Skip to main content

Apple exec Phil Schiller sticks to script on day one of Apple-Samsung patent trial

iPhone 5 vs Galaxy S3 angle side by side apple samsung
Image used with permission by copyright holder

With the selection of the eight-person jury taken care of on Monday, the latest Apple-Samsung patent trial kicked off for real in a San Jose, California court yesterday, with Apple’s senior vice president of marketing, Phil Schiller, taking the stand as the tech company’s first witness.

Apple is accusing Samsung of infringing five of its patents, each relating to software features found on its iOS mobile operating system. It’s seeking damages of $2 billion from the Korean electronics company, as well as a sales ban on several Samsung devices including the Galaxy S3 smartphone. A verdict is expected toward the end of the month.

phil schiller
Apple’s Phil Schiller. Image used with permission by copyright holder

According to reports, Schiller pretty much stuck to the script in his testimony, going over the same kind of points he made to a jury back in November during a retrial in another patent case with Samsung.

Using various graphs and charts sporting stats that won’t have looked out of place in one of Apple’s high-profile product launches, Schiller described the success and popularity of the company’s iPhone.

When asked about how he felt when he first set eyes on Samsung’s original Galaxy smartphone, Schiller replied, “It looked so much like an attempt to copy the iPhone.”

He added that Samsung’s alleged copying had “caused people to question some of the innovations we created,” adding, “I think it has confused people as to which products are creating this experience.”

The iPhone maker says it believes that in the US Samsung sold more than 37 million smartphones that violated its patents, and that 10 percent of those are, for Apple, lost sales.

Prior to Schiller’s testimony, opening arguments were laid out by both sides. While Apple pressed home the idea that Samsung had infringed a number of its patents by incorporating similar features into its own products, lawyers for the Korean tech firm argued that the Cupertino company’s damage claims are hugely exaggerated, while the patents relate to relatively minor software features.

The patents at the center of the court case include a “system and method for performing an action on a structure in computer-generated data,” where addresses and times are shown as links within messages, and “unlocking a device by performing gestures on an unlock image,” otherwise known as the ‘slide to unlock’ feature.

[via Re/code, BI]

Editors' Recommendations

Trevor Mogg
Contributing Editor
Not so many moons ago, Trevor moved from one tea-loving island nation that drives on the left (Britain) to another (Japan)…
How to turn off Activity Status on Instagram
Instagram on an iPhone.

Instagram is a popular social networking site that allows users to communicate through text, photos, and videos. One of its features is the app's Activity Status, which lets users know when someone was last active on the app or if they are currently online.

Read more
Grab a 4-pack of Apple AirTags while they’re on sale
Person holding an Apple AirTag.

If you're one of those people who always keep misplacing their stuff, then you may want to take advantage of Walmart's offer for the Apple AirTag. Four of the Bluetooth trackers, which will make sure that you never lose anything again, are available for just $80, following a $19 discount on the bundle's original price of $99. There's no telling how long this lowered price will last, so if you think you'll find some use for these tracking devices, it's highly recommended that you proceed with the purchase as soon as possible.

Why you should buy the Apple AirTag
The Apple AirTag is highlighted in our roundup of the best Bluetooth trackers as the top choice if you're invested in the iOS ecosystem. In addition to a quick and easy one-tap setup to link the tracking device to your iPhone or iPad, the Apple AirTag uses Apple's Find My network to keep track of your things. Precision Finding with Ultra Wideband technology will lead you to your Apple AirTag, with the help of the millions of devices in the Find My network that will work together to locate your missing item when you activate Lost Mode.

Read more
Huawei’s gorgeous Pura 70 phones just got expanded availability
Huawei Pura 70 pink, green, white, and black colors.

Huawei Pura 70 Huawei

After being announced for China in mid-April, the Huawei Pura 70 series is now confirmed for the EU market. Those in the European market can expect to preorder the Pura 70, Pura 70 Pro, and the top-tier Pura 70 Ultra starting May 2 for 999 euros, 1,199 euros, and 1,499 euros, respectively. This pricing is in line with what we saw in China, with the Ultra coming in at 9,999 yuan ($1,400) and the base Pura 70 at 5,499 yuan ($760).

Read more