Skip to main content

Google vs. Bing experiment: Half of search results are identical

bing-logo-with-google-colors-question-mark
Image used with permission by copyright holder

The gloves are off and Google has thrown the first punch. On Tuesday, Google released the results of a detailed investigation it conducted to prove that Microsoft’s Bing is stealing copying search results from the world’s largest search engine. Google claims that Bing is collecting Google search data from its Bing toolbar and using it to improve its own search results. In response, Microsoft fired back saying it does not copy results, but also admitted that it does look at Google results from its toolbar. In defense of that fact, Microsoft claims that Google’s results are only one of 1,000 input streams Bing uses to determine search results.

But pretend you’re Microsoft. Imagine that you own Internet Explorer, the browser 56 percent of all Internet goers use. Now imagine that one of the features you built into your browser gives you access to a constant stream of results from searches made to competitors to your own search engine named Bing. Most importantly, you have access to the search engine results of your biggest competitor, a search engine named Google that holds a dominant 68 percent of the search market. Your own search engine, Bing, has 28.2 percent of the market. You’ve already started using this stream of Google searches to benefit your own search. The question is: how far do you go? How much of Google’s search juice do you bottle and mix with your own?

The experiment

We know now that Bing uses Google results to augment its search. So the real question is: how similar are the results from these two search engines? To find this out, I decided to conduct my own investigation using 10 random terms I thought up from whatever was floating in my head earlier today. This is not a scientific study by any stretch of the imagination. My results may not be typical. They are simply the results Google and Bing provided.

  • 10 random words: adoxography (def: writing on a trivial subject), aromatherapy, arpu, best search engine, Digital Trends, “park place,” Sean Sheep (misspelling for Shaun the Sheep), The Rite, welk, and Will Wright. These words have been sorted alphabetically.
  • The method: I searched each of these words simultaneously on Google (left) and Bing (right) and scanned the first page of results. Both engines default to 10 results per page, along with a varying number of social, map, news, and other widgets. I looked at Page 1 results in both search engines. Using colored boxes, I marked links that were shared across both Google and Bing.
  • Preparation: To search, I used a Google Chrome browser in Incognito mode. I was logged out of both search engines and kept all settings at default. Both search engines seemed to know where I am (Chicago, Illinois), but I did not inform either of my location. I also ensured I was logged out of Facebook in Bing, which appears to have an effect on some results. Search histories on both engines were cleared.

Below are pictures of the actual searches I performed on Google and Bing. Shared links are colored and connected via lines. Browse them them yourself to see just how cozy Google and Bing get, or skip ahead for the conclusion and breakdown.

Word: adoxography

7 out of 10 results are identical. Adoxography means “to write on a trivial subject.” It was the first, and strangest, word that came to mind. The results were astoundingly similar.

bing-vs-google-identical-results-comparison-word-adoxography
Image used with permission by copyright holder

Word: aromatherapy

7 out of 10 results are identical. This word was on a container of soap in my kitchen. Again, the results are in a different order, but are mostly identical. As seems to be the norm, both search engines add their own little image and news widget boxes around the search results to differentiate themselves. Bing was most helpful here.

bing-vs-google-identical-results-comparison-word-aromatherapy
Image used with permission by copyright holder

Word: arpu

4 out of 10 identical results. This is a common acronym in the mobile industry. It means “average revenue per user.” Apparently, it can also refer to the American Racing Pigeon Union. I didn’t know pigeons were allowed to organize.

Image used with permission by copyright holder

Word: best search engine

5 out of 10 results were identical. You be the judge here. Most interesting to me: Bing and Google advertise on one another.

bing-vs-google-identical-results-comparison-word-best-search-engine
Image used with permission by copyright holder

Word: Digital Trends

5 out of 10 results were identical. To kick things off, I vainly searched our own site up on both search engines. The correlations are largely explainable.

bing-vs-google-identical-results-comparison-word-digital-trends
Image used with permission by copyright holder

Word: “park place”

5 out of 10 results were identical. I wanted to search with quotes and a place. Monopoly came to mind. These results are strangely similar.

bing-vs-google-identical-results-comparison-word-park-place
Image used with permission by copyright holder

Word: Sean Sheep

2 out of 10 results were identical. This was one of the more obscure searches I did, and I attempted to confuse the engines by misspelling Shaun and omitting “the” from the search. Interestingly, only Bing showed perhaps the most relevant result: SeanSheep.com. Both engines assumed I meant Shaun the Sheep without asking.

bing-vs-google-identical-results-comparison-word-sean-sheep
Image used with permission by copyright holder

Word: The Rite

4 out of 10 results were identical. This word was chosen as it is a recent movie release. Most of the shared results here could probably be logically explained.

bing-vs-google-identical-results-comparison-word-the-rite
Image used with permission by copyright holder

Word: welk

3 out of 10 results were identical. Both search engines assumed I was referring to the Welk Resorts Theatre and/or Lawrence Welk. Neither search engine produced great results.

bing-vs-google-identical-results-comparison-word-welk
Image used with permission by copyright holder

Word: Will Wright

7 out of 10 results were identical. I searched this term to see what results might look like for a famous person. Will Wright is a renowned game designer, best known for SimCity, The Sims, and Spore. Most of these shared links would be expected. IMDB, Wikipedia, etc are large aggregators of content relevant to this search.

bing-vs-google-identical-results-comparison-word-will-wright
Image used with permission by copyright holder

Conclusion

Out of the 100 search results returned from Google and Bing, I found 49 shared links between them, meaning about half of all results were duplicated across both websites. Most words had at least 2 (20 percent) matching links between Google and Bing, and for 3 words, 70 percent of all links were duplicated across both search engines. Comparing second page links appeared to lead to even stronger correlations between the two search engines. Many of these similarities can be explained. After all, it is probably smart and natural for both search engines to pull up entries from Wikipedia and other top sites, but some shared links are fairly obscure and precise. There are some strange correlations between Google and Bing. I tried a few more words, some nonsensical, and found that there are, of course, search terms that produce no shared results.

Does any of this mean anything? Have you done your own comparisons between Google and Bing? One of the major things I learned today is that neither Google or Bing are very good at retrieving relevant results. A majority of links returned were to sites I had no interest in. Search, though much better than it was five years ago, is still in its infancy. We’ve got a long way to go.

I’ve always enjoyed revising and editing. It comes with all of the creative elements of writing, and the comfort of knowing that somebody else will do the hard leg work for you. Whether its one tiny metric out of a thousand or the dominant way Bing attains results, it isn’t right for Microsoft to use Google searches for its own benefit. In return, it is wrong if Google has done anything like this as well. However, instead of sniping at one another, it would be nice if both parties would sit down and actually improve the quality of their own products. With content farms like AOL around, we need smart search more than ever.

Editors' Recommendations

Jeffrey Van Camp
Former Digital Trends Contributor
As DT's Deputy Editor, Jeff helps oversee editorial operations at Digital Trends. Previously, he ran the site's…
Save $400 on this Dell PC with an RTX 4070, 32GB of RAM, 1TB SSD
The Dell XPS desktop on a table.

If you're willing to spend on desktop computer deals for a machine that will offer flagship performance for all of your needs, it's highly recommended that you go with the Dell XPS Desktop 8960. This certain configuration that's on sale from Dell will let you enjoy savings of $400 on its original price of $2,250, so you'll have to pay $1,850 -- it's still not cheap, but it's going to be worth every single penny at this discounted price. You're going to have to be quick though -- this is a clearance sale, so there's no telling when the offer expires and when stocks will run out.

Why you should buy the Dell XPS Desktop 8960
The Dell XPS Desktop 8960 isn't just an excellent PC -- it's our top pick among the best desktop computers for its flexibility to accommodate almost any budget and purpose. This particular model of the PC features the 13th-generation Intel Core i9 processor, the Nvidia GeForce RTX 4070 graphics card, and 32GB of RAM, which will make it more than enough to tackle even the most demanding tasks, while also offering high-end gaming potential to play the best PC games for whenever you need to take a break from work.

Read more
Best color laser printers for 2024: tested and reviewed
A Brother printer on a counter in front of a brick wall.

The best color laser printers can be a great investment, saving you quite a bit of time and money. For shoppers worried about the long-term ink costs, you'll find color laser printers surprisingly affordable. Laser printers use toner, which lasts a very long time, delivering a low cost per page for monochrome documents and fast color prints. The best color laser printers offer quick performance and reliability to help keep your home office or small business productive.

If you need to scan documents for record-keeping and photo capture or want the convenience of a color copier, an all-in-one color laser printer is an essential tool for your small business or personal use. For a small added cost, you get expanded capabilities. That's why every model on this list is an all-in-one from the best printer brands.

Read more
The 5 best Wi-Fi adapters for PC in 2024
The Ugreen AC1300 Wi-Fi adapter in a desktop PC.

Whether you're designing it yourself or getting a pre-built PC, it can be easy to get a computer and realize that it doesn't have a native Wi-Fi adapter. Or, maybe it does, but you're internet speeds are getting faster, game downloads are getting bigger, you've already upgraded your router and need an adapter to match your newfound power requirements. No matter the situation, an external Wi-Fi adapter that you can add to your PC setup or even laptop setup will be worth your time. Here, we investigate the best Wi-Fi adapters for PC use. Most are incredibly affordable and just snap into a free USB port and start working.
The best Wi-Fi adapter for PC in 2024

Buy the

Read more