Dishonored: The Knife of Dunwall DLC review

dishonored the knife of dunwall dlc review cover art
Dishonored: The Knife of Dunwall DLC
“The story of Dishonored expands with a new protagonist, new powers, and more of the solid gameplay that made the game a hit”
Pros
  • The strong gameplay returns but with a few twists
  • Three new massive sections with multiple ways to approach your objectives
  • A compelling story
Cons
  • The DLC ends on a cliffhanger
  • With only three missions you don’t have time to level up

I liked Dishonored a bunch. It took familiar mechanics and introduced several new twists to those, then topped it off with fresh options on how to put it all together. I tried it out as a standard combat-based game for a bit, but like any good obsessive the chance to make it through an entire area without a single person seeing me was appealing. It meant that most of my time was spent replaying the same sections over and over and over again, but it was worth it for that one moment when you completed an area and could proudly look back at your enemies with middle fingers held high, knowing they wouldn’t be offended because they didn’t even know you were there.

Dishonored plays with the typical convention of the FPS, and does it well. It presents unique tools that let you handle things in a way you haven’t quite seen before. The story was on the weak side, but the narrative was really just there to give you an excuse to explore new gameplay options. That doesn’t mean the story was bad, it just wasn’t the driving force of the game. The same is true of the new DLC, The Knife of Dunwall.

Knife puts you in the role of Daud, the assassin that killed the Empress at the beginning of the vanilla campaign, an action that Daud has come to regret. Shortly after that act the mysterious Stranger, the being that gifted Corvo, Daud, and a handful of others with their powers, tells Daud that he should seek out “Delilah,” but gives no other hints as to why or even who that is.  

Daud’s search eventually takes him across three new areas of the city of Dunwall, each with multiple sections. Like Corvo, Daud has several fantastic – and unique – abilities. Daud is missing a few key powers that Corvo has, like the ability to possess, but instead he can call on assassins and even level them up so they have their own abilities. Corvo is the stronger character, but it really is mostly a tradeoff.

Each area offers Daud plenty of mission goals as well as a handful of optional objectives – some of which you can get a leg up on by buying help before the mission. This help might come in the form of a safe combination left out for you that allows you to complete an optional objective, or it may offer you a new rune.

As with the vanilla game, the way you play will change the options presented. If you decide to spare a target, you may not have the option to destroy something that would inadvertently kill them; or you may kill someone before they can tell you information you need to complete another objective that won’t be available to you after that. The optional missions are not always apparent either. Some may require you to explore and find documents or talk to a person you had no idea was there before they are triggered. How you play is up to you, and there are options that suit all playstyles.

The areas are big and have multiple points of ingress, so there are options there as well. That also makes it tough to say how long the DLC is. If you want to burn through it and kill anyone in your way, you could conceivably make it through in 2-3 hours at most. If you play stealth, however, it will take you longer. Daud starts out with only a few powers, just as Corvo did at the start of the game, so his abilities are initially limited. Things like teleporting using the Blink power have limited range at first, and you’ll have to work up  to earn abilities like bending time. That can make it tougher to go stealth at first, and requires patience to learn the patterns. In that case, the game takes much longer. That shouldn’t be anything unfamiliar to Dishonored fans though.

Conclusion

And that’s where Knife succeeds. It is more of the same, but with just enough of a twist on it to make it feel like an important and justifiable addition to the game. There is a catch though.

The Knife of Dunwall is the first of two DLCs, the second of which, The Brigmore Witches, will conclude Daud’s story. No release date has been given yet. Since the game is so heavy on the gameplay side it’s forgivable, but if you are in deeply into the narrative you may want to wait for the conclusion – even though the cost may a bit prohibitive. If that isn’t an issue though and you just want more DishonoredThe Knife of Dunwall is for you.

(This DLC was reviewed on the Xbox 360 using a code provided by the publisher)

Editors' Recommendations

Former Digital Trends Contributor
Ryan Fleming is the Gaming and Cinema Editor for Digital Trends. He joined the DT staff in 2009 after spending time covering…
Major Redfall patch adds 60 fps performance mode, a stealth overhaul, and more

Xbox exclusive Redfall just got a major patch. The update adds a long-awaited 60 frames per second (fps) mode to the game, as well as a heap of quality of life upgrades and an overhaul to stealth gameplay.
Among lots of other problems, the dame infamously only ran at 30 fps at launch on Xbox Series X and S. While Arkane Studios promised a performance mode patch was in the works prior to release, it didn't arrive until today.

On October 6, Arkane Studios and Bethesda dropped Update 2 for Redfall. The most notable addition is Performance Mode, which lets players prioritize frame rate over resolution to finally get the game to run at 60 fps on consoles. Simply navigate to the Video tab within Redfall's settings menu to activate it. The patch notes for this update claim it brings improved stability on PC, in addition to solutions to memory-based crashes and AMD GPU-related graphics corruption. The update also contains some new gameplay tweaks to hopefully make the experience better.
Redfall will now encourage stealth more, as Arkane added the ability to sneak up on and do stealth takedowns on enemies and made it clearer which weapons are silenced in menus. It also added more options for players to fine-tune aim assets and dead zones while aiming, increased the number of enemies wandering the game's open world, and added unique ping colors for each player in a multiplayer squad. You can check out the full list of patch notes to see the additional tweaks and bug fixes made.
Redfall had a notoriously rocky launch this year, so it was hard for anyone outside of Microsoft to truly know whether or not improvements to the game would actually be delivered. Bethesda's Pete Hines had previously claimed it wouldn't abandon the game, and this update is our first real indication that it's true. While this isn't a Phantom Liberty-level rework for Redfall, it certainly seems like the game is now in the best condition it's been in since launch.
Redfall is available now for PC, Xbox Series X, and Xbox Series S.

Read more
Should you choose Aceles or Microbe in Starfield?

Starfield has perhaps Bethesda's best main narrative yet, however, most people will still prefer to spend most of their playtime going through the various faction questlines. Among all the different groups out there that your character can join, one of the earliest and most appealing is the UC Vanguard. During one of these faction quests called "A Legacy Forged," you will have a critical decision to make regarding the use of either Aceles or Microbes to stop the deadly Terromorph threat. The consequences of which one you pick won't be made clear until after you commit, so here are the repercussions of each decision in Starfield.
Should you choose Aceles or Microbe?

The Terromorphs are a created species designed to completely destroy whatever environment they encounter and must not be allowed to propagate. To contain this threat, Abello from the UC Council presents you with two options to destroy the Terromorphs: Aceles and Microbes.

Read more
Dishonored 3: release date window, rumors, and more

The Dishonored series has always been a critical darling and it has cultivated a small, but passionate fanbase. The original game got some DLC, a sequel in Dishonored 2, and one last entry called Death of the Outsider in 2017, but since then the franchise has remained dormant. The studio's latest game, Deathloop, shares some DNA with Dishonored, but is certainly its own beast. However, since the success of that new IP far exceeded anything Dishonored had achieved, many fans felt we'd never return to Dunwall to see the conclusion of the story. Thanks to the recent leak of some court documents related to the Activision purchase by Xbox, which owns Dishonored publisher Bethesda, new hope has appeared for the existence of Dishonored 3.
Release window

According to the leaked documents, which we should still take with skepticism until an official public statement is made, Dishonored 3 is currently planned for a "FY24E" release. FY24E is shorthand for Fiscal Year 2024, which runs between April 2024 and March 2025. Again, things are likely to change, if they haven't already, but this is at least a good starting point to predict the earliest we might see it.
Platforms
Again, this is just speculation until the game is officially confirmed, but considering that Xbox owns publisher Bethesda, Dishonored 3 is almost certainly going to be an Xbox console exclusive with a PC port. It should also be available as a day one Game Pass title, as all Xbox first party titles are.
Trailers
As mentioned, Dishonored 3 isn't even meant to be known about publicly yet, so no marketing exists for the game. All we have is the name.
Gameplay

Read more