Skip to main content

YouTube’s ‘Time Watched’ signal was implemented because of misleading thumbnail previews

youtube-tv-fl
Image used with permission by copyright holder

YouTube mysteriously, and without an explanation, changed its recommendation algorithm last month to penalize videos that were garnering a high volume of clicks but weren’t keeping the attention of its viewers. The move may have indicated YouTube’s favoritism for original programming. But during an Ad:Tech panel this week, Laura Lee, Director/Head of Entertainment East Content Partnerships revealed that the decision to implement the Time Watched algorithm came after brainstorming ways to systematically prevent YouTube content creators from gaming its search engine.

The “gaming” she’s referring to is the use of thumbnails that misleadingly advertise videos. Content creators can take any single frame from their video and feature it as a preview thumbnail. These thumbnails proved to be a critical component in luring viewers to click on the video. Any YouTuber can tell you that it’s becoming increasingly difficult to have their content discovered on the platform, so creators will take any edge that they can get.

How it works, according to Lee, is that YouTubers will add just five seconds of irrelevant, often lewd or graphic, content for the sole purpose of using one frame from the content as a thumbnail.

“We talked to our product team and did a lot of A/B testing, and we felt that this was a bad user experience on YouTube and the users might not come back,” says Lee. “Part of our tinkering was that we didn’t reward those gaming the system.”

Even some of the upper echelon YouTubers weren’t immune to the update, and felt the initial impact. “All of a sudden some partners were like, ‘hey my view count isn’t as great as it used to be, what’s up with that?’ And not always but sometimes they were gaming the system,” recalls Lee.

She makes sure to point out that this change doesn’t necessarily favor feature length content and it shouldn’t be a logical extension of what content creators do. “Time spent for us could mean someone coming to watch five two minute clips for a total of 10 minutes. Or it could mean watching Machinima’s 19 minute Battlestar Galactica too.”

“We just want to make sure that we’re doing everything we can to surface content that’s relevant and very meaningful to the niche user,” Lee adds.

Since YouTube is able to figure out that you’ve watched five two minute videos rather than one 10 minute video, there’s probably a machine learning algorithm behind its search engine. When I asked Lee before the conference if YouTube could confirm that it was tracking its user’s viewing habits for the purpose of recommending targeted content, she neither confirmed nor denied my speculation.

But let’s entertain the theory for a second: It doesn’t take a fortune teller to see that the natural progression for YouTube’s search algorithm will evolve, if it hasn’t already, into an engine for suggesting targeted results. In other words, based on individual viewing habits, soon the same query searched by two different people may suggest two different, but tailored results.

With YouTube maintaining its position as the second largest search engine on the Web, if targeted results become a reality it could have a far-reaching impact for marketers and content creators alike.

Editors' Recommendations

Francis Bea
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Francis got his first taste of the tech industry in a failed attempt at a startup during his time as a student at the…
YouTube brings pinch to zoom and video navigation changes to everyone
The red and white YouTube logo on a phone screen. The phone is on a white background.

YouTube is updating its user interface with a slew of changes, and chief among them are the pinch-to-zoom feature and "precise" video navigation.

On Monday, YouTube announced quite a few updates to its viewing experience on mobile and web. Notably, the video-sharing platform said that it was finally "launching pinch to zoom and precise seeking to all users starting today."

Read more
10 longest videos on YouTube
YouTube logo on top-left corner of home screen

YouTube is a platform where you can watch millions of videos from around the world. Whether these videos are podcasts, reviews, or even reactions, YouTube has something for everyone. However, some content creators take it a step further and make their videos extra long. If you're looking for videos that last for over several hours, then you're in luck, because we've assembled ten of the longest videos currently on YouTube. Note that these may not be the absolute longest videos on YouTube, but we tried to limit the scope to entrees that have entertainment value. Somehow we suspect a clock countdown for 70 hours one second at a time wouldn't be very enjoyable.
10. The longest 5 seconds on YouTube.

If you ever wanted to see a five-second-long excerpt stretched out into a 19-hour thrill ride, check out this video from The Slow Mo Guys. As their chosen name suggests, these two men like to film in slow motion some crazy activities such as jumping on a water balloon, getting hit in the face with a soccer ball, and shooting a newton's cradle. "The longest 5 seconds on YouTube," which was released in 2016, stretches out a clip from their "Glass Explosion at 343,000 fps!" where they heat up a glass measuring cup and make its handle explode with only a squirt of water. Even though the build-up to this explosion is quite long, it's worth watching for the shattering effect alone.
9. I Counted To 100,000!

Read more
YouTube to overhaul channel names with @ handles for all
Youtube video on mobile. Credits: YouTube official.

YouTube is launching “handles” to make it easier for viewers to find and engage with creators on the video-sharing platform.

The change means that soon, every channel will have a unique handle denoted by an "@" mark, "making it easier for fans to discover content and interact with creators they love," the Google-owned company said in a post announcing the change.

Read more