Skip to main content

Does HBO Max think you’re dumb?

You can’t swing a dead cat in the entertainment space these days without running into a headline about how the newly combined Warner Bros. Discovery — which owns HBO Max — has canceled a show that was in the planning stages. Or already was in production. Or had finished production but now will never see the light of day. Or canceled any future episodes or seasons of a strong show. Or left another in limbo. Or killed a weekly news show that was more important than not. Or unceremoniously removed hundreds of episodes from literally the most important children’s series in the history of television.

Fine. That’s business. The newly combined Warner Bros. Discovery reportedly is trying to shave a mere $3 billion off the balance sheet, and cuts of content and people were always going to happen.

Recommended Videos

But you don’t have to be a math major to look at the recent promotions coming from HBO Max before you scratch your head a little. Nor does it take graduate-level courses to reach the following question: Does HBO Max think you’re dumb?

HBO Max discount
Phil Nickinson/Digital Trends

It’s hard to reconcile the bloodletting at HBO Max — again, both in things to watch and the people who make those things — with the act of desperation you’ll find in your inbox and atop the HBO Max homepage. HBO Max is offering a pretty steep discount when you pre-pay for a year. And who among us wouldn’t be tempted by the cry to “save over 40%” on the first year of service? (After that, things bump back up from $105 without ads to $150, or from $70 to $100 if you don’t mind advertising.)

It’s one thing to save some money with annual subscriptions. I’d actually argue against that in the current age of streaming unless you’re 100% sure that you’re going to get your money’s worth month after month. But that requires a commitment not just on your part, but on the content provider’s part as well.

Take, for instance, the fourth season of Westworld, which just wrapped up. It did so in a way that absolutely could set up a fifth (and almost certainly final) season. Or it could simply fade away, like a host who’s lost its pearl. Snowpiercer will end after its fourth season. Original animation is all but dead.

And that’s just barely scraping the surface of all the cuts HBO Max has made public so far — certainly there are others we don’t even know about.

Then you have to consider the fact that the 2020/2021 strategy of pushing major movies to HBO Max ahead of (or instead of) a theatrical release is done and gone. It’s back to the usual moneymaking scheme of theater first, then digital (rent or buy), and then streaming (watch whenever). That’s three ways to bring in money. And from the standpoint of Warner Bros. Discovery, it makes sense. But from the POV of someone who just wants to watch a thing sooner rather than later, it hurts a little.

Lest anyone think I’m being unfair to poor, poor HBO Max, which has absolutely been through a lot lately, it’s worth noting that the 40%-off promotion comes right as the Game of Thrones prequel House of the Dragon premieres. So it makes complete sense, from a marketing standpoint, to get more people in.

On the other hand, the premiere once again proved that the existing HBO Max infrastructure isn’t up to the task. And now they’re asking you to pay for a year in advance, while we’re still a year out from the launch of the combined HBO Max/Discovery service?

That’s a tough pill to swallow in what has been a series of hiccups, gurgles, burps, and outright expulsion of the brand equity that HBO used to have.

Phil Nickinson
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Phil spent the 2000s making newspapers with the Pensacola (Fla.) News Journal, the 2010s with Android Central and then the…
3 action movies on Max you need to watch in November
Two women battle in Lady Snowblood.

Max has one of the deepest libraries of any streaming service out there, but that doesn't mean it's easy to find what you want to watch. In fact, because there's so much interesting stuff, it can actually make picking any one thing more difficult.

We've decided to do some of the hard work for you by picking three great action movies that are worth checking out this month. These action movies represent a wide swath of what action cinema can be, and each of them is worth watching for very different reasons. We hope you'll see all three, but at the very least, you can certainly find time for one.

Read more
After The Penguin, this iconic Batman villain should get their own HBO show
The Penguin burns something in The Penguin.

HBO's new hit series The Penguin may have seemed like an odd choice for a comic book series at first. But following the show's extraordinary success as a thrilling crime drama in Gotham City, it is clear that Matt Revees' The Batman has laid the foundation for even more successful spinoffs set in the world of Robert Pattinson's Dark Knight. There are already reports that Barry Keoghan's Joker will get his own spinoff show set between The Batman Part II and Part III. (These reports have since been debunked by James Gunn himself.)

The Batman gave a terrific introduction to Colin Farrell's villainous character, who was expanded in The Penguin along with the fabled Falcone/Maroni crime war referenced in the former. It's clear DC has only scratched the surface of its new vision of Gotham and that there are other stories just waiting to be told on HBO. For many reasons, the best next option is a solo series centered around Zoë Kravitz's Selina Kyle/Catwoman.
Catwoman started out strong in The Batman

Read more
2024’s most divisive thriller is finally streaming on Max. Here’s why you should watch it
A man is being tortured in Trap.

M. Night Shyamalan is one of the most divisive filmmakers of the past 30 years. After achieving breakout success in the late '90s and early 2000s with acclaimed thrillers like The Sixth Sense, Unbreakable, and Signs, his reputation began to sour following the releases of largely critical failures like The Village, Lady in the Water, and The Happening. In recent years, Shyamalan has experienced a late-career resurgence writing and directing modestly budgeted, high-concept thrillers (see: Split, Old, Knock at the Cabin). He remains, however, one of Hollywood's most polarizing directors.

You need look no further than the reception to his latest film, Trap, for proof of that. The serial killer thriller was both embraced and tossed aside in equal measure when it hit theaters in early August. Some were quick to share their praise for the film's technical craftsmanship and perfectly pitched lead performance, while others dismissed it based on Shyamalan's consistently stiff dialogue and its absurdly twisty third act. Now, several months later, Trap is officially streaming on Max.

Read more