Are new laptops really faster? As it turns out, not by much anymore

Are new laptops really faster

The traits consumers desire in a laptop have changed a bit over the last few years. There was a time, just five years ago, when most people didn’t expect any computer to offer a long-lasting battery. Then, smartphones and tablets changed expectations, and laptops were forced to catch up.

And caught up they have. Today’s best laptops offer roughly six to seven hours of continuous web-browsing and, in less demanding situations, can last well into the teens. While tablets still hold the crown, computers have closed the gap significantly.

But there’s no such thing as a free lunch. Improvements in efficiency have been flanked by a decreasing interest in performance. We found that the latest MacBook Pro 13 with Retina, for example, is slightly slower than its predecessor, and Intel’s new 4th-gen Core processors do not seem noticeably quicker than those that came before. Has performance really stalled, or just merely shifted to other areas?

Processors are running in place

To judge whether processors have made a significant leap forward, we decided to pick out a few past laptops with various generations of the Intel Core processor. The first generation is represented by the Asus U36JC, the second generation by the HP Envy 14 and Lenovo ThinkPad T420s, the third generation by Asus Zenbook Prime UX31 and Lenovo ThinkPad X230, and the fourth generation by the Dell XPS 12 and Lenovo T440s.

All of these laptops posted scores we considered average to above average at the time they were reviewed, so they’re a good representation of other systems we tested near the same time. The laptops are listed in order of review date, oldest at the bottom, latest at the top. And importantly, all systems are equipped with a dual-core processor.

laptopperformance1

What the results show is that performance peaked in the middle, which corresponds roughly with the final days of Intel’s 2nd-gen Core processors and the introduction of Intel’s 3rd-gen Core product line. The ThinkPad X230, the fastest system on this chart, was reviewed a year and a half ago but remains the second-quickest dual-core laptop we’ve ever tested. Only the ASUS Zenbook UX301LA, which we recently reviewed, scores better – but its expensive Core i7-4558U processor isn’t representative of what most current laptops provide.

At first glance, then, it would seem that performance has barely budged over the past three years, and has actually fallen back compared to a year ago. In an absolute sense this is true; our most recently tested laptops are slower on average than what we tested in the middle of 2012. So what’s the deal?

Intel 4th gen haswell chip low power process

Well, this isn’t really an apples-to-apples comparison. Intel’s introduction of the ultrabook not only added a new super-slim option to the market, but also encouraged computer manufacturers to use low-voltage processors in a wide range of products. No one has sent us a review laptop with a “standard” dual-core processor in months, and a quick look at Intel’s product information shows that only three of the fifteen 4th-gen Core i5 mobile processors sold by the company are not low-voltage.

In other words, the typical laptop sold in the last year or two was quicker in terms of raw compute performance, but it also drew significantly more power. The blazing-fast ThinkPad X230, for example, lasted only four and a half hours in our light-load test despite its massive 63 watt-hour battery.

There’s more to it than the processor

While the X230 was a very quick laptop, we think that, if we tested it again today, it might feel a bit slow. Why? Because it had a mechanical hard drive.

Though a mechanical drive offers a lot of storage space it is also slower than a solid state drive in both response times (the delay between requesting a file and the drive beginning to load it) and bandwidth (the maximum amount of data that can be handled per second). PCMark 8’s storage benchmark, which we use to gauge the speed of a laptop’s hard drive, usually reaches a score between 1,800 and 2,400 in laptops with a mechanical drive. That increases to between 4,500 and 5,000 when we tests systems with a solid state drive.

Solid-state drive
JIPEN/Shutterstock

Though SSDs are not yet standard on the most affordable PCs, they have crept into systems sold below $1,000, and many ultrabooks with a mechanical drive use a small cache SSD to provide some of the benefits at a low price. We don’t think it’s an exaggeration to say that an SSD is the single most important performance upgrade a laptop can receive.

3D performance has improved, too, thanks to Intel’s attempts to improve the speed and feature set of its integrated graphics chips. 1st-gen and 2nd-gen Intel Core processors didn’t even support DirectX 11 graphics, which meant some games would not even run without a discrete GPU installed, and performance was generally abysmal.

Intel HD 4000 added DX11 support, however, boosting performance substantially. Today’s laptops, which usually ship with Intel HD 4600 graphics, can run almost any 3D game sold, though the latest titles still won’t play smoothly above low detail on a 1080p display. You can read more about the latest Intel integrated graphics option by reading our review of Intel HD 4600.

Long lasting, but not faster

The fact that laptop performance has stalled seems strange at first, and contrary to the progress computers have traditionally made. When closer inspected, however, it makes some sense. We have progressed well past the point where performance is a day-to-day concern for most users. The question in the consumer’s mind has shifted from “how quickly will my software run?” to “how long can I use my software?”

Speed freaks shouldn’t fret too much, however, because it’s likely that the current state of affairs is temporary. Consumer interest in battery life forced Intel to cut back power draw so aggressively that compromising performance was inevitable. Laptops are now capable of lasting for at least a work day, however, and the average user probably doesn’t need more than that. Eventually, the excitement over battery life will also lose its luster, giving performance a chance to step back into the limelight. 

Product Review

Amid a new fleet of budget laptops, the ZenBook 13 sails where others sink

It’s never been truer that you don’t need to spend over a thousand bucks to buy a good laptop. The ZenBook 13 takes we’ve always loved about its predecessor and makes enough small refinements to keep it ahead of its competitors.
Computing

What's the best laptop? We've reviewed a lot of them, and this is our answer

The best laptop should be one that checks all the boxes: Great battery life, beautiful design, and top-notch performance. The laptops we've chosen for our best laptops you can buy do all that — and throw in some extra features while…
Product Review

Dell’s G3 Gaming laptop knows what gamers want, and what they can live without

Compromise and budget gaming laptops go hand-in-hand, but with the G3, Dell has figured out how to balance what gamers want with what they can live without.
Computing

'World's best gaming processor'? We put Intel's new i9 through the ringer

Intel has launched the first Core i9 for the average gamer. Despite some controversies around its release, it’s the fastest gaming processor we’ve yet tested.
Computing

Capture screenshots with print screen and a few alternative methods

Capturing a screenshot of your desktop is easier than you might think, but it's the kind of thing you'll probably need to know. Here's how to perform the important function in just a few, easy steps.
Virtual Reality

Oculus Rift, HTC Vive head-to-head: Prices drop, but our favorite stays the same

The Oculus Rift and HTC Vive are the two big names in the virtual-reality arena, but most people can only afford one. Our comparison tells you which is best when you pit the Oculus Rift vs. HTC Vive.
Emerging Tech

Awesome Tech You Can’t Buy Yet: A.I.-powered cat toys, wallets, food containers

Check out our roundup of the best new crowdfunding projects and product announcements that hit the web this week. You may not be able to buy this stuff yet, but it sure is fun to gawk!
Emerging Tech

Looking for a good read? Here are the best, most eye-opening books about tech

Sometimes it's sensible to put down the gadgets and pick up a good old-fashioned book -- to read about the latest gadgets, of course. Here are the tech books you need to check out.
Gaming

The 'Fallout 76' beta starts tomorrow! Here's when it starts and how to join

Want to get into Bethesda's Fallout 76 beta? We don't know when the program will launch, but we provide instructions on how to get ready. The game officially launches on November 14.
Computing

Samsung’s HMD Odyssey Plus gives you a clearer view into the virtual world

Samsung's refreshed HMD Odyssey+ promises to make Windows Mixed Reality experiences better by eliminating pixelated views caused by screen doors. The $500 headset also focuses on comfort this year with ergonomic improvements.
Computing

Intel denies rumors that 10nm Cannon Lake CPUs have been canned

Intel's long-in-development and oft-delayed, Cannon Lake 10nm CPU design has reportedly been canceled. Intel is denying the rumor, but if true, it could push back the release of new Intel chips by a long time.
Computing

Not to be outdone, Samsung says it’s making a laptop with a foldable display

Samsung announced that it is also working on a dual-screen computer. But rather than using two separate display panels, Samsung said that its novel laptop will come with a large flexible display that can fold when closed.
Photography

Free your digital memories, and frame them, with the best photo printers

Printed photos are experiencing a revival at the moment, but you don’t need to go to a special lab. Here’s our favorite options for making quality prints, from pocket-sized printers to wide-format photo printers capable of spitting out…
Computing

A new bug in the Windows 10 October 2018 Update could delete your files

The Windows 10 October 2018 Update has been on a rough path and in the latest set of issues, a new bug is impacting native zip file operations, potentially leading to overwritten files in some instances.