Weird home security camera mix-up streams video to wrong person

swann smart security camera review facing right
Terry Walsh/Digital Trends

A security slip-up with a home security camera sounds absurd, to say the least, but occasional reports of such happenings suggest the matter needs to be taken extremely seriously when it occurs.

An odd story out of the U.K. this week explains how a woman with such a camera started receiving live footage to her smartphone. But it wasn’t from her camera.

Instead of showing the interior of her home, the woman, Louisa Lewis, found herself looking at a family she didn’t know, in a kitchen she didn’t recognize. The voice of a child could also be heard off-camera, the BBC reported.

Lewis owns the Swann Smart Security Camera, a compact, wireless device for both indoor and outdoor use.

She said she’d been using the camera since last year and had had no issues with it until last weekend. According to Lewis, she was out of her home when she received an alert from the camera to her phone, suggesting the device’s motion sensor had been triggered.

She immediately realized the footage streaming to her phone wasn’t of her home and instead showed what appeared to be a family in their kitchen. She assumed it was a technical error and thought she could ignore it. But then several more alerts came through showing video of the same location.

Lewis contacted Swann to explain what was happening, but the company reportedly took two days before the erroneous streams were stopped.

Swann: ‘Human error’

A Swann spokeswoman told the BBC the issue was caused because two cameras had been made with the same “bank-grade security key, which secures all communications with its owner,” something the spokeswoman put down to “human error.”

She said it happened “after the [family] connected the duplicate camera to their network and ignored the warning prompt that notified: ‘Camera is already paired to an account,’ and left the camera running.”

The spokeswoman expressed regret that the matter hadn’t been dealt with more quickly, and said changes had been made for any future cases.

But most concerning of all, Swann said it was yet to identify the family so it could inform them of what had happened.

Swann has been in the business of security monitoring for 30 years and now runs a global operation. Its website features a large range of security systems alongside a slogan that says “Security made smarter.”

The company called the incident a “one-off,” but the BBC’s report notes a similar episode just last month when another owner of a Swann camera received footage from a pub that happened to be a short drive away. The recipient of the video told the pub owner about what had happened. Swann put the error down to both users registering their products with identical usernames and passwords, though the report claimed this not to be the case.

While we’ve heard in the past of smart monitoring devices being hacked, incidents where the feed simply turns up on the wrong device seem rare.

Swann told Digital Trends it’s been in contact with the affected customers “to sincerely apologize for the recording error that took place when using our security cameras. We acknowledge and regret the concern and inconvenience caused to all parties involved.”

It added: “We take the security and privacy of our customers very seriously and are taking corrective action while investigating this issue further as our highest priority.”

Updated on 29 July: Added statement from Swann.

Product Review

Stop stringing cords and replacing batteries with Ring's Spotlight Cam Solar

We like outdoor wireless cameras but dread the low-battery warning that inevitably comes with them. We tested the Ring Spotlight Cam Solar to see if it was the answer to our dead-battery prayers.

An iPhone survived 48 hours in the ocean and retained most of its battery

An iPhone 7 went for a dive, and lived a full 2 days to tell the tale. In what may be the most impressive story about a waterproof case ever, a scuba diver found a very rare form of marine memorabilia when she saw an odd light.

If you're looking for a good laugh, here are more than 60 questions to ask Siri

Siri has come a long way since her first appearance on the iPhone 4S in 2011. We know she can make appointments and give directions, did you know she can make you laugh too? If you want proof, here are lots of funny questions to ask Siri.
Product Review

Ring’s Video Doorbell Pro goes on a diet, but doubles the resolution

Porch pirates will think twice when faced with Ring’s Video Doorbell Pro. Packing top tier features into a slim design, the Doorbell Pro is at home beside any front door.
Product Review

Knock, knock. Who's there? The Ring video doorbell shows you on your phone

Along with the door itself, the doorbell is one of the first items most visitors will interact with when entering your home. The Ring Video Doorbell can show you who's at the door, whether they've actually rung the doorbell or not.

Visual snapshots on Google Assistant provides your day at a glance

Google's artificially intelligent bot, Google Assistant, is available on smart home speakers, smart home devices, iOS and Android phones, and it can do a whole lot of work on your behalf. Here are all of its features.

Win a Blink camera home security starter set and protect your turf

If you want to protect your home from burglars or keep an eye on your pets, IP cams are the way to do it. We've teamed up with Blink to give one reader a Blink indoor camera starter set totally free.
Movies & TV

Here are our predictions for the 2018 Emmy Awards

Here's a look at all of the nominees in the top categories for the 70th annual Emmy Awards, as well as our predictions for which actors and series will take home the golden statue in each.
Movies & TV

The best movies on Netflix in July 2018, from ‘Coco’ to ‘Jurassic Park’

Save yourself from hours wasted scrolling through Netflix's massive library by checking out our picks for the streamer's best movies available right now, whether you're into explosive action, subdued humor, or anything in between.

Alexa for PC invades your notebook, signs a truce with Cortana

We took a look at Alexa for PC running on the first notebook to ship with Amazon's digital assistant pre-installed, the Acer Spin 5 convertible 2-in-1. Does she add value to the Windows 10 platform?
Movies & TV

The best shows on Netflix in July, from ‘Arrested Development’ to ‘Mad Men’

Looking for a new show to binge? Lucky for you, we've curated a list of the best shows on Netflix, whether you're a fan of outlandish anime, dramatic period pieces, or shows that leave you questioning what lies beyond.
Smart Home

Watch Kevin Hart ask Alexa if he’s more fit than The Rock

Turns out there are indeed a few things that Amazon Alexa just doesn't know, and one of them is the comparative fitness of Kevin Hart. She was unable to say whether Hart was more in shape than The Rock.

Walmart slashes Google Home prices for Prime Day

Prime Day is a great time to find great deals on Echo devices, but if you use Google for all of your smart home needs, Walmart is offering steep discounts on Google Home, Google Home Mini, and Google Home Max to stay competitive.

Pop-up cams could be the next must-have feature for phone privacy nuts

Phones with pop-up cameras, such as the Vivo Nex and the Oppo Find X, may be exposing nefarious plans to record our activities using the selfie camera. Certain apps are opening the camera at unusual times, prompting security fears.
Movies & TV

A horse, a sword, and hair clips highlight latest 'John Wick 3' set videos

The third installment of the wildly successful action series that stars Keanu Reeves as a deadly assassin forced out of retirement, John Wick 3: Parabellum, hits theaters in May 2019. Here's everything we know about the movie so far.
Smart Home

Allergies acting up? The six best air purifiers on the market can offer relief

Indoor air is often more contaminated than the air outside, which can cause an array of health issues over time. Luckily, these five air purifiers can easily rid your home or office of unwanted allergens and contaminants.
Smart Home

Every parent’s nightmare: A 3-year-old gets trapped in a washing machine

When kids begin expressing interest in helping around the house -- poking around the dishwasher or learning about the laundry -- parents normally rejoice. But that was not the case for one 3-year-old trapped in a washer.
Smart Home

Nest will merge into Google’s home and living room team as CEO steps down

Nests' CEO has stepped down as Marwan Fawaz is reportedly no longer at the helm of the Google-owned smart appliance maker. Nest will now join Google's home and living room products team.

Win the new Square Off Kingdom Set automated smart chess board

The all-new Square Off Kingdom Set "smart" chess board takes this centuries-old game into the 21st century, letting you play against AI or compete with millions of players from all around the world -- and it even moves the pieces for you.
Smart Home

Clean your home for cheap with these awesome Prime Day vacuum deals

Modern technology has made keeping a clean home a little bit easier, and now that tech is getting cheaper too. For Prime Day 2018, Amazon is slashing the prices of many of our favorite vacuums, some of which are of the robot variety.
Smart Home

Wait, there's more! The Instant Pot Ultra 8-quart is also on sale for 33% off

If you're looking for a way to do more cooking without spending more time in the kitchen, Prime Day has a gift for you. It comes in the form of the Instant Pot Duo 60, which is 35 percent off. The Instant Pot Ultra 8 Qt is also on sale.
Smart Home

Samsung’s S9 and S9+ Prime Day bundles include an Echo and an Echo Spot

Samsung's Amazon Prime Day bundles include an Amazon Echo, Echo Spot, and a Samsung SmartThings Home Monitoring Starter Kit for no extra charge with Samsung Galaxy S9 or S9+ smartphones. The bundle savings equals $430.
Emerging Tech

The UN and Yale unite to build a ‘smart’ tiny house for the future

In an effort to create more sustainable and affordable housing for future populations, the United Nations and Yale University recently teamed together and created an environmentally minded tiny house.