Study finds motorists overestimate Autopilot’s capabilities; Tesla disagrees

tesla autopilot black box model s oped

The Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS) has asked automakers for more transparency when it comes to what semi-autonomous technology can and can’t do. The independent, non-profit organization carried out two separate studies, and it concluded many motorists are convinced semi-autonomous systems are far more capable than they truly are. This behavior can lead to potentially deadly accidents, but Tesla said its own research tells a completely different story.

The IIHS focused on five level-two systems: Autopilot (Tesla), Traffic Jam Assist (Audi and Acura, though they’re two different systems), Super Cruise (Cadillac), Driving Assistance Plus (BMW), and ProPilot Assist (Nissan). After polling over 2,000 drivers, it learned some of these names are misleading because they suggest motorists don’t need to pay attention to the road. The organization notably singled out Autopilot.

It asked participants whether they thought it was acceptable to take their hands off the steering wheel, talk on a cell phone, send a text message, watch a movie, and sleep while using the aforementioned systems. 48 percent replied it’s OK to take both hands off the wheel while using Autopilot, compared to 33 percent for ProPilot Assist, the second-highest score. Tesla scored higher than others in the four remaining areas. Six percent of users alarmingly said they believed they could doze off after engaging Autopilot. The IIHS did not reveal the age or the driving experience of the motorists it polled.

“Manufacturers should consider what message the names of their systems send to people,” IIHS president David Harkey wrote. Super Cruise and Autopilot perform essentially the same functions, and Cadillac’s system even lets drivers take their hands off the wheel when the right conditions are met, but Tesla’s technology arguably sounds like the more capable of the two.

Tesla told Digital Trends it doesn’t agree with the study’s conclusion.

“This survey is not representative of the perceptions of Tesla owners or people who have experience using Autopilot, and it would be inaccurate to suggest as much. If IIHS is opposed to the name Autopilot, presumably they are equally opposed to the name automobile. Tesla provides owners with clear guidance on how to properly use Autopilot, as well as in-car instructions before they use the system and while the feature is in use. If a Tesla vehicle detects that a driver is not engaged while Autopilot is in use, the driver is prohibited from using it for that drive,” the company said in an email sent to Digital Trends.

The second study found many motorists are confused about the technology-related messages they see in their car’s instrument cluster. The IIHS showed participants some of the icons that can appear on the digital instrument cluster of a 2017 Mercedes-Benz E-Class. Those who hadn’t received training had a difficult time figuring out what they meant; for example, they weren’t able to tell when the car’s lane-centering function turned itself off, and why. Those who received training were less confused by the messages. They knew what was going on, but they often didn’t understand why. Again, the IIHS hasn’t released the age and the driving experience of the motorists that participated in the study.

“If your level two system fails to detect a vehicle ahead because of a hill or curve, you need to be ready to brake. Likewise, when lane centering does not work because of a lack of lane lines, you need to steer. If people aren’t understanding when those lapses occur, manufacturers should find a better way of alerting them,” Harkey concluded.

The aforementioned systems are clearly detailed in the car’s owner’s manual, whether it’s an actual book or an app on a screen, but motorists rarely take the time to sit down and read it. While we’ve grown accustomed to learning how to use new technology as we go, a sensor-powered function that prevents a car from veering out of its lane at 80 mph is different than a new filter on a smartphone-based photo-editing app, and learning the correct way to use it is a worthwhile way to spend five or 10 minutes.

We’ve reached out to Mercedes-Benz, and we’ll update this story if we hear back.

Updated 6-21-2019: Added Tesla’s statement.


Awesome Tech You Can’t Buy Yet: Wearable chargers and A.I.-enhanced keyboards

Check out our roundup of the best new crowdfunding projects and product announcements that hit the web this week. You may not be able to buy this stuff yet, but it sure is fun to gawk!

Cadillac’s new 2020 CT5 sedan lets you Super Cruise across America

The 2020 Cadillac CT5 proves the General Motors-owned luxury brand still cares about sedans. Introduced at the 2019 New York Auto Show, it's optionally available with Cadillac's Super Cruise technology and a lineup of turbocharged engines.

How Lexus, one of the industry’s hybrid champions, is preparing for the 2020s

Lexus predicts significant shifts will reshape the automotive industry during the 2020s. The hybrid champion is preparing to branch out into electric cars, it's investing in autonomous technology, and it wants to keep focusing on SUVs.

AWD vs. 4WD: What’s the difference between the two and which is right for you?

Although four-wheel drive (4WD) and all-wheel drive (AWD) are related, they are actually quite different in how they operate. Here, we talk about the fundamental differences between the two systems, and what it means for you as a driver.
Product Review

The 2020 Alpina B7 is a BMW 7 Series crossed with a bullet train

Alpina began making hot-rodded BMWs years before anyone heard of an M5. Digital Trends traveled to scenic Bavaria to put the B7, its flagship model, through its paces on a variety of roads.

Cadillac drivers can now find and pay for parking from their dashboards

Cadillac hopes to make parking easier with a new embedded feature that allows drivers to find, reserve, and pay for parking spaces from their dashboard. It's the latest new feature of General Motors Marketplace.

I used to be a die-hard petrol-head, but Jaguar’s electric SUV converted me

Simply put, the Jaguar I-Pace is the first electric vehicle I’ve driven that hasn’t made me miss an internal combustion engine, or even once consider that I’m in an electric car. Regardless of how it is propelled, the I-Pace is a…

Polaris builds Lunar Rover Vehicle replica with Indian, Slingshot, and RZR parts

Polaris Industries employees worked with a NASA astronaut and members of the original Apollo 11 Lunar Rover Vehicle (LRV) team to build a replica of the vehicle that landed on the moon. Most of the parts came from current Polaris vehicles.

2020 Lincoln Aviator adaptive suspension scans the road for potholes

The 2020 Lincoln Aviator's adaptive suspension system uses an array of sensors to detect potholes and other road imperfections, then preemptively adjusts settings to maintain a smooth ride.

Audi’s latest suspension system can help protect you during a crash

The Audi A8 is getting a more sophisticated adaptive suspension system for the European market. The system can raise or lower the body in a fraction of a second, improving ride, handling, and even safety, according to Audi.

Tesla Model 3 is the world’s most-searched-for electric car, survey says

The Tesla Model 3 is the most-searched-for electric car in the world, according to a survey of Google search data. The Nissan Leaf and Tesla Model S were far behind the Model 3 in second and third place, respectively.

For $25 a month, Uber will give you rides, rent you a scooter, and grab dinner

Uber is working on a monthly subscription plan that gives users access to discounted rides, free Uber Eats food delivery, and free JUMP bike and scooter rides. The plan is being tested in San Francisco and Chicago.

Amazon wants Alexa embedded in every vehicle to connect with smart homes

Amazon is following up on Alexa's penetration into smart homes with an incursion to embed the voice assistant in cars. There are third-party Alexa-compatible automotive aftermarket products, but the big score is in-vehicle software systems.

Toyota shows off mascot robots and tiny autonomous car for Tokyo Olympics

Toyota has shown off seven robots that it says will assist and entertain during the Tokyo Olympics next summer. The collection includes mascot and telepresence robots, as well as a tiny autonomous car to help during field events.