Study: Robot surgeons as good as humans, despite what your doc might say

Kidney transplant waiting list dialysis surgery
A robotic surgeon bested its human counterpart by stitching up a pig’s intestine just a few months ago. Although human supervisors occasionally gave the robot a hand, the medical and robotic breakthrough seemed to herald an era in which human surgeons played a secondary role to machines.

But new researcher on robotic surgery for prostate cancer suggests that, despite the oft-perceived benefit having a robot-assisted operation, humans and machines are pretty much equal when it comes to a patient’s recovery months after surgery.

Robot-assisted prostatectomy allows a surgeon to operate robotic arms remotely from a console. This method has been used for the past 16 years and is now often recommended by practitioners, who suggest it provides better outcomes for patients.

The traditional method is an open surgery, in which the patient’s prostate is removed through an incision in the lower abdomen. To this day, advocates of the traditional method highlight the lack of strong evidence for the robotic method, according to the study’s authors. Nonetheless, robot-assisted prostatectomies continue to grow in popularity around the world.

To test the results of the competing methods, Gardiner and his team examined over 300 Australian men who had either traditional or robotic prostate surgery for three months following operation. They examined the control of cancer, sexual function, bowel function, urinary continence, and time spent away from work, finding no significant difference between either group.

“Contrary to common clinical belief, our research found no significant statistical differences between the robotic approach and open surgery at this early time-point,” the University of Queensland’s Center for Clinical Research’s Professor Robert “Frank” Gardiner said in a news release.

“Surgery has long been the dominant approach for the treatment of localized prostate cancer, with many clinicians now recommending the robotic method to patients,” Gardiner said. “Many clinicians claim the benefits of robotic technology lead to improved quality of life and oncological outcomes — but our randomized clinical trial has found no statistical difference between the two groups at 12 weeks follow-up.”

This study doesn’t mean mechanical surgeons like the Da Vinci surgical system will soon be out of a job, but it does highlight the importance of high-quality evidence in support of a new technology, particularly if that technology is high-cost and quickly adopted within the industry.

Gardiner and his team will continue their study, testing quality of life in patients for the years following their procedure. Until then, he said, “We encourage patients to consider all their treatment options and choose an experienced surgeon rather than choose a specific surgical approach.”

Emerging Tech

Behind the unsettling sci-fi landscapes of Simon Stalenhag’s ‘Electric State’

The narrative artbook follows the journey of a young traveler, Michelle, and her robot, Skip, as they head west to the Pacific coast through an alternative America torn apart by civil war and the trappings of military-grade virtual reality.
Smart Home

If you're not sipping beer while a robot mows your lawn, you're doing it wrong

Imagine watching your lawn being mowed by a robot while you sit on the porch drinking a beer. That’s life with Husqvarna’s line of electric Automowers, which takes the gas and the manpower out of one dreaded aspect of yard work.
Smart Home

Vector, the engaging Alexa-like robot, is ready to roam around your home

Anyone who has ever watched Short Circuit or WALL-E has surely dreamed about having a robot buddy come live with them. Finally, that dream is now a reality. It's name is Vector, and it's available now.
Emerging Tech

Drop everything and watch Boston Dynamics’ robo-dog dance to ‘Uptown Funk’

After a few years of Earthbound training, Boston Dynamics’ SpotMini robot dog is ready to take on Mars. Bruno Mars, to be precise. Check out Skynet's future pet as you've never seen it before.
Product Review

Garmin's Fenix 5X Plus is built for fitness freaks who fawn over every feature

With onboard music, full-color topographic maps, and new sport metrics, the Garmin Fenix 5X Plus sets a high bar for GPS smartwatches. Find out how it can help boost your performance in our Fenix 5X Plus review.
Outdoors

These zip-on bike tires change up your tread to match the terrain

Retyre gives cyclists the ability to change the tread on their bike tires simply by zipping on an overlay designed to provide better grip on trails or in the snow, without replacing the existing tires.
Product Review

Withings Steel HR Sport is a fitness tracker you’ll love wearing

Withings jumps back in the wearables game with the new Steel HR Sport, a hybrid smartwatch that is as much a fitness tracker as it is a timepiece. It's so good that it hasn't left our wrist since we pulled it out of the package.
Emerging Tech

Forget laxatives — this electronic pill will literally shake the crap out of you

Are you suffering from constipation? What you really need is a vibrating smart pill that promises to shake the crap out of you. And we mean that completely literally. Here's how it works.
Deals

The best sound machines to help you fall (and stay) asleep

Whether you find that sleep better with white noise, rain sounds, or deep sleep music, there’s a sound machine on the market that will be able to help you catch more z’s in no time at all.
Wearables

Our favorite fitness trackers make it fun to keep moving

Looking for your first fitness tracker, or an upgrade to the one you're already wearing? There are plenty of the wrist-worn gadgets available. Here are our picks for the best fitness trackers available right now.
Outdoors

The Wau stands out in the crowded ebike market with its 60-mile range

The Wau ebike is a high-tech commuter that offers onboard GPS tracking, geofenced alarm systems, built-in front and rear lights, and pedal-assist speeds of up to 20 mph, with a range of as much as 60 miles between charges.
Emerging Tech

With VR dinosaurs and ‘Minecraft,’ one hospital is making medicine less scary

From augmented reality rabbits on the wards to a Minecraft recreation of the hospital for kids to explore, one of the world's most renowned children's hospitals just got a major tech overhaul.
Emerging Tech

Awesome Tech You Can’t Buy Yet: DIY smartphones and zip-on bike tires

Check out our roundup of the best new crowdfunding projects and product announcements that hit the web this week. You may not be able to buy this stuff yet, but it sure is fun to gawk!
Emerging Tech

Here’s all the best gear and gadgetry you can snag for $100 or less

A $100 bill can get you further than you might think -- so long as you know where to look. Check out our picks for the best tech under $100, whether you're in the market for headphones or a virtual-reality headset.