Skip to main content

Madden creator sues Electronic Arts for unpaid royalties on alleged ‘derivative works’

john-madden-footballThe Madden NFL series is Electronic Arts‘ yearly “old faithful” release, a dependable franchise that each year brings out large numbers of fans looking for the latest rosters and gameplay tweaks for their virtual pigskin gaming. It is also one of the publisher’s oldest franchises, starting in 1988 with John Madden Football.

Robin Antonick, one of the top-level programmers on that game, has filed a lawsuit against EA, alleging that subsequent Madden releases incorporated design ideas from his original work, and thus he is owed almost two decades worth of unpaid royalties. A California District Court filing (via Gamasutra) states that the use of the initial game’s concepts — including 11-player sides, a 3D rendering of the playing field and instant replay features — in future releases entitles Atonick to 1.5 percent of any “derivative works,” per his 1986 contract with the company.

Recommended Videos

EA has maintained the stance that those games in the franchise that were released after John Madden Football didn’t incorporate Antonick’s design ideas. The court document alleges that he was told Park Place Productions, the follow-up game’s developer, was charged with creating more of an arcade-like experience.

Antonick argues that Park Place worked closely with Richard Hilleman, a collaborator on the original John Madden Football and EA’s current chief creative officer. His intimate knowledge of the first game’s code couldn’t help but inform the work he did subsequently with Park Place, the lawsuit contends. EA founder Trip Hawkins and EA executive Bing Gordon are also named, due to their “extensive access to and knowledge of Antonick’s code, design documents and other intellectual property,” all of which were allegedly used during the development of the follow-up release.

The lawsuit also adds additional context in calling out the video game publisher for its general business practices with regards to IP rights. “Electronic Arts’ cavalier treatment of Antonick’s intellectual property and contractual rights is symptomatic of a corporate culture that has long taken a ‘so sue me’ approach to the use of third party intellectual property that it does not own and generally devalues the importance of intellectual property,” the court document reads.

It’s a sticky situation, no question. It seems, from a legal layman’s perspective at any rate, that both sides have a case to make here. This will all ultimately come down to what actually qualifies as a “derivative work” built off of Antonick’s original ideas. There is no question that subsequent games in the series incorporated ideas like instant replay features and a 3D perspective of the playing field, so the judge will be left to decide in the end on whether or not those innovations actually belong to Antonick.

Adam Rosenberg
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Previously, Adam worked in the games press as a freelance writer and critic for a range of outlets, including Digital Trends…
The top 5 best defensive playbooks in Madden 22
Aaron Donald in Madden 22.

With 32 NFL teams and a handful of non-team-specific playbooks, Madden 22 players have plenty of options when it comes to choosing the best defensive playbooks to run. However, the gambit of players runs from the casual football fan to the Bill Belicheck of Madden 22. Your choice of defensive playbook changes based on how defensive-minded you are. Here are the top five Defensive playbooks in Madden 22.

Madden 22: Tips and tricks to up your game
The history of the Madden Curse
Is Madden 22 coming to mobile? Everything we know so far

Read more
The top 5 best offensive playbooks in Madden 22
Lamar Jackson holding the football in Madden.

Madden 22 is all about big plays and big moments. With 32 different teams featuring vastly different offensive playbooks, you'll rarely play the same team twice. Are you a pocket passer like Tom Brady or a scrambling magic-maker like Patrick Mahomes? Maybe you prefer to run the ball up and down the field with Derik Henry or Dalvin Cook. No matter your preference, there's a playbook built for you in Madden 22. Here are the top 5 offensive playbooks in Madden 22.

Madden 22: Tips and tricks to up your game
Baltimore Ravens' new esports initiative includes a Fortnite tournament
How to dive in Madden 22 and why you should

Read more
Madden 22: Tips and tricks to up your game
A wide receiver and defensive back are tangled up in Madden 22.

A new year means a new Madden. With Tom Brady and Patrick Mahomes on the front cover, pocket passers and on-the-run QBs will finally settle the dispute of who's the best in the NFL. Each new Madden tightens a few bolts, changes the UI, and adds new elements to the game that returning players may not be familiar with.

Here are some tips and tricks for Madden 22 that'll take your game to the next level.

Read more