Skip to main content

Suspects plead not guilty in lost iPhone 4 prototype case

Last year tech blog Gizmodo turned up with an iPhone 4 prototype in its possession. It was subsequently accused of receiving stolen goods. Last month, San Mateo County district attorney Steven Wagstaffe, having reviewed all the evidence, decided that no crime had been committed by Gizmodo.

Brian Hogan and Sage Wallower haven’t been quite so lucky. They’ve been accused of selling the iPhone 4 prototype to Gizmodo for $5,000. On Thursday the pair pleaded not guilty to misdemeanor theft charges.

A report by The Examiner says prosecutors allege that 22-year-old Hogan came across the phone in a bar in Redwood, near San Francisco, in March last year. It is believed to have been left by an Apple employee who’d been testing the device prior to its release.

Prosecutors are accusing Hogan and his friend, 28-year-old Wallower, of then selling it on to Gizmodo. Both guys face a misappropriation of lost property charge. Wallower is also charged with being in possession of stolen property.

According to district attorney Steven Wagstaffe, Hogan and Wallower should have tried to return the prototype to Apple instead of selling it.

The Examiner reports that Jeffrey Bornstein, acting as Hogan’s attorney, released a statement in August saying that Hogan was “extremely remorseful.”

“Although we do not believe that charges of any kind should have been filed, Brian fully accepts responsibility for his actions,” Bornstein said in the statement.

The judge set a pretrial conference date for October 11, with the trial date set for November 28.

The news comes just days after it emerged that another Apple employee left another prototype in another bar. Although the phone’s GPS signal led investigators to an address in San Francisco’s Bernal Heights district, they still couldn’t find the device. It’s thought that it could be the much-anticipated iPhone 5, likely to be launched in the coming weeks.

Editors' Recommendations

Trevor Mogg
Contributing Editor
Not so many moons ago, Trevor moved from one tea-loving island nation that drives on the left (Britain) to another (Japan)…
Best iPhone deals: Save on iPhone 15, iPhone 15 Pro Max and more
iPhone 13 Pro in blue.

The Apple iPhone is likely the most popular smartphone of all time, and even older models are still seeing impressive sales. This popularity can make it difficult to find iPhone deals, but there are quite a few hanging around out there right now and some of them could be considered among the best phone deals currently taking place. And while you can always shop refurbished iPhone deals to ensure some savings, we think we’ve found some iPhone deals worth taking a look at right now. They include the newest model iPhone 15, so whether you’re looking for the latest and greatest or an iPhone that simply gets the job done, read onward and start shopping the best iPhone deals going on right now.
iPhone 15 128GB (AT&T) — $730, was $830 (plus up to $700 off w/ trade-in)

The Apple iPhone 15 finally brings with it Dynamic Island which we’ve only previously seen on the Pro range. It’s a real game changer at times and is very convenient. Alongside that, the Apple iPhone 15 has the Ceramic Shield front to keep it more protected while its 6.1-inch Super Retina XDR display promises to be up to two times brighter than the iPhone 14 in the sun. There’s also a 48MP main camera with 2x telephoto lens to help you take great shots. The A16 Bionic chip has plenty of processing power to aid with software adjustments.

Read more
5 phones you should buy instead of the iPhone 15
A green iPhone 15 on a green bench.

Apple’s iPhone lineup continues to be among its bestselling products. In 2023, we got the iPhone 15, which packs some of Apple’s latest and greatest tech and starts at $800.

The iPhone 15 is one of the easiest iPhone recommendations in 2024. But if you're open to a few other suggestions, there are some great alternatives to consider — including cheaper iPhone options and some really compelling Android phones. Here are five other phones you should consider buying instead of the iPhone 15.
iPhone 14

Read more
How to find your lost phone (tips for iPhone and Android)
The Motorola Edge Plus 2023 lying next to the Galaxy S23 Ultra and iPhone 14 Pro.

Not knowing how to find your smartphone can cause a real panic when the need arises. It likely has way too much information about you, has access to your bank details and stock portfolio, and can grant access into pretty much any personal sphere of your life. Plus, you're likely addicted to your smartphone in ways that no device has ever addicted humankind before. In short, if you've lost your phone, you may start to panic.

Read more