Freemium game developer reveals the dirty truths behind in-app purchases

apple and supercell partner for charity microtransactions clash of clans
Much has been made in recent years about the rise of the so-called “freemium” model sweeping games on mobile platforms, luring users in with free initial downloads and making boatloads of profit through countless, in-app micro-transactions. Despite several high-profile lawsuits forcing Apple and Google to temper the more exploitative elements of the practice, the model is thriving, with apps like Game of WarClash of Clans, and Candy Crush dominating the top-grossing charts. The vast majority of writing on the subject focuses on the consumer perspective, and how the distorted value proposition of these supposedly free games has eroded trust between players and developer.

Less attention has been given to the developers’ side of the equation. A revealing piece on Touch Arcade, written by an anonymous producer of major, free to play games, has pulled back the curtain on the machinery behind these massively profitable games, and the truth is even ickier than most of us have probably realized. Note that while the anonymous authorship of the piece means that its revelations could be taken with a grain of salt, Touch Arcade is a reputable and well-connected news source for the mobile gaming field, giving this story the weight of credibility.

The writer describes him or herself as “a senior producer at a free-to-play games company” that has worked for several major companies. You have almost certainly played or are playing a game that this person produced or worked on in some significant capacity. Originally a console game producer, they joined mobile games in the early days of the iPhone and witnessed the whole evolution that brought us to where we are today.

The most troubling revelation of the story is how much personal data developers skim about their players, and then use to target them for in-app purchases:

“This is about how we can target you, because we (and our partners) know everything about you. We know where you live, we know your income level, we know your relationships, your favorite sports teams, your political preferences. We know when you go to work, and where you work. We can target an event to start for you when we know you have a long weekend coming up. We own you.”

As is so often the case, the road to this dystopian present started innocently enough. In order to balance their games to be as enjoyable and accessible as possible, developers started to track player behavior. At first this just allowed them to do things like adjust the difficulty of particular levels and “balance the game in the wild.” Trouble started when the engineers started to look at not just the in-game data, but also the metadata about when people were playing.

“We know where you live, we know your income level, we know your relationships, your favorite sports teams, your political preferences … We own you.”

“During a meeting about the game, the guy who ran our website brought up some interesting information. He started watching the Web logs and seeing all the connections to the JSON file [which tracked in-game behavior]. Unbeknownst to him (or our team) he was getting us a DAU [daily active users]. For the engineering and production teams, this was just a neat thing to know, a feel good ‘look how many people love our game’ statistic. The CEO saw something else.”

Like sharks to the smell of blood, upper management developed an insatiable hunger for data about when, where, and how users were playing their games. They realized the potential this information held for getting players to buy more things, or convince their friends to play as well. Particular focus was given to the best way to find “whales” — the minority, high-spending users that account for the most profit in freemium games.

“Time passed, Free to Play became a thing. I went from company to company. Each time, every new project became less and less about how we can do cool things, and more about how we can track and target users to get the most whales possible, boost chart position and retain users to shove as many ads on them as possible.”

The widespread adoption of Facebook was the turning point. Like marketers of all kinds, developers mine Facebook’s rich stores of data to build creepily intimate portraits of how you play their games, so you can be targeted with personalized push notifications and store specials optimized to maximize the likelihood that you will spend money. Even if you do not actively use Facebook, your connections reveal a lot about you. As Edward Snowden’s NSA revelations demonstrated, a dangerously complete portrait of a person can be developed just from the metadata of their connections and communications, even without any actual content.

If you are a whale, the stalking goes to an even creepier level. “You spend enough money, we will friend you. Not officially, but with a fake account. Maybe it’s a hot girl who shows too much cleavage? That’s us. We learned as much before friending you, but once you let us in, we have the keys to the kingdom. We will use everything to figure out how to sell to you.” The writer then goes on to describe a particular whale who lived in Saudi Arabia, but loved American football, and how they created virtual items based on his favorite teams to sell just to him.

The same data that was once used to maximize fun is now being used to maximize profitability, with developers going so far as to manipulate gameplay itself. “We will flat out adjust a game to make it behave just like it did last time the person bought IAP. Was a level too hard? Well now they are all that same difficulty.”

If this makes you uncomfortable, then your only recourse is to opt out. Like lunch, there ain’t no such thing as a free game. Vote with your wallet and buy games with an up-front cost, or else publishers will continue to focus on manipulative tactics as the only way to extract profit from games.


From NES to PlayStation, retro gaming is booming. But will it last?

Everyone craves the good old days, and companies like Nintendo and Sony are cashing in with their mini versions of beloved retro consoles. But is this fad built to last or will our fixation with pixelated graphics come and go like mom…

Your PlayStation 4 game library isn't complete without these games

Looking for the best PS4 games out there? Out of the massive crop of titles available, we selected the best you should buy. No matter what your genre of choice may be, there's something here for you.

These are the best Xbox One games available right now

More than four years into its life span, Microsoft's latest console is finally coming into its own. From 'Cuphead' to 'Halo 5,' the best Xbox One games offer something for everyone.

Feeling nostalgic? Here are the 25 best Sega Genesis games

Although the company has since fallen into obscurity, Sega was an indisputable titan throughout the '90s. That said, here are 25 best Sega Genesis games that helped define its fabled decade.

The best free-to-play games you can play right now

Believe it or not, free-to-play games have evolved into engaging, enjoyable experiences. Here are a few of our favorites that you can play right now, including Warframe and the perennially-popular League of Legends.

‘Blockchain gaming’ startup gets $16 million in Series A funding

A gaming startup, Mythical Games, has raised $16 million in Series A funding to work on their concept of blockchain gaming. The aim is for the startup to develop games for the PC, console, and mobile markets.
Emerging Tech

Awesome Tech You Can’t Buy Yet: A.I. selfie drones, ‘invisible’ wireless chargers

Check out our roundup of the best new crowdfunding projects and product announcements that hit the web this week. You may not be able to buy this stuff yet, but it sure is fun to gawk!

‘Fortnite’ named Ultimate Game of the Year at the Golden Joystick awards

This year's Golden Joysticks, the gaming awards handed out by GamesRadar, have been announced and Fortnite has been named the Ultimate Game of the Year. It beat out Red Dead Redemption for best game, but Red Dead was named critics' choice.

Want to gift a Steam game so you can play with a friend? Here's how to do it

The holidays may have passed, but it's always a good time to give the gift of gaming (especially when there's a Steam sale)! Here's our quick guide on how to give a Steam game as a gift.

‘Final Fantasy XIV: Shadowbringers’ to launch next summer with gunblades, Viera

Square Enix revealed that Final Fantasy XIV: Shadowbringers will be released in summer 2019. The third expansion of the MMORPG will include new story content, dungeons, and raids, in addition to gunblades and the Viera.

The Fix PUBG campaign is over: What’s next for ‘PlayerUnknown’s Battlegrounds’?

The PlayerUnknown's Battlegrounds development team declared that the Fix PUBG campaign was over. Here are the results of the three-month campaign, as well as the future plans for the multiplayer Battle Royale shooter.

Cyber Monday 2018: When it takes place and where to find the best deals

Cyber Monday is still a ways off, but it's never too early to start planning ahead. With so many different deals to choose from during one of the biggest shopping holidays of the year, going in with a little know-how makes all the…

Get an Xbox One S or PlayStation 4 for just $200 at GameStop starting Sunday

GameStop is currently running an early Black Friday sale that offers an Xbox One S or a PlayStation 4 slim model for just $200 apiece. Both consoles come with a free game, and other games are also on sale.

Original ‘Diablo’ developer calls out Blizzard for disrespecting its employees

In a Twitch rant, an original creator of Diablo has said that Blizzard is more interested in caring for its shareholders and the elite one percent of the company than looking after its workers.