Skip to main content

Digital Trends may earn a commission when you buy through links on our site. Why trust us?

LG ordered to cough up $3.5 million in patent violations

LG G4
Image used with permission by copyright holder
Soon to release its modular G5 flagship smartphone, LG found itself facing some bad news when it was court-ordered to pay $3.5 million to Core Wireless Licensing, a subsidiary of Conversant Intellectual Property Management.

Core Wireless, which holds patents for 2G, 3G, and 4G LTE network technologies, alleged that LG infringed on its patents that relate to a smartphone’s user interface. The jury not only found the patents to be valid, but sided with Core Wireless, awarding the company $3.5 million in past damages. In addition, Core Wireless will ask United States District Court Judge Rodney Gilstrap to award the company 10 cents for each future sale of the infringing LG products, the majority of which are smartphones.

Recommended Videos

The smartphones in question reportedly include those that run the more recent versions of Android, including Jelly Bean, KitKat, and Lollipop. As such, they include the G2, G3, and G4; LG’s flagship smartphones for 2013, 2014, and 2015, respectively, with the G4 explicitly called out in the lawsuit.

Unsurprisingly, Conversant CEO John Lindgren expressed his content with the verdict, thanking “the court and the jury for their efforts in ensuring that LG compensates Core Wireless for the value of the inventions they are using.”

This isn’t Core Wireless’ first rodeo in the court system when it comes to patents, however. Back in 2012, the company tried to sue Apple for $100 million due to alleged patent infringement. Last March, however, a Texas federal court ruled in favor of Apple, saying that there was no evidence that Apple infringed on any of Core Wireless’ patents.

Related Offer: See Oculus Rift virtual reality headset and desktop Bundles here

Regardless, Core Wireless’ victory juxtaposes nicely with Uniloc’s March 25 loss in court. Uniloc, a company that specializes in “try before you buy” software, consistently sued companies over alleged infringement of a vague patent filed in 1996. The U.S. Patent Office recently invalidated the patent, though Uniloc has the option to appeal the decision.

As for this case, we’re not sure if LG will appeal the decision and have reached out to the company for comment.

Williams Pelegrin
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Williams is an avid New York Yankees fan, speaks Spanish, resides in Colorado, and has an affinity for Frosted Flakes. Send…
I created the perfect iOS 18 Control Center
Someone holding an iPhone 16, showing the Control Center.

Apple's iOS 18 update is a big one. You can tint and change the colors of your app icons, freely place apps/widgets on your home screen, customize your lock screen controls, and more. There's a lot to dig into.

One of the other big features is the ability to fully customize the Control Center, and admittedly, I've largely ignored it since I downloaded the iOS 18 beta months ago. But last Friday after work, I took some time to dive headfirst into the Control Center on my iPhone 16 and completely rearrange it. After about 30 minutes of tinkering with things, I think I created the perfect Control Center setup.
How I set up my Control Center

Read more
OnePlus 13 display and processor specs have leaked. Here’s what’s new
OnePlus 12 in Flowy Emerald held in hand in sunlight.

We expect the OnePlus 13 to debut soon. Until then, further leaks about OnePlus' new flagship device continue to surface, like this latest one from Android Headlines.

According to Thursday's report, the OnePlus 13 will have an 8T LTPO BOE X2 display panel. It will feature a 2K resolution and a 120Hz refresh rate. The new phone is also expected to include an in-display ultrasonic fingerprint sensor.

Read more
Android 16’s Priority Modes leaked, and I need them right now
Someone holding the Google Pixel 9 with the screen on.

On those days when you have a lot of work to do and not nearly enough time to do it, shutting out distractions is vital. Android's Do Not Disturb mode is already tremendously helpful in that respect, but it looks like a better version is coming in Android 16 called Priority modes.

Android Authority's Mishaal Rahman first spotted the change in the Android 15 QPR1 Beta 1. According to Rahman, the Priority Mode feature replaces the Do Not Disturb menu and brings with it UI elements and display settings straight from the Digital Wellbeing feature. He played around with the feature, but was unable to interact with it beyond that.

Read more