Skip to main content

How long does it take for eggnog to go bad? It’s all about the booze

Puerto Rican Christmas Dinner Eggnog
Didriks’s Flickr

Nothing divides a holiday party quite like the serving of eggnog. Some love it, others hate it. Let’s say you make a batch for Christmas, but you inadvertently find yourself in a group of nog loathers. How long can you keep the dairy-laden brew around? It depends on how much booze you added, essentially.

In 2009, we heard a story on Science Friday about Rockefeller University microbiologists Vince Fischetti and Raymond Schuch testing the salmonella levels in eggnog from Dr. Rebecca Lancefield’s recipe, which had been chilling in the fridge since before Thanksgiving. They’d added a bunch of salmonella and tested it at one, two, and three weeks. The longer the eggnog sat, the fewer bacteria there were, until it was completely sterile by week three.

But the aging process does more than kill bacteria: It makes the nog less boozy-tasting. The year after we heard the SciFri episode, we made our own — though we didn’t have the lab equipment to test the bacteria count. We admit we may have tasted a glass or two before the three weeks were up (living dangerously), and we found it to be quite the potent potable. Some of the liquor taste seemed to evaporate by the time Christmas rolled around, but we never made it again. We prefer Mary Meade’s eggnog recipe, which one of our dads has been making since before we were born.

Booze it up

But is Mary’s mellower concoction high-octane enough to kill bacteria that may have been lurking in the eggs? First, our dad only lets his eggnog sit a day or two before serving — which wouldn’t be enough time to do any real damage to the salmonella, the Rockefeller experiment found. No matter what, we’re playing with delicious, delicious fire. But if you want to age your nog and don’t want to use Lancefield’s recipe, Cook’s Illustrated figured out a formula you can adapt to your family’s favorite: Use 1.5 ounces of 80-proof liquor for each egg, and don’t add your dairy until you’re ready to serve. The alcohol by volume is amped up initially to ensure sterilization and then sinks down to around 14 percent once you add the cream.

Meade’s recipe uses one cup of rum, one cup of Grand Marnier, and a half-cup of brandy. That’s 20 ounces of alcohol to six eggs. That means even if your brandy isn’t 80 proof, the recipe more than meets Cook’s Illustrated’s requirements (as long as your Grand Marnier and rum are 80 proof, of course).

The FDA cautions that relying on alcohol is risky and wants you to use pasteurized eggs or cook them beforehand. Safety first of course (salmonella isn’t something you want to mess with), but we will leave you with a link to Michael Ruhlman, who lived to tell the tale after drinking two-year-old eggnog.

Editors' Recommendations

Jenny McGrath
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Jenny McGrath is a senior writer at Digital Trends covering the intersection of tech and the arts and the environment. Before…
Tempur-Pedic Memorial Day sale: Up to 40% off mattresses and more
Tempur-Pedic Adapt mattress on a pedestal with a woman shaking a dog's paw.

Snagged the best Eight Sleep deals to monitor your sleep? Now, check out the Tempur-Pedic Memorial Day sale so you can enjoy a better mattress for less. There’s up to 40% off its mattresses and other items for sale, so this is the perfect time to upgrade your bedroom for less. With so much on sale, the smartest thing to do is tap the button below and check it out for yourself. Alternatively, if you want some guidance, keep reading and we’ll take you through what to know.

What to shop for in the Tempur-Pedic Memorial Day sale
Right now, you can save 30% on the -- one of the company’s most popular mattresses. The Queen size model normally costs $1,999 but right now, you can buy it for $1,399 thereby saving $600 off the usual price. Similar discounts are available on other sizes. The Tempur-Cloud adapts to your weight, shape, and temperature to provide personalized comfort and support. It also minimizes pressure points to prevent tossing and turning at night, while there’s also reduced motion transfer so you won’t disturb your sleep partner. With plenty of layers, there’s breathability and cooling properties here, but also plenty of soft comfort too.

Read more
This Ninja air fryer is $69 for Memorial Day, and it’s selling fast
The Ninja 4QT Air Fryer next to a plate of food.

There's often one thing that can easily take you by surprise when it comes to air fryers — the cost in your head versus the cost in reality. Air fryers ultimately seem cool, but the price can often sail North of what value we'll really be getting out of the device. That is, unless we shop great air fryer deals, like this one we found as part of our Memorial Day deal hunting. Usually a somewhat expensive $89, today you can save $20 and get the Ninja 4QT Air Fryer for a much cooler $69. Check it out by tapping the button below or keep reading for our take and all of the details.

Why you should buy the Ninja 4QT Air Fryer
The Ninja 4QT Air Fryer is a highly-beloved air fryer that (as the not-so-clever model name suggests) holds four quarts of food, or about enough for two pounds of French fries in a single batch. Due to a wide temperature range, you can go beyond air frying to also dehydrate or reheat foods, especially those that should be served crispy but lose that satisfying crunch we crave after a long night in the fridge. For example, using a low fan speed and low temperature setting you can make fresh, liquid-heavy vegetables like zucchini into a healthy crunchy snack.

Read more
Get 15% off this FlexiSpot electronic standing desk at Amazon
A white FlexiSpot Home Office Electric Height Adjustable Desk in an office.

There are lots of benefits to using a standing desk, and if you think you need one, you should check out the standing desk deals that are available today. Here's an attractive option from Amazon -- the Flexispot electronic standing desk for only $238, following a 15% discount on its original price of $280. This is a limited-time offer though, so there's a real risk of missing out on the $42 in savings if you take too long to complete your purchase. If you think this is the standing desk for you, we recommend buying it right now.

Why you should buy the Flexispot electronic standing desk
The Flexispot electronic standing desk can adjust its height to anywhere between 28 inches and 47.6 inches through its motor lift mechanism that you can access through the two-button controller at the corner of the table. It stays pretty quiet as it moves up or down, and you can go through the full range of the standing desk in less than 10 seconds. Moving from a sitting position to a standing position that quickly will make sure that you maximize the benefits of the Flexispot electronic standing desk, including being able to stretch your spine every once in a while over the course of the day.

Read more