Skip to main content

Uber wins war against de Blasio — for now

uber takes down searchable database with exact trip location date and time information hit  7 million fine in california regu
Image used with permission by copyright holder
Government officials in New York will not place a limit on how many new drivers Uber can add to its fleet, according to a New York Times report. Mayor Bill de Blasio and members of the city council had previously proposed to cap Uber’s growth for a year while the city studied the company’s contribution to traffic congestion.

But, with the fight turning bitter, de Blasio is now backing away from the proposal. Instead, the city will study Uber and other ride-hailing apps over a four-month period and will not impose a growth cap, according to the New York Times.

de Blasio and other government officials have objected to the ride-hailing app’s takeover, claiming that the influx of cars is contributing to congestion. But Uber has fired back in recent weeks, claiming the proposed bill would take opportunity away from poor New Yorkers who rely on Uber as the bootstrap they lift themselves up by. A video ad created by the company said the bill would harm job growth; Uber CEO Travis Kalanick’s Twitter feed has lately consisted of anti-de Blasio messages; and the Uber app has offered New York users a “de Blasio” option, which removes all cars from the map. Crucially, Governor Andrew Cuomo sided with Uber this morning, telling radio program “The Capitol Pressroom” that the service “is taking off like fire through dry grass and it’s offering a great service for people and it’s giving people jobs.”

“I don’t think government should be in the business of trying to restrict job growth,” Cuomo added.

And, as the New York Times editorial board recently pointed out, capping growth for ride-hailing companies would lock smaller companies like Lyft out of the competition against Uber.

Is Uber causing traffic jams? Or is de Blasio lashing out at ride-hailing companies from his cushy position in the pocket of the taxi industry? Both Uber and de Blasio’s arguments are somewhat specious. Uber’s suggestions that the proposed bill would wipe its fleet out entirely are silly — the company is already well-established in the city, and would still have been allowed to add more drivers under the proposal. The growth cap would certainly have been a burden, but not a company-killing one.

The supposition that Uber’s growth is bringing jobs to New York isn’t really true either. Uber is bringing money, but the company has always stressed that its drivers are not employees. They’re independent contractors who receive none of the traditional benefits that come with a full-time job: no health insurance, no 401k contributions. Even a typical part-time job provides a regular schedule and tax withholdings, things that Uber drivers don’t receive. Uber offers its drivers an opportunity akin to day labor, and drivers can make good money doing it — but Uber is not offering employment.

On the other hand is de Blasio’s claim that Uber drivers are clogging the streets of New York and that the problem requires serious study. While New York traffic is notoriously bad, it’s difficult to attribute the problem solely to the proliferation of ride-hailing apps in the city. New York’s transportation commissioner Polly Trottenberg admitted to WNYC that the presence of more drivers on the streets is only part of the problem, and that construction and economic factors play a role in congestion as well.

The newly proposed four-month study seems able to more accurately assess the impact of ride-hailing apps on traffic. If Uber grows and traffic worsens, then it makes sense to hold the company accountable. If Uber’s growth had been capped during the study, the outcome could not have given a clear answer on how the growth of ride-hailing apps affects traffic.

The City Council could vote on the new proposal as soon as tomorrow.

Editors' Recommendations

Kate Conger
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Kate is a freelance writer who covers digital security. She has also written about police misconduct, nail polish, DARPA…
Uber Copter is now available to everyone with the Uber app — in NY City
uber copter is a new on demand flight service between nyc and jfk

Uber has opened its New York City helicopter service to all of its customers, so now anyone with the ridesharing app — and $200 to spare — can take a flight between JFK Airport and a Manhattan helipad in just a few taps.

Uber Copter launched for its top-tier customers in July 2019, but the company now wants to gauge its popularity among all Uber customers in New York City as it considers further expansion of its various transportation options.

Read more
Uber investigators were forbidden from reporting criminal allegations to police
An Uber App on a smartphone.

A new report reveals that Uber's internal investigation team that handles customer complaints of crimes like sexual assault and rape is “forbidden” from reporting allegations against drivers to authorities. 

The Washington Post reports that Uber uses a three-strike system for its drivers and won’t remove them as a driver from the platform unless they get three strikes for “bad behavior.” Even still, when a driver is kicked off the platform, Uber doesn’t necessarily let local authorities, other rideshare companies, or background check firms know the driver’s behavior that provoked their removal. 

Read more
Here’s why your Uber or Lyft car always seems to be a Toyota Camry
2018 Toyota Camry

Ridesharing services like Uber and Lyft rely on drivers to provide their own cars, which should mean endless variety for riders. But drivers seem to prefer one car over others. The Wall Street Journal has confirmed what many riders likely suspected: Uber and Lyft drivers love the Toyota Camry.

A 2018 report by the New York City Taxi and Limousine Commission, the agency that regulates for-hire vehicles in the Big Apple, found that 38 percent of the 72,000 app-dispatched cars in the city were Camrys, noted The Wall Street Journal. In comparison, the second-place Honda Accord only accounted for 11 percent of ride-share cars, according to the report.

Read more