have eluded them before. Let’s cover each strategy.

How AMD is exploiting Intel’s weaknesses

AMD has only historically beaten Intel when the Santa Clara company stumbled, and it has never stumbled long enough for AMD to sustain a significant lead. This is because Intel is larger, more deeply entrenched, and AMD simply isn’t strong enough to fully displace the company in any major account. For years, AMD had tried to do what Intel does best better, and that never worked. However, this week AMD launched its Llano A Series Fusion processor, which goes where Intel has struggled: graphics performance. Intel’s weakness here has presented an increasing problem for both battery life in notebooks, and visual application performance.

Recommended Videos

AMD took a huge bet in buying ATI to make this work, and got pounded for making it, but the end result is now a processor ideal for attractively priced laptops with 10-hour battery life and strong graphics performance. Eventually it will make its way into desktops with similar advantages, that position well against Intel PCs for specific high-performance workloads. Suddenly AMD is in the game again. Coupled with a strong line of products from HP, the Sunnyvale underdog has a shot at making a sustained run against Intel. The lesson AMD learned and now exemplifies is attacking the weaknesses rather than the strengths of a dominant competitor. In Intel’s case, that weakness was graphics.

Get your weekly teardown of the tech behind PC gaming
Check your inbox!

How Dell is outflanking Apple

Dell’s last big run at Apple was with its MP3 player in the US market, and Apple kicked Dell’s butt. But while Apple is unbeatable in the US market, it is far weaker in Europe and Asia (I’m told this is largely because their distributors aren’t very effective and the geographic distances involved limit Apple ability to correct this problem). Part of this weakness is also that Apple designs for the US market, and doesn’t do geography-specific products that may other countries require. Regardless of the cause, it would be silly to bring out an iPad competitor in the US where the company is strong, and we’ve seen a number of Android, and RIM tablets fail in this market.

Dell instead pushed its latest iPad-like tablet into the Chinese market first, and loaded it with software that was specific to China. The company essentially did what Toyota finally learned to do when it moved effectively against Ford and GM in the US market. Dell built a tablet specifically for China. This is a flanking move away from Apple’s core strength, and against two known weaknesses that Apple has. The end result should be far better than if Dell had run against Apple in the US.

How Kodak is cherry picking HP’s customers

HP is nearly as dominant with printers as Apple is with the iPod. A fierce competitor, HP has an unmatched ecosystem for paper and ink and massive retail presence. Companies like Kodak, Lexmark, Xerox, and even IBM have broken on the shores of HP’s dominance, making it the most capable division in what is arguably the most powerful company in the world. Kodak couldn’t run at HP directly, but recognizing that the printer market was a razor-blade-type market where the printers were largely subsidized by the relative high cost of supplies, Kodak moved to break the model and tightly target its offering.

Kodak InkKodak charges more for its printers, but then sharply discounts their ink and supplies so that power printers find substantial savings by using Kodak products. The firm is reporting strong market-share gains in the most lucrative, high-volume segments as a result, because supplies are what make the money. HP can’t effectively counter without destroying its own revenue model. This is called “cherry picking,” or focusing your effort on the part of the market you want (Apple kind of does this with premium PC buyers against Microsoft). The end result is that Kodak is having some of the greatest success in printers it has ever enjoyed, just by thinking through where HP was most vulnerable and exploiting that vulnerability.

Fighting smart

Each of these companies has taken on a very powerful company not known for making mistakes. But by attacking where the company is weak, flanking the company, or cherry picking them, each is (in theory) moving vastly better competitively than they ever have before. There is a lesson here for anyone competing on anything. Learn your opponents’ weaknesses and exploit them, because if they are dominant, attacking them where they are strong is a losing proposition.

Rob Enderle
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Rob is President and Principal Analyst of the Enderle Group, a forward-looking emerging technology advisory firm. Before…
Apple Memorial Day sales: Save on Apple Watch, iPad, MacBook, and more
The 14-inch MacBook Pro with M3 Max chip seen from behind.

Most of this year's Memorial Day deals are set to launch very soon, but if you want to get your shopping for Apple devices done early, we're here to help you out with this roundup of the early Apple Memorial Day sales that are already available. Whether you're planning to buy a new iPad, iPhone, AirPods, MacBook, or Apple Watch, we've got some excellent bargains below. If anything catches your eye. it's highly recommended that you complete your purchase as soon as possible because there's no telling how soon these offers will expire -- some may not even make it to Memorial Day itself!
Best Memorial Day iPad deals

Memorial Day is one of the best times of the year to search for iPad deals. There are some fantastic discounts that are available across a variety of models of Apple's tablet, including the entry-level Apple iPad and the creatives-focused Apple iPad Pro, so whatever your purpose is for thinking about getting an iPad, there won't be any shortage of options for you here.

Read more
Best LastPass alternatives for 2024
A digital security lock.

Whether you're security-conscious or have a terrible memory, using a password manager is a great way to free up brain space and secure your most important information. Unfortunately, LastPass -- once one of the best password managers -- has had several security incidents over the years, making customers look to other options.

This list of both free and paid password managers are solid replacements for LastPass.
Best LastPass alternatives

Read more
How to get Microsoft Office for free
A person using a laptop that displays various Microsoft Office apps.

Microsoft Office, or Microsoft 365, is a premium application suite that you need to pay for to get full access to. That is, unless you use the web apps, or the free trials, or you're a student. Then you can get Microsoft Office for free. And don't forget the excellent Microsoft Office alternatives you can try (for free!) too.

Here's how to get Microsoft 365 for free, in a few different ways.

Read more