Skip to main content

Digital Trends may earn a commission when you buy through links on our site. Why trust us?

I love the Google Pixel 8 Pro — except for one thing

A person holding the Google Pixel 8 Pro.
Google Pixel 8 Pro Andy Boxall / Digital Trends

I really like the Google Pixel 8 Pro, but it does not feel like a $1,000 smartphone. It makes me miss the Pixel 7 Pro and pine to return to the unbelievably high-quality Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra that I left behind little more than a week ago.

However, for now, I’m staying with Google’s latest flagship. And there’s one simple reason why.

Recommended Videos

What should a $1,000 phone feel like?

The Google Pixel 8 Pro and Google Pixel 7 Pro's screens.
Google Pixel 8 Pro (left) and Google Pixel 7 Pro, showing the difference in screen curvature. Andy Boxall / Digital Trends

The Pixel 7 Pro was controversial, as some owners experienced crippling software problems that ruined the phone. But I managed to avoid anything like that, and it was almost completely reliable every time I used it. It meant I could enjoy the super camera, the clean and simple software, and the wonderful design. It still looks excellent, and my model’s white and polished steel look really stands out. It cost $900 when it was released.

But when you pick it up along with the Pixel 8 Pro, which costs $1,000, there is a disappointing difference in in-hand feel, and a lot of this is down to the change from a curved screen to a flat screen. The Pixel 7 Pro has a gentle curve down the sides, with the glass meeting the frame in a way that comfortably suits how we hold a phone with one hand. It minimizes the visual impact of the side bezels, too.

The Google Pixel 8 Pro and Google Pixel 7 Pro's screens.
Google Pixel 8 Pro (left) and Google Pixel 7 Pro, showing the difference in screen curvature Andy Boxall / Digital Trends

This is not the case with the Pixel 8 Pro, which has a flat screen and no contoured flow between it and the frame. It’s not uncomfortable as such, but it’s not very ergonomic, and the bezels around the screen are there for all to see. Curved screens are as controversial as the Pixel 7 Pro’s reliability, with a clear split between those that love them and those that don’t. I think curved screens are more attractive, more ergonomic, and a more pleasing design choice that works to justify the price of a modern smartphone.

The screen problems don’t stop there

The back of the Google Pixel 8 Pro and the Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra.
Google Pixel 8 Pro (left) and Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra Andy Boxall / Digital Trends

But not all flat screens have to come straight out of 2019 like the Pixel 8 Pro’s, and the evidence is right there in the Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra. Although technically flat, the screen still flows into the curved titanium frame, which has been designed to feel great in your hand. It’s a completely different and far superior alternative to full curved glass. It’s also representative of the S24 Ultra’s massive $1,300 price.

The Pixel 8 Pro’s overall design is still great, and while the camera module has a lot more going on than before, it’s still a fancy-looking device. But the flat screen and the disregard for ergonomics is a backward step and very disappointing on a phone that costs $100 more than its predecessor. Samsung shows that adopting a flat screen doesn’t have to come with that one big drawback of reduced comfort, and it has resulted in a phone that is far more modern than you’d expect.

The screen on the Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra and the Google Pixel 8 Pro.
The difference in screen reflection on the Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra (left) and Google Pixel 8 Pro Andy Boxall / Digital Trends

The Pixel’s screen problems don’t end there either, as coming from the big, bright, and reflection-free Galaxy S24 Ultra, the Pixel 8 Pro’s screen isn’t quite as pleasant to use. The S24 Ultra’s Corning Gorilla Armor glass’s anti-reflection properties aren’t marketing nonsense, and it really shows when it’s alongside the Pixel 8 Pro outside.

Brilliant in its simplicity

The back of the Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra, Google Pixel 8 Pro, and Google Pixel 7 Pro.
Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra (left) Google Pixel 8 Pro, and Google Pixel 7 Pro Andy Boxall / Digital Trends

Yet here I am, with the Pixel 8 Pro still in my hand, despite not being that impressed with the design or the screen, especially because I know I can do better. Why am I “suffering” like this?

Once again, I’ve had no software problems with the Pixel 8 Pro — which seems to be a far more reliable phone in general — and appreciate Android 14’s design and efficiency enhancements. But as I mentioned earlier, there’s a simple reason why the Pixel 8 Pro is staying put, and it’s exactly that: simplicity,

The Galaxy S24 Ultra is fantastic, but it’s also absolutely stuffed with features, tools, and distractions. There’s always something to do and try, and to just use the basic features feels almost like a waste. Between the Galaxy AI tools, the S Pen stylus, and the monstrous power, it can sometimes seem like the smartphone equivalent of buying a fully kitted-out Mac Pro only to write shopping lists in Notes. There’s nothing wrong with that, but it’s undeniably overkill.

I don’t feel like that with the Pixel 8 Pro. It does everything I want without argument, and at a very fast speed, and isn’t filled with other features I rarely use. It’s beautifully simple in the best way possible, as the things it does — software, camera, apps, games, and calls — it does extremely well, and I rarely want more.

The biggest problem of all

The Pixel 8's camera module
Google Pixel 8 Andy Boxall / Digital Trends

I’m enjoying the Pixel 8 Pro, provided I ignore the fact it’s a little uncomfortable to hold, and I am in the process of comparing the camera to the Galaxy S24 Ultra to see which one is better. But regardless of how that test turns out, I can’t get the thought that there is another very similar smartphone out there that would likely satisfy me just as much out of my head, and it reinforces the fact the Pixel 8 Pro costs too much money.

It’s the non-Pro Google Pixel 8, which is appropriately priced at $700 yet still has the same processor, IP68 water resistance, selfie camera, software, and update promise, plus its own brilliant main camera. That’s a significant $300 savings, and while the Pixel 8 Pro is clearly the higher specification device, the Pixel 8 is a better value considering the similarities. When I reviewed the Pixel 8, I wondered how much better the Pixel 8 Pro could be, and now I have the answer. It’s better, but I don’t think it’s $300 better.

The further problem for the Pixel 8 Pro is that I think the Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra is $300 better than the Pixel 8 Pro, as it’s jam-packed with features and tech the Pixel doesn’t have. It leaves the Pixel 8 Pro somewhere in the middle, competing with the also-excellent Samsung Galaxy S24 Plus.

But on those days and weeks when I just want a truly brilliant, delightfully simple smartphone with a killer camera and software, the Pixel 8 Pro is hard to beat. It’s just $100 more expensive than it really should be.

Andy Boxall
Andy is a Senior Writer at Digital Trends, where he concentrates on mobile technology, a subject he has written about for…
I found the perfect accessory for carrying my iPhone 16 Pro Max
Waterfield Designs Shinjuku Sling in black being worn by a person.

With Apple wrapping up 2024’s flagship smartphone releases, it’s time to peek into the world of mobile accessories for the iPhone 16 and other smartphones. I’m not talking about another iPhone 16 case or a MagSafe phone grip. No, today, I'm taking a look at a stylish little sling to carry your everyday essentials, even an iPhone 16 Pro Max, around town. Say hello to the Shinjuku Sling from Waterfield Designs.

I’ve been a fan of Waterfield Designs for over a decade now, as I’ve used several of its products, including backpacks, messenger bags, and laptop sleeves. As someone who often carries more than one phone around these days, I’m always looking for gear to help make that a bit easier.

Read more
Goodbye, iPhone 15 Pro Max. Why did I barely know you?
The header image for the OuttaFocus column, showing the iPhone 15 Pro Max.

My year with the iPhone 15 Pro Max is almost up, and as I prepare to send it away as a trade-in for the iPhone 16 Pro Max, I thought I’d gather up my favorite photos taken with the top iPhone, show them off here, and generally sing its praises.

But as I went through my gallery, I was surprised to find that, unlike other years, I hadn’t taken all that many photos with the iPhone. I began to question why and whether that would change with my incoming iPhone 16.
Not many photos?
Apple iPhone 15 Pro Max Andy Boxall / Digital Trends

Read more
Here’s what the inside of the iPhone 16 Pro looks like
A screenshot of the iPhone 16 Pro from iFixit's teardown video.

A bit over a week ago, we covered how the iPhone 16 is a major step forward in terms of repairability. Now, iFixit has posted its teardown video of the iPhone 16 Pro and the Pro Max, giving us a look inside the device and showing how all the components fit together. To quote the video, Apple has "massively simplified" the disassembly process and made it easier to access several vital components. The video is only about 10 minutes long, so give it a watch. The biggest takeaway? Apple has made it more repairable, earning a provisional score of 7/10 from iFixit.

The video shows the redesigned chassis and its back-glass entry, a far less risky alternative than entering the phone through the screen. If you've never done anything like this, it can feel intimidating in the same way that your high school bully (who you're pretty sure was in his early 20s) looming over you felt. There are lots of small components and connectors to keep track of, as well as fragile ribbon cables you need to be careful when removing.

Read more