Will OnLive Kill the Gaming Rig?


When OnLive first grabbed a soapbox at last year’s Game Developer’s Conference and told the world it would bring high-end gaming performance to even the most meagerly equipped PCs, Nvidia execs must have seen their jobs flash before their eyes.

Or maybe chuckled to themselves.

onlive-welcomeAs promising as the company’s remote rendering technology seems now that it has passed further into development, I still see no foreseeable future where neon-lit, heat belching gaming rigs will fade into obscurity. But within a few years, the more accessible casual and console segments of the gaming markets might need to make room for the newcomer. Here’s why.

With the beta well under way, the pitfalls that critics initially predicted for OnLive outside of controlled demos have finally bubbled to the surface in the real world. As PC Perspective’s Ryan Shrout reported when he got a crack at the closed OnLive beta, playing a game on a computer thousands of miles away or on your own computer just don’t feel the same. Mouse and keyboard lag are too apparent in first-person shooters like Unreal Tournament 3 to have an enjoyable gaming experience, and graphics clearly suffer from all the compression used to pass them back from the render farms. For a crowd of gamers who scoff at even the almost-imperceptible delay from a wireless mouse, and spend hundreds on hardware to increase detail on the reflection in a pool of alien blood, neither will fly.

Even if OnLive can somehow work out the kinks – a dubious assumption, considering bandwidth woes mostly lie outside their control – most hardcore PC gamers will never want to give up control of the game experience to an inaccessible server. A cloud gaming experience means no more mods, cheats, hacks, or even playing when the Internet is dead.

Right now, the client can’t even work on Wi-Fi or handle Intel Atom processors with Nvidia Ion graphics, so kiss any thought of playing Crysis Warhead on your netbook at the airport goodbye.

onlive-console-controllerThe good news: Shrout reports that less control-sensitive games like Burnout Paradise and Tom Clancy’s H.A.W.X. played passably, and using a Xbox controller further insulated him from the perception of lag. That makes OnLive sound like a great next-generation platform for casual gaming. No more simple 2D Bejeweled Twist at work – OnLive will let you fire up full 3D games that would never run on your dust-choked Vostro. And Mom could still dabble with The Sims 3 on her Emachine.

That means the console market OnLive will target with its standalone box still looks viable, even as the technology’s shortcomings have been laid bare. Xbox 360, PlayStation 3 and Wii owners are all already accustomed to wireless controller delay and clumsy analog controls which help mask other lag, can’t modify their games, and play games from a distance on big-screen displays that help to mask compression artifacts and other nitpicky visual details.

High-end PC hardware companies can breathe easy, but Microsoft, Sony and Nintendo might want to watch their backs.

The views expressed here are solely those of the author and do not reflect the beliefs of Digital Trends.


3DMark’s Port Royal lets you benchmark ray tracing on Nvidia’s RTX cards

UL is adding another benchmarking utility to its popular 3DMark suite to help gamers measure their graphics card's ray tracing performance. You'll soon be able to measure how Nvidia's RTX 2070, 2080, and 2080 Ti stack up.

The Super NES Classic is the perfect holiday gift for Nintendo lovers

Whether you're a long-time Nintendo fan looking to relive the 16-bit glory days or just doing some holiday shopping, the SNES Classic -- now in stock at multiple retailers for $80 -- might just be the perfect Christmas gift for gamers of…

How do Nintendo Switch, Xbox One X compare to each other? We find out

The Nintendo Switch is innovative enough to stand apart from traditional consoles, but could it become your primary gaming system? How does the Switch stack up against the Xbox One?

Xbox One S vs. PlayStation 4 Slim: Which console is worth your money?

Microsoft's new Xbox One S and Sony's PlayStation 4 "Slim" have bucked the generational gaming console trend. But which of these stopgap systems is worth spending your paycheck on?

Trash at 'Super Smash Bros. Ultimate'? Use this guide to train up and get good

Super Smash Bros. Ultimate is the biggest game in the entire series, and it can be overwhelming for newcomers not used to the universe-colliding fighting game. Here's what you need to know when you're starting.

Where we droppin’ (presents)? Perfect ‘Fortnite’ gifts for the fans in your life

Chances are someone on your holiday shopping list is a fan of Fortnite. As the most popular game on the planet, there are plenty of Fortnite-themed gift options available for purchase in stores and online. Here are the best ones we found.

Sega Genesis classics now playable on Amazon Fire TV, no retro console required

Sega released the SEGA Classics app for Amazon Fire TV devices, allowing gamers to play Sega Genesis classics without having to buy a retro console. The $15 app contains 25 games, including three remastered Sonic titles.

Have a spooky dance party at an abandoned mansion with Fortnite's new challenges

The Fortnite season 7, week 2 challenges have arrived in Battle Royale. From searching for chests to dancing off at an abandoned mansion, here's how to do them and the rewards you get for completing them.

Turn your Raspberry Pi into a Steam streaming hub with Valve’s Steam Link app

Valve's Steam Link app is now fully supported by Raspberry PI hardware, meaning that just about anyone with a few dollars to spare can build their own Steam streaming box in a matter of minutes.

Nintendo pulls the plug on making more SNES Classic, NES Classic systems

Nintendo extended production of the NES Classic and SNES Classic into 2018, but once the current supply of consoles is gone, the company won't be making more. Instead, you'll have to use Nintendo Switch Online.

Fancy ‘Kingdom Hearts III’ PlayStation 4 Pro launches alongside game in January

A limited edition PlayStation 4 Pro bundle for Kingdom Hearts III will launch alongside the game in January. The system included has a special design on the side, as does the controller.

Want to share your Xbox One games? Here's how to do it

Sharing games on modern consoles is possible, but it takes a few steps. Here's how to start sharing games on your Xbox One console, so friends and family can easily access your library.

Here's where Xur is and what he has for wares this week in 'Destiny 2: Forsaken'

The weekly vendor in Destiny 2: Forsaken always brings Exotic weapons and armor, some of the toughest loot to find in the game. Here's everything you need to know to track down Xur: Where he is, when he shows up, and what he's stocking.

‘Fortnite’ removes the Infinity Blade weapon after player backlash

Following player backlash over the Infinity Blade weapon's inclusion in Fortnite's battle royale mode, Epic Games decided to remove the weapon from the game completely. It was not limited to a special mode.