Skip to main content

Is a Super Smash Bros. Ultimate sequel even possible?

With Sora’s addition to Super Smash Bros. Ultimate, Masahiro Sakurai, the creative force behind the game, can finally rest. The work is done, the game is finally finished, there’s no more content coming out for it. So, just as any properly adjusted, societally acceptable Smash fan would do, I have to ask one question: “Well, what about the next Smash game?”

Super Smash Bros. Ultimate – Battling with Sora - Nintendo Switch

Except, looking at Super Smash Bros. Ultimate, I’m not sure how there can even be another Smash game. Not to get too literal with it, but the franchise’s latest entry might be, without exaggeration, the textbook definition of ultimate for Smash. It’s the one to top all others, the grand finale, the be-all and end-all. At this point, I’m not sure when or if Nintendo can put together a Smash game that matches Super Smash Bros. Ultimate‘s scale.

Too much video game

Simply put, iterating upon Super Smash Bros. Ultimate would be an enormous task. The game, with its 89 characters, 116 stages, and over 1,000 songs, is simply massive, and for a proper sequel, every bit of that content would have to be included. Assuming that a new Smash game would release on Nintendo’s next console, Nintendo’s developers would have to rework textures and animations for every single playable character in the game.

If that weren’t enough, there’s also the issue of how the game actually plays. No two Smash games are the same; each has its own specific mechanics. Melee has wavedashing, Brawl has tripping, and Ultimate has rage. Another Smash game would theoretically include reworks to every single character, as well as an overhaul of most of the game’s mechanics. This is a massive undertaking that seems almost impossible without years upon years of work.

Super Smash Bros. Ultimate‘s size is one of its best features. There’s so much content in the game — so many fighters, stages, items, etc. — that it’s a challenge to run out of things to do. In that way, it’s a perfect party game. However, its size is a double-edged sword. Ultimate, and Smash as a franchise, are weighed down by how much is stuffed into it. Another Smash game won’t be a proper sequel unless it manages to overcome a gargantuan task: Exceeding Ultimate‘s scale. Imagine the reaction if its sequel cut the roster in half rather than took it over 100.

Mario from Super Smash Bros. Ultimate.
Image used with permission by copyright holder

It’s called ‘ultimate’ for a reason

And of course, that’s all before the next hypothetical Smash game would even launch. Before the public would see any of the game, Nintendo would have to figure out how to make it look better, play a different way, and include some additional content. Without any of those traits, fans of the franchise would simply call the game a port and head back to Ultimate. Once the (again, hypothetical) game actually releases, it would go through the same support cycle as Ultimate, with DLC characters being announced and added, creating even more content to stuff into the Smash franchise.

In this way, the Smash Bros. games are sort of an infernal machine, constantly growing themselves and eventually becoming unsustainable for Nintendo. The question isn’t if a Smash game will get too big to properly iterate upon, it’s a matter of when — and I believe we’re already there.

To be perfectly honest, I don’t have a problem with that. Super Smash Bros. Ultimate is perfectly self-titled. It’s the ultimate Smash game, even from my point of view as a die-hard Melee fan. It’s packed with so many characters that anyone playing the game for the first time could easily recognize one and get a favorite, and it’s easy to pick up, but difficult to master. At some point, someone at Nintendo has to ask: “What’s left to improve?” And at this point, I’m not sure if there’s an answer to that.

Editors' Recommendations

Otto Kratky
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Otto Kratky is a freelance writer with many homes. You can find his work at Digital Trends, GameSpot, and Gamepur. If he's…
Our 10 favorite Wonder Effects in Super Mario Bros. Wonder
Wonder Flower in Super Mario Bros. Wonder.

Super Mario Bros. Wonder's defining gimmick is its series of Wonder Effects. A Wonder Flower is hidden somewhere on almost every level and, once found, radically switches up what is going on within that stage. Some expand on ideas the stage was already exploring, while others are wildly unpredictable, giving players something they were not expecting at all.

There are over 69 stages with Wonder Effects that players can see while playing through the story of Super Mario Bros. Wonder, but 10 of those Wonder Effects effects stood out the most during my playthrough. By order of appearance, these are my 10 favorite Wonder Effects in Super Mario Bros. Wonder, which showcase just how inventive and unpredictable the platformer is.
Piranha Plants on Parade
Super Mario Bros Wonder – Piranha Plants on Parade - 100% All Wonder Seeds, Flower Coins & Flag

Read more
It’s Super Mario Bros. Wonder’s subtle changes that make it special
The flagpole is knocked away in Super Mario Bros. Wonder

While I’m only partway through Super Mario Bros. Wonder, I’m already utterly in love with the game.

As our glowing review outlined, it’s a highly polished 2D platformer that’s approachable for anyone to play and elicits a joyous and vibrant sense of wonder. But for me, what makes Super Mario Bros. Wonder special aren't so much the wild Wonder effects or elephant transformations. It's the subtle touches. These elements might not be immediately noticeable or relevant to most, but they all work together to create an experience that’s a step above most other platformers.
Changes enhance enjoyment
Super Mario Bros. Wonder isn’t afraid to show that it’s different from previous Mario games through small moments and changes. One instance that illustrates this early on is in one of the first Bowser Jr. fights. It starts like all his New Super Mario Bros. boss fights do, with him getting in his shell and spinning toward Mario. At first, I was disappointed that Nintendo was just doing the same thing again, but after the first hit, that changed. Bowser Jr. activates a Wonder effect and changes in size for the following two stages of his fight. It's a moment of surprise that subverts my expectations, which are based on decades of Mario games. This is a small moment and reference that many Super Mario Bros. Wonder players probably won’t even internalize. Still, it is a smart way to show how the platformer differs from what came before.

Read more
Super Mario Bros. Wonder has some of Nintendo’s best online features
Wiggler in Super Mario Bros. Wonder

When it comes to multiplayer integration, Nintendo can be wildly unpredictable. Unstable online servers and disappointing co-op experiences built for young players can leave its games lacking. Thankfully, that's not the case with Super Mario Bros. Wonder. In fact, the new 2D adventure might just contain the best Nintendo multiplayer experience on the Switch next to Mario Kart 8 Deluxe or Super Smash Bros. Ultimate.

At any point while playing Super Mario Bros. Wonder, players can bring their game online with the press of a button in the main menu. Doing so will unlock several multiplayer features at once. For one, there's traditional online multiplayer. Simply press a button to "play with friends" and you'll be able to explore both the overworld and levels co-operatively. Like the New Super Mario Bros. series, four players can work together to complete levels (which can be very hectic fun).

Read more