Skip to main content

AOL Unfazed by Paid-Email Criticism

America Online says it plans to begin offering a new pay-to-send email system to customers within the next 30 days, despite growing criticism from a diverse group of organizations claiming AOL’s plan amounts to a de-facto “email tax.”

AOL plans to launch the system, run by Goodmail, through which advertisers and other senders would pay a fee (from roughly ¼ to 1 cent per message) to guarantee their messages will successfully reach AOL subscribers. Paid messages would bypass AOL’s spam filtering technologies and arrive in users’ mailboxes certified as legitimate. Yahoo is also planning to institute a similar service via Goodmail for transactional messages (such as account statements, policy notifications, and receipts) in “the coming months,” although AOL will be the first out of the gate.

Recommended Videos

However, the system is drawing mounting criticism from an increasingly diverse range of organizations, who claim the system will end up blocking legitimate mail from groups which can’t afford to pay AOL’s delivery fee. Political action group MoveOn.org has mounted a campaign against the move, which, although not yet calling for an outright boycott of AOL, openly says a boycott campaign is a possibility. The group has launched a Web site, www.dearaol.com carrying what amounts to an open letter to AOL protesting the pay-per-message deliver plan, and listing supporters as diverse as the AFL-CIO, computer book publisher Tim O’Reilly, the United Farm Workers, Oxfam America, the Consumer Federation of America, and the Gun Owners of America.

Some advertisers and businesses who use email to communicate with their customers argue the service would help users discriminate between legitimate communications and fraudulent messages like phishing schemes. For its part, AOL contends nothing will change for mailers who do not buy into the new system: their mail will be subject to spam and junk mail filtering it always has been.

However, some senders think AOL’s new system may further irritate AOL users. AOL has not made any claims about auditing the email practices of the organizations using the new system (through Goodmail has published some criteria, including fee structures, policy requirements, with enforcement largely managed by “reputation scores”). In “certifying” email, AOL is in no way saying the sender follows ethical email practices, merely that the sender was accredited by Goodmail. To ordinary users, the only meaningful distinction between everyday spam and AOL’s certified email might be that they can’t expect AOL to do anything to make the “certified” messages go away.

[Updated 01-Mar-2006 to link to GoodMail’s program qualifications, detail Yahoo’s stated intentions, and correct two typographical errors.]

Geoff Duncan
Former Contributor
Geoff Duncan writes, programs, edits, plays music, and delights in making software misbehave. He's probably the only member…
Apple could tie up with Sony for a critical Vision Pro upgrade
A man wears an Apple Vision Pro headset.

Apple hasn’t quite tasted the domain-shifting success it expected with the Vision Pro headset. A price tag worth $3,500 was already a deterrent, but the gaming ecosystem — a key driver for the VR segment — has also been lackluster. The company is now hoping to fix that situation with some help from Sony.

According to Bloomberg, the two companies have been working together to bring support for the PlayStation VR 2’s controllers to the pricey Apple headset. “Apple has discussed the plan with third-party developers, asking them if they’d integrate support into their games,” adds the report.

Read more
Gmail may add a handy temporary email address feature
Moto G 5G (2024) in Sage Green showing Gmail.

Future Gmail versions could include support for temporary email addresses if Google ever enables this feature that has been discovered within its app code.

Android Authority discovered the feature, referred to as “Shielded Email,” within the code of the recent 24.45.33 release of the Google Play Services APK. The publication detailed that its APK teardown revealed several clues about how the feature would work.

Read more
Opening more than 60 emails could crash Outlook
Scheduling an email in Outlook in Firefox on a MacBook.

As Microsoft reports on its Support page, the Outlook app is facing a new issue that causes it to crash when you open more than 60 emails simultaneously. This adds to an existing problem with the Ctrl + C keyboard shortcut. The software giant is investigating the problem and its possible cause.

When you open over 60 emails on the Outlook app or try the keyboard combination when copying text, the app freezes and displays different error messages. However, the error messages include tips for fixing the issue. You might see a message that says: "Sorry, we're having trouble opening this item. This could be temporary, but if you see it again, you might want to restart Outlook. Out of memory or system resources. Close some windows or programs and try again."

Read more