Skip to main content

There’s a hidden environmental cost to renting electric scooters to get around

Lyft Scooter

Electric scooters are touted as an environmentally-friendly way to get around town, but a new study suggests that they might be worse for climate change than the transportation methods they’re replacing.

While the escooters don’t emit carbon, which is why they’re often considered greener than other modes of transportation, they’re also typically made in China. Making and moving those scooters to the United States creates a carbon footprint, as does moving them around in the cities where they operate. Within cities, scooters are often moved around using gasoline-powered cars. The data comes in a new report from North Carolina State University that was published in the journal Environmental Research Letters on Friday.

The report says that while dock-less shared escooters are touted as a last-mile problem to help reduce traffic and congestion, they’re also not technically accomplishing that goal. According to the study, half of escooter riders would have walked or biked that last mile if the scooter wasn’t available, making it so the escooters are actually adding to the congestion problem rather than helping it. Just a third of respondents to the group’s study said they would have used a car for that last mile of their journey if the scooter was not available.

The news isn’t all bad. The study says that the global warming impact of a scooter is roughly half that of a gasoline-powered car, taking into account the creation of both the car and the scooter. So while that scooter isn’t as good as walking or biking to your destination, it is better than getting behind the wheel of a traditional gasoline-powered automobile.

It can also get better, the study says:

“Alternative approaches to collect and distribute escooters can greatly reduce the adverse environmental impacts. Reducing the average driving distance for collection and distribution to 0.6 miles per scooter reduces the average life cycle global warming impacts by 27%, while the exclusive use of fuel-efficient vehicles for collection results in a 12% reduction,” reads the report. “Limiting scooters collection to those with a low battery state of charge would require a change in policy to allow scooters to remain in public spaces overnight, but could yield a net reduction in global warming impacts of 19%.”

The report also suggests creating better ways to increase the life of the scooters. Escooters are often vandalized, which increases their environmental impact due to the replacement of parts or the entire scooter. The study suggests creating sturdier scooters and better ways to combat damage can help increase their lifespan and decrease their environmental impact.

“We welcome research into the environmental benefits of new mobility options and have already made significant progress on many of the areas highlighted in the study,” Allie Zamaria, a spokeswoman for scooter rental company Lime, told Digital Trends in a statement.

“Lime has made continuous advancements in sustainability, introducing sturdier and longer-lasting scooters, charging with renewable energy, and streamlining operations, from collection and rebalancing to repair and reuse.”

We’ve asked Uber and Lyft, which both have scooter services in some cities, for comment as well and will update this story if we hear back.

Editors' Recommendations

Emily Price
Emily is a freelance writer based in San Francisco. Her book "Productivity Hacks: 500+ Easy Ways to Accomplish More at…
Lyft may join the party by putting its own electric scooters in San Francisco
Riding a scooter in San Francisco

Already a partner in a bike-sharing scheme in Baltimore, Maryland, Lyft is now eyeing the launch of a scooter-sharing scheme in San Francisco.

The news comes via The Information, which recently learned that Lyft representatives have been seeking advice from local transportation officials about the possibility of obtaining permits for such a scheme.

Read more
Scoot around town on the Kiwano K01 electric scooter — or have it follow you
kiwano electric scooter black 45 degrees t

Since the reveal of the original Segway, self-balancing transportation has taken off in a variety of styles and methods. Joining the market is the Kiwano K01 electric scooter.

The Kiwano electric scooter uses a sleek design to provide a stable, intuitive mode of transportation. Like other self-balancing scooters on the market, the Kiwano features responsive body control. What truly sets it apart is its ability to control wirelessly. Users can get off, press a button, and the Kiwano will follow along.

Read more
The Immotor Go electric scooter wheels you around in style
immotor go super battery rsz download 2

Segways. Ebikes. Hoverboards. The field of personal transportation is a booming one, and likely to remain one for some time: By some estimates, the personal transportation device market is forecast to grow to nearly 25 million owners by 2020. The problem? Supplying power to the devices on which all those folks will be riding, and doing so safely. But ambitious startup Immotor is proposing a solution: the Immotor Go scooter and its companion modular power cell, the Super Battery.

Immotor isn't your average mobility company. It's helmed by executive-turned-entrepreneur Daniel Huang, former CEO of mobile device company Mophie, whose founding goal was nothing less than an entirely new category of personal transportation. He envisioned a internet-connected scooter that would put features like turn-by-turn directions and cruise control at riders' fingertips, but crucially one with a power delivery method energy-efficient, replaceable, and resistant to wear and tear. Years of research and development later, Huang's unveiled the realization of that dream in the Immotor Go.

Read more