Skip to main content

The Playdate is a better gaming handheld than the Switch

Since its launch in 2017, there has rarely been a time when I leave the house without my Nintendo Switch. The portable console became so fundamental to my routine that I had to adopt a messenger bag into my daily fashion choices so I could carry it. When I got my Steam Deck, I ended up carrying both consoles with me, unwilling to fully put down what had become my digital safety blanket.

So when I say the Playdate finally has me leaving my Switch OLED at home, that’s no small feat. Despite being a niche device with far less games available on it, the bright yellow gaming device is filling certain gaps in my life better than Nintendo’s console. That’s because the Playdate is a better gaming handheld than the Switch.

Portable design

A Playdate and Switch OLED sit side by side on a table.
Image used with permission by copyright holder

I’m choosing my words wisely there. The Nintendo Switch is, without question, the better video game console between the two. The Switch is home to some of the greatest games of all time, whereas the Playdate’s best titles are more toy-like, charming oddities.

Prime Day Focus
These Razer Blade Prime Day deals really pack a punch [in gaming power]
Secretlab Prime Day deals: Build your ideal work-from-home or gaming station
Amazfit Amazon Prime Day deals dropped: Save up to 40% off smartwatches today
Send it! This HoverAir X1 Drone can capture your adventures and it's $120 off

But when I think about what I look for most in a handheld device, the Playdate checks all the boxes in a way that no device has since the Nintendo 3DS. On the most basic level, it’s the most truly portable gaming device I’ve ever owned. At roughly three inches  by three inches and 84 grams, it’s a device so unobtrusive that I could leave it in a pocket and forget it’s there. Whenever I decide to take my Playdate out instead of my Switch, it’s a literal weight off my shoulders.

With the small size comes an ease of use. If I want to break out my Switch while waiting in line at the DMV, I have to take it out of my bag, remove it from its case, and boot it up. If I suddenly need to stop, I have to rush to do that in reverse, hastily tossing my Switch into my bag to put it away at a moment’s notice. The Playdate is more elegant by comparison: I click the top button once to put it to sleep, magnetically dock its crank, and throw it in my pocket.

That ease of use alone has me choosing the Playdate over the Switch in key situations. While I’m still taking my Switch out anytime I have to commute on public transportation more than a half hour, I’m more likely to leave it behind and take the Playdate if I’m traveling a few stops or doing something that’s going to involve a small patch of downtime, like waiting for a friend to arrive at the movies.

And yes, if you must know, it’s the ideal bathroom companion too. Happy?

Thinking small

A gamer holds a Playdate in their hands.
Image used with permission by copyright holder

It’s not just the size that makes the Playdate a great handheld though: It’s the games. Because the system has so many technical limitations, developers are forced to design small. Even the longest games on the consoles only take an hour or two to complete. That means that the Playdate’s initial season 1 library is filled with micro-games that can be played in a few minutes.

Omaze, for instance, is a tiny maze navigation game where players move a ball through a series of circles using the system’s crank. Even its trickiest levels only take a few minutes of trial and error to complete, making it a great fit for those awkward moments where you’d usually pass the time aimlessly doom scrolling through social feeds.

I’ve been sorely missing that kind of game design in recent years. While the Switch’s best games can work both for long sit-downs or in small chunks, I’ve found myself nostalgic for Game Boy titles that were built with short play sessions in mind. I usually have to gamble with mobile games to recreate that experience, which can be a minefield due to microtransactions. The Playdate’s best games call back to the portable era with high score-focused arcade games where rounds last just a few minutes, but the hooks are so strong that you feel compelled to play over and over.

A gamer plays Spellcorked on the Playdate.
Image used with permission by copyright holder

All of the Playdate’s strengths came together for me recently when I went to get a haircut. I can walk to my barbershop, but there’s always that awkward 10-minute wait where I find myself looking for a way to kill time. Instead of bringing my Switch, I slipped my Playdate into my jacket’s chest pocket. When I got there, I fired up Hyper Meteor, a crank-controlled version of Asteroids, and did three quick rounds over the course of 10 minutes. When my barber called me to the chair, I turned it off and dropped it in my pants pocket without missing a beat.

While the Playdate’s a bit of a one-off gimmick, I find myself wishing there was more space for small-scale gaming tech like it. My phone fills that gap, but I’ve discovered that I sincerely enjoy carrying around a dedicated gaming device that’s built around bite-sized play. There are still spaces in my life where I want to play a low-stakes arcade game for two minutes with as little fuss as possible. The Playdate is the perfect device for that, and you can bet that if I show up to your wedding this summer, it’ll be hiding in my handkerchief pocket.

Topics
Giovanni Colantonio
Giovanni is a writer and video producer focusing on happenings in the video game industry. He has contributed stories to…
You can only play one of 2024’s best games on a tiny, 1-bit screen
An alien comes up to the door's window in Mars After Midnight.

It's only March and 2024 is already full of bold, big-budget games like Prince of Persia: The Lost Crown, Final Fantasy VII Rebirth, Like a Dragon: Infinite Wealth, and Dragon's Dogma 2. But one of my favorite games of 2024 isn't available on PC, PlayStation 5, Xbox Series X, or even Nintendo Switch. It's Mars After Midnight, a game from Papers, Please and Return of the Obra Dinn developer Lucas Pope. The only place you can play it? On the Playdate, Panic's quirky little 1-bit handheld with a crank.

Mars After Midnight is a more lighthearted game than Pope's previous work. It follows an alien who dreams of coming to Earth and works to achieve that goal with his robot companion by moderating and serving as the bouncer for community events each night on Mars. Using the Playdate's limited buttons and a crank, players must vet every alien creature that comes up to the door before deciding whether or not to let them in while also cleaning up after the aliens who eat the offered refreshments.

Read more
If you’re looking for a great new Switch game, you’ll dig Pepper Grinder
A giant beetle stands in Pepper Grinder.

Look, it’s been a busy time for video game enthusiasts. Rather than easing out of a busy holiday season, the first three months of 2024 have been filled with enormous, high-profile RPGs that can eat up an upwards of 60 hours each. I’m tired. You’re tired. Don’t you just want to play something short and sweet at this point?

If the answer to that question is “yes,” then you’re in luck. Pepper Grinder, the latest release from publisher Devolver Digital, is out today and it's the perfect change of pace for anyone exhausted from playing long RPGs for months. And it helps that it’s a fun little platformer with a unique hook, too. Actually, “hook” isn’t exactly the right word here. I should say “drill.”

Read more
World of Goo 2 might just be the Nintendo Switch’s next must-own co-op game
A built structure in World of Goo 2.

When I sat down to demo World of Goo 2 at this year’s GDC, I noted to the developers on hand how surprising it was to see a sequel after so long. “It’s been, what? Ten years?” I said. I was very far off the mark: They noted that the original World of Goo launched in 2008. After playing a few levels (and having an existential crisis over time’s rapid passing), I’d find myself wondering how such an obvious slam dunk didn’t come sooner.

Like its predecessor, World of Goo 2 is a physics-based puzzle game where players craft structures from little, gooey critters. It presents a series of engineering challenges, as poorly built structures will topple under the weight of all those jiggly little pals. Rather than reinventing that concept entirely, World of Goo 2 adds some wild new ideas onto that stable structure that opens up its puzzle potential. The result is a chaotic co-op game that’s a perfect fit for the Nintendo Switch.

Read more