Judge dismisses Wikimedia v. NSA lawsuit, says plaintiff arguments are based on speculation

wikimedia v nsa news
After hearing arguments from both sides, a federal judge has dismissed Wikimedia v. NSA — a major case that challenged the U.S. National Security Agency’s sweeping “Upstream” surveillance program, arguing that it was unconstitutional.

For those who might not recall the case, here’s a quick refresher: Back in March, the ACLU filed suit against the NSA on behalf of the Wikimedia Foundation and eight other organizations. The lawsuit challenged “the suspicionless seizure and searching of Internet traffic by the National Security Agency (NSA) on U.S. soil,” asserting that, “the NSA conducts this surveillance, called ‘Upstream’ surveillance, by tapping directly into the internet backbone inside the United States — the network of high-capacity cables, switches, and routers that today carry vast numbers of Americans’ communications with each other and with the rest of the world.”

More specifically, the ACLU claimed that the NSA’s surveillance program “exceeds the scope of the authority that Congress provided in the FISA Amendments Act of 2008 (FAA) and violates the First and Fourth Amendments. Because it is predicated on programmatic surveillance orders issued by the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court (FISC) in the absence of any case or controversy, the surveillance also violates Article III of the Constitution.”

However, after a lengthy hearing process, Judge TS Ellis III tossed out the ACLUs case, ruling that the plaintiffs did not have enough information to plausibly make such a claim. Despite the fact that the existence of the Upstream program has been confirmed by government officials, judge Ellis ruled that just because the NSA has the technical ability to monitor all our online communications, it doesn’t necessarily mean they are doing so. “Plaintiffs provide no factual basis to support the allegation that the NSA is using its surveillance equipment at full throttle,” he wrote. “In the end, plaintiffs’ standing argument boils down to suppositions about how Upstream must operate in order to achieve the government’s stated goals.”

Basically, Judge Ellis concluded that the plaintiffs had to speculate about key elements of the NSA’s Upstream program, and due to precedent established in Amnesty v. Clapper — a 2013 Supreme Court ruling on a similar challenge — their case could not go forward.

In a response on its blog, the ACLU fired back, claiming that “the court misunderstands how upstream surveillance is fundamentally different from and much more intrusive than the surveillance considered by the Supreme Court in Amnesty v. Clapper,” adding that “given how much is in the public record about upstream surveillance, our clients’ allegations are not ‘speculative’ or ‘hypothetical.'”

The ACLU said it is considering an appeal, however, so the fight may not be over just yet.

Up Next: Read the original aritcle

Smart Home

Booth babes, banned sex toys, and other mishaps at CES 2019

From female sex toys bans, to fake Tesla/robot collision stories, there was some weird stuff going on at CES 2019 this year. Here are some of the biggest mishaps and flubs at the world's biggest tech show.

Apple banned from distributing some iPhone models in Germany

Apple is following the FTC's lead and has sued Qualcomm for a massive $1 billion in the U.S., $145 million in China, and also in the U.K., claiming the company charged onerous royalties for its patented tech.

Shutdown makes dozens of .gov websites insecure due to expired TLS certificates

The US government shutdown is causing trouble in internet security. As the shutdown enters day 22, dozens of government websites have been rendered insecure or inaccessible due to expired transport layer security (TLS) certificates.

Our favorite Chrome themes add some much-needed pizzazz to your boring browser

Sometimes you just want Chrome to show a little personality and ditch the grayscale for something a little more lively. Lucky for you, we've sorted through the Chrome Web Store to find best Chrome themes available.
Social Media

A quick swipe will soon let you keep bingeing YouTube on mobile devices

The YouTube mobile app has a new, faster way to browse: Swiping. Once the update rolls out, users can swipe to go to the next (or previous) video in the recommended list, even while viewing in full screen.

Cathay Pacific messes up first-class ticket prices — again

A couple of weeks ago, an error on Cathay Pacific's website resulted in first-class seats selling for a tenth of the price. On Sunday, January 13, the airline made the error again. The good news is that it'll honor the bookings.
Social Media

YouTube to crack down on dangerous stunts like the ‘Bird Box’ challenge

YouTube already bans content showing dangerous activities, but new rules published by the site go into greater detail regarding potentially harmful challenges and pranks, including certain blindfold- or laundry detergent-based stunts.

Reluctant to give your email address away? Here's how to make a disposable one

Want to sign up for a service without the risk of flooding your inbox with copious amounts of spam and unwanted email? You might want to consider using disposable email addresses via one of these handy services.

Pinning websites to your taskbar is as easy as following these quick steps

Would you like to know how to pin a website to the taskbar in Windows 10 in order to use browser links like apps? Whichever browser you're using, it's easier than you might think. Here's how to get it done.

Want to save a webpage as a PDF? Just follow these steps

Need to quickly save and share a webpage? The best way is to learn how to save a webpage as a PDF file, as they're fully featured and can handle images and text with ease. Here's how.

Delete tracking cookies from your system by following these quick steps

Cookies are useful when it comes to saving your login credentials and other data, but they can also be used by advertisers to track your browsing habits across multiple sites. Here's how to clear cookies in the major browsers.
Social Media

Nearly a million Facebook users followed these fake Russian accounts

Facebook purged two separate groups behind more than 500 fake accounts with Russian ties. One group had ties to Russian news agency Sputnik, while the other had behavior similar to the Internet Research Agency's midterm actions.

Switch up your Reddit routine with these interesting, inspiring, and zany subs

So you've just joined the wonderful world of Reddit and want to explore it. With so many subreddits, however, navigating the "front page of the internet" can be daunting. Here are some of the best subreddits to get you started.
Smart Home

Amazon Prime members number more than 100 million in the U.S., survey says

Consumer Intelligence Research Partners estimated there were 101 million U.S. Amazon Prime members as of December 31, 2018. Last April, CEO Jeff Bezos wrote there were more than 100 global million Prime members.
1 of 2