Windows 7 Review

Windows 7 Desktop

We put Windows 7 through the paces in our detailed review. Is it better than Vista? How does it compare to Mac OSX?

It’s finally here. Nearly three years after Microsoft unleashed Windows Vista unto the world, crippling otherwise competent computers with obscene system requirements and feature bloat, Microsoft has returned for redemption with Windows 7, otherwise known as “what Vista should have been.” Though not as revolutionary in appearance as its predecessor, Microsoft has promised a slew of long-awaited refinements, including better performance, a powerful universal search, and better driver and hardware compatibility. We popped our freshly minted RTM copy of Windows 7 into the favorite office testbed – HP’s Firebird – and put the new OS through its paces to see whether Redmond can deliver on its promises when Windows 7 hits the streets on October 22.

Check out our Window 7 video review.

Installation

Not surprisingly, the installer for Windows 7 looks uncannily like Windows Vista’s: pop in the disc, navigate through a few questions about where you want it installed, then let it grind out the rest. Amazingly, it took only 17 minutes after finishing up the brief question period to landing on the Windows 7 desktop – a pretty impressive feat.

After launching for the very first time, Windows 7 transparently dealt with all our Firebird’s hardware except the video card, which we had to right click on under device manager and ask it to pull new drivers for. After a short automated search and install process, we had month-old drivers on the machine without so much as having to open a browser – though we did find slightly fresher drivers on Nvidia’s site.

The New Desktop

While Windows 7 retains the same glassy window style, icons and many other holdovers from Vista, more users will immediately notice that the taskbar has changed dramatically. Most notably, Microsoft has stripped out the clutter. A slightly taller taskbar now accommodates large, squared-off icons (rather than rectangular labels) in the bar, making it in some ways similar to Mac’s OS X dock. Every open program gets an icon, but you can also pin your favorites to hang out on the bottom even when they’re not in use, similar to the quick-launch area in previous Windows. This helps reduce the visual untidiness that comes from stringing out program titles in the taskbar itself. And really who needs them? If you do decide to revert to the old ways, Windows 7 will allow you to turn off the icon-based system, and also shrink the taskbar back to its original size.


Windows 7 Taskbar

New and improved Windows 7 taskbar



Since icons alone don’t tell you what’s going on with your desktop at any given time, Microsoft has implemented its new Aero Peek feature to fill in the necessary details. Hovering over any icon (or clicking if you’re in a hurry) will show the separate thumbnails for each window within any given program, like different Firefox windows, along with labels (Yahoo, Digg, Downloads, etc.) above them. Hovering over a thumbnail will take the details a step further by hiding every window and showing just the one in question to clarify which you’re dealing with. You can also right-click on any of the taskbar icons to get Jump Lists, which are basically shortcut lists pertaining to the programs. For instance, IE will present shortcuts for your last visited sites and tasks, like opening a new tab, while Windows Media player will let you pause or skip forward through playlists without actually opening it to full screen.


Windows 7 Hover Feature

Hover over any icon to view thumbnails



With many users now sporting enormous widescreen monitors, Windows 7’s new “snaps” feature turned out to be one of the most unexpectedly smart additions to make the most of all that real estate. Grab any window, drag it to the right or left edge of the screen, and it will automatically resize to half the screen. This makes it easy to browse on two screens at once to compare, type in Word with a browser window next to it, and so on. When you’re done, dragging the window to a new position automatically returns it to the old size. Additional options for snapping (akin to those the freeware AllSnap offers) would still be appreciated, though.


Windows 7 Snap Feature

Windows 7 new snap feature



For those who immediately look at a Windows desktop and want to get to work making it their own, Microsoft has made that easier, as well. The new personalization menu features a wide array of attractive built-in themes, plus the means to switch them up by swapping backgrounds, screensavers, and even picking a custom color from a mixer for menus and using a slider to determine its opacity. This isn’t quite a WindowBlinds level of customization, but it’s easy, and 99 percent of users will probably be thrilled with the results.


Windows 7 Personalize

Windows 7 personalization options



A revamped device management window takes much of the confusion out of connecting new gadgets. Simple devices like hard drives, thumb drives and webcams will mostly be automatically detected, and show up under this pane alongside other connected items like mice, keyboards and Wi-Fi adapters. Although we didn’t witness it in our demo, manufacturers will also be able to customize the windows with specific images and custom interfaces.


Windows 7 Devices

Windows 7 device management



Showing 30 comments

  1. Microsoft shifts 350 million Windows 7 licenses in 18 months, XP still king at 9:00am 23rd April 2011 [...] announced in a post on Friday that in its first 18 months, more than 350 million licenses of the Windows 7 operating system have been shifted, making it possibly the fastest selling operating system of all [...]
  2. liz hunt at 1:49pm 26th October 2010 I have a new Satellite A665 with Windows 7. My problem is : I print to a Epson work force 600. It takes a good 5 minutes after I click print for the printer to work. We have reinstalled the printer and still it works this way. I am working from the laptop and other laptops also print from the printer. They have no problem. I do not know what is is. I am not real good at computers , either. Any help?
  3. Windows 7: 1 year, 240 million licenses at 5:33am 22nd October 2010 [...] is Windows 7’s first birthday and Microsoft has reason to celebrate. License sales of Windows 7 have eclipsed 240 million copies in just a year, reports Datamation. The company claims that 17.1 [...]
  4. Danny at 1:36am 21st October 2010 Some of these comments are so ridiculously biased.. Firstly, it is not microsofts job to provide drivers, these are written by the 3rd party companys who produce the hardware. If you have driver issues, it is because whoever the hardware vendor is cannot be bothered to write drivers for windows 7. The same people who expect flawless backwards compatibility also complain about bloat and sluggishness. To be honest I think a lot of these people who objectify things to the extremes are mostly fan boys (mostly apple) who enter into it with an already formed opinion. While we're on that topic, I don't like apple anymore because of its breeding of an elitist almost nazi like regime where everything must be controlled by them. I have been running on windows 7 since the open beta and have never had it crash on me.
  5. Western Digital launches world’s largest SATA drive with 3TB Caviar Green at 11:27am 19th October 2010 [...] designed for 64-bit systems, they’ll also function with legacy 32-bit systems running Vista or Windows 7, with a few caveats. Western Digital offers a chart spelling out which operating systems will [...]
  6. Siddharth at 10:05am 12th October 2010 i use windows vista......had got it with my computer an year back...guys just wanted to tell u all one thing ....ITS NOT BAD.....i use it for everyday for surfing ,gaming and home use etc...it works perfectly fine.doesnt even hang.its just made to look bad.many people tried to use it on their old rotting computers.i dont find any reason to Úpgrade to windows 7. p.s-i have service pack 2.
    1. Marcus at 2:17am 18th October 2010 are you stupid? i bought the same machine as you and it workd better on win7! you are a delusional indian!
      1. Siddharth at 6:04am 23rd October 2010 i am not a delusioned indian........u must be one from whichever country u are......by the way how do u know which machine i have? i didnt say that windows 7 is not better....i just said that i see no reason to upgrade.see before u type.
  7. Rosh at 1:58am 26th August 2010 Windows 7 Jump list is an amazing feature.. Read below how Win7shell Integrates Winamp with Windows 7 Taskbar and Jump List http://www.globinch.com/2010/07/11/win7shell-adds...
  8. Graydon at 5:14am 18th August 2010 I will be getting a new studio laptop soon Anyone know if Sony Acid Pro 7.0 works on W7 If you know please contact me at miclipzrecords@gmail.com subject as "2Miclipz"
  9. Gazza at 5:23am 13th August 2010 All my software have work on w7 when most did not on vista so I stayed with XP and some of my software go back w95. You just right click go to properties and then compatibility. So far I love it and think it is the best.
  10. Inexpensive Back-to-School Laptops and Desktops from AMD at 2:00am 23rd July 2010 [...] a 2.1 GHz dual-core Athlon processor, ATI 4250 graphics, and a 6.7-pound carry weight. It also has Windows 7 Home Premium, a built-in webcam, and about every memory card slot you can think of.HP dv5-2035dx [...]
  11. Ticked 2 at 10:11am 8th June 2010 also a bit ticked, one of 7's selling points was compatibility, I have hundreds of dollars wotrh of software that will not work on w7. Not happy about that and my business is loosing money daily as I try to find software that fits my needs.
  12. Russ at 3:41pm 3rd May 2010 Where can you get it for $30??????
  13. Wayne at 11:02pm 17th March 2010 You are dumb.
  14. Ticked Off at 8:35pm 14th March 2010 Windows 7 has more non compatibility issues with software than I have ever seen before. Another trip back to the drawing board and return with the drivers for previous software editions either that or be prepared to dish out anywhere fromm a few hundred to a thousand to replace simple programs, lets hope the future is better, if possible I will return to Vista and even XP
  15. Robroy at 2:58pm 5th January 2010 Truly, Ralph - we all know that you have no PC friends..
  16. henrylow at 4:30am 5th January 2010 Having been a part of the Online Universal Work Marketing team for 4 months now, I’m thankful for my fellow team members who have patiently shown me the ropes along the way and made me feel welcome

    www.onlineuniversalwork.com
  17. kiramatalishah at 7:22am 1st January 2010 Build Traffic!
    Here is an old rule! If you want to be really successful in affiliate marketing, you ought to drive traffic to your website. The more visitors to the website, the higher the probability of click through. Many affiliate guides forget to mention that it is always prudent to build traffic first and then consider affiliate marketing. There is no magic potion. If there is no traffic, there are no profits. Don’t worry, if you haven’t got hordes of visitors, even a few visitors will do initially. Once these visitors start trickling down the web drain, you can place banners and advertising in appropriate places to get the results. A good affiliate marketer doesn’t care about the number of clicks but on the average number of clicks per visitor.
    www.onlineuniversalwork.com
  18. MAP at 11:33pm 28th December 2009 Hi Martha,
    I'm sorry to hear that you are running into trouble with W7, but doesn't surprise me.
    eMachines are low cost PCs built by ACER. ACER doesn't produce high quality machines. Apple does. I don't have an eMachine (thanks God) but a DELL which came with pre-installed W7. The machine is not mine but it is a company machine (thanks God again), so at the end the problem is company's problem. The "IT" manager thought he was making a good deal buying this DELL at 2800$, but by now he may have changed his mind when he found out that a FAR superior quality Mac with the latest OS was in the market for 2500$ (the values are in Australian dollars, I am based in Australia)
    Mac will be my next personal computer, not this thing with its W7 horror installed.
    If you purchased your machine brand new, it should come with all the software installation disks, so I would not be worried to re-format the disk and make it ready for another OS.
    Personally, I would disconnect the HDD and have it replaced by a brand new one (good HDD are cheap these days) and I would install XP on the new disk.
    Also, if you have your old XP HDD I am afraid that installing this HDD in your new system won't work because your existing XP won't recognize the new hardware. For it to work, it should be installed properly.
    If you have an XP upgrade installation you will need to install a previous version in order to upgrade. I don't know if you have Windows 98 or Windows 95 to start with, but you can't install your XP from scratch because it's an upgrade.
    If your problem is that you don't have an older OS installation disk to start with, you will need the help of some friend. Also these old OS can be downloaded from the Internet (P2P mode) that would be worth a try. (Maybe eMachine can send you a XP disk installation after all, why don't you call eMachine for that disk?) I am sorry of not being more helpful at this point. Please let me know if you have resolved your problem.
    Best regards.
  19. Martha McLaughlin at 8:37am 28th December 2009 I agree MAP. I got an e-machine with windows 7 with Windows 7 built in.
    I hate the new control panel and keep getting error messages, some of which are in- accurate.
    I'm not sure if the problems are related to E-Machines or the OS. Is there a way to downgrade to XP?
    I have a windows up grade disk for XP but I'm not sure if I can use it to replace Windows 7.
    1. Mike Chudej at 11:41am 5th August 2010 The downgrade to XP is not really a downgrade. It will let you install XP as a 2nd operating system. You can use it that way.
  20. Ralph at 4:26pm 24th December 2009 Windows 7 will never match the Mac OS system. Does any one at Microsoft have a clue? For a system that works from the start get a Mac. That what I tell all my PC friends.
  21. MAP at 5:31am 23rd December 2009 After testing windows 7 and these features, all I want to say is "good luck" to microsoft, your product looks horrible, your product works horrible and your product IS horrible.
    I have awful issued with software, well, I think that there is a competition between Microsoft and Bentley to see who writes the worst and most backwards but it doesn't matter, because Windows 7 doesn't like Microstation and / or Microstation doesn't like Windows 7, in the balance I don't like any of the above and I don't see the moment for AutoDESK to come up with software able to run under Macs, because when the moment comes, I will be the first to burn this PC with Windows 7, Vista or whatever (CD installation disks included) and all the rest of the crap with them.
  22. nintendo dsi r4 at 1:01am 30th November 2009 Strong design and Microsoft don't always go together, but they do in Windows 7. Users might take a while to get used to the new taskbar and Aero Peek, but they're a pleasure to use.
  23. Mark Kelly at 10:04am 28th November 2009 Nice review of Windows 7 :) I really like the fact that you can get rid of the nasty pop-ups ;) Pop over to my blog and say helo http://www.iping.org/blog
  24. Ian Bell at 11:16pm 9th November 2009 I give it a 9. It runs fast, I haven't had any issues with software or hardware and it has a good looking, smooth interface. Definitely gives OS X a run for their money.
  25. setag at 6:07am 3rd November 2009 THERE ARE ONLY 3 EDITIONS: Home Premium, Professional and Ultimate. And you can get Home Premium for only $30. Windows 7 is the best OS EVER MADE
  26. TechFreak at 12:24am 21st October 2009 I don't think that Windows 7 is slow at all, in fact I think it blows Vista away. My system loads up faster from boot, and I rarely see it crash. I would say that it is on par with OSX. I do agree that 6 editions is just stupid. They need two maybe: Work and Home versions.
  27. JD at 7:32pm 20th October 2009 Windows 7 has had very clever marketing saying it's so good and building it up! but it's really still slow and Vista like! And 6 Editions of it? Microsoft is clearly money hungry and deceptive !
Close Suggestion Acer Aspire One 532h Hops On the Pine Trail Processor
View Article